The Giants never got to make the call on Jeremiyah Love, but the way things played out may have saved them from a much louder night of second-guessing.
Up until April, Love was widely viewed around the league as the top running back prospect since Saquon Barkley. That made him a real possibility for New York at No. 5, especially with new head coach John Harbaugh trying to build a physical, smash-mouth identity. Even with Cam Skattebo and Tyrone Tracy Jr. already on the roster, the idea was to take the best player available and sort out the rest later.
Then Arizona stepped in at No. 3 and took the player many saw as the next Barkley, knocking the Giants off their original plan and sending them to Ohio State linebacker Arvell Reese instead.
That pick drew plenty of immediate skepticism. Reese had been used mostly as a pass-rusher in college, and New York already had Brian Burns, Abdul Carter, and Kayvon Thibodeaux leading that part of the defense. On draft night, it looked like a crowded fit.
But the early returns are making that reaction look a little too fast.
Arizona offensive coordinator Nathaniel Hackett recently put Love’s early camp work into plain English when he said, "He's definitely a rookie."
That’s a pretty simple four-word reminder of how steep the adjustment can be for even the most hyped running back prospects. And while Love works through that learning curve, Reese has been busy turning the Giants’ pivot into something that looks a lot smarter by the day.
Since arriving for rookie minicamp and OTAs, the 20-year-old has drawn steady praise. At 6-foot-4 and 243 pounds, he brings the kind of size and speed New York has been missing in the middle of its defense. Carter has said he has "special qualities," and Burns called the pairing of Reese and Tremaine Edmunds "scary."
There’s still the obvious caveat: he has to do it in pads, not just in shorts. But the talent has shown up early, and that’s enough to quiet a lot of the draft-night noise.
It also fits the kind of defense Harbaugh has leaned on throughout his career. In Baltimore, his teams were built around linebackers in the middle like Ray Lewis, C.J.
Mosley, Patrick Queen, and Roquan Smith. Reese looks like the sort of player Harbaugh has wanted in that spot all along.
Love, meanwhile, is still in the early part of his development, and none of this means he won’t become the player people expected. But for the Giants, Arizona’s decision at No. 3 may have done them a favor.
If Love had still been there at No. 5, New York might have taken him - and the backlash would have been immediate if he struggled right away.
Instead, the Giants walked away with a defender who appears to fit exactly what Harbaugh wants this defense to become.
In Other News...
Giants Tight End Battle Already Hit By An Early Camp Setback
The Giants opened training camp with a few early absences, and the tight end room is already feeling the ripple effect. Thomas Fidone II was among the players placed on the active/PUP list to start camp, a reminder that even before the pads come on, roster battles can be shaped by availability as much as talent. For a young player trying to carve out a place, every practice rep matters, especially in a competition where the margin for error is thin.
New faces and fresh evaluations tend to move quickly once camp begins, and that makes missed time more costly for players still trying to earn trust. The Giants can afford to be patient with Fidone, but the early stretch of camp is where coaches start sorting out who can handle the details and who can be counted on when the real competition for roles heats up. [Read more 🡒]
Giants May Already Have A New WR1 Problem Brewing
The Giants receiver picture already has a long-term question hanging over it, and it is the kind of roster issue that can sneak up on a team before it becomes urgent. With the current group carrying plenty of mileage and the organization still sorting out how much young talent it truly has at the position, it is easy to see why the front office would be thinking ahead to the 2027 draft and the next wave of wideouts who could reshape the room.
One name worth keeping on the radar is a young Texas pass catcher who has already shown enough production to draw attention from NFL evaluators. For the Giants, the appeal is not just about adding another receiver, but about finding someone who can grow alongside the rest of the offense and eventually ease the burden on a depth chart that could use more speed, durability and upside before the conversation gets much louder. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Camp Already Feels Like A Sharp Break From Recent Years
The early days of Giants camp already sound different from the old grind-and-survive version of summer football. John Harbaugh has been talking about the physical and mental demands of training camp, but the bigger point is how much the modern setup has changed under the 2011 Collective Bargaining Agreement. Practices are shorter and less punishing than in past eras, so the emphasis has shifted to making every rep count, with the staff trying to squeeze as much value as possible out of the time that is available.
Harbaugh also laid out how the Giants have been organizing their work since the spring, with rookie minicamp reps going to draft picks and OTAs and minicamp built around first- and second-team players handling most of the team work. He described a program that spends heavily on preparation and recovery, and one that is built around repetition and detail rather than speed for speeds sake. The result is a camp that feels less like a race through the calendar and more like a long, deliberate effort to get the structure right before the real pressure starts. [Read more 🡒]