New York’s backfield debate may not be as simple as the loudest Cam Skattebo highlights would suggest.
Tyrone Tracy Jr. has spent much of his Giants tenure looking like the guy who keeps getting edged out of the spotlight. He was pushed into a major role as a rookie in 2024 after Saquon Barkley left for the Philadelphia Eagles, then got another chance to seize the job when Cam Skattebo suffered a dislocated ankle and fractured tibia in Week 8 last season. And yet, even with back-to-back 1,000-plus all-purpose yard seasons, the 166th pick in the 2024 Draft still tends to get overlooked.
That’s why the idea of Tracy as the lead back deserves a real look, even if it runs against the cult-hero instinct around Skattebo.
Skattebo brings the kind of bruising, throw-your-body-at-the-defense style that’s impossible to ignore. He’s the back who looks built for chaos, the one who can drag a pile and turn a short-yardage snap into a fight.
But that style comes with limits. His 4.05 yards per carry last year points to a runner who’s at his best when the assignment is simple: get the tough yards, punish the front, finish drives.
Tracy gives the offense something different. He finds space naturally, and that matters.
He became the first Giants player since Barkley to post back-to-back 1,000-yard scrimmage seasons in his first two years, and while his 4.2 yards per carry last season only edged Skattebo’s number, the separation showed up in how often each back got stopped cold. Tracy was stuffed on just 13.6% of his carries, while Skattebo was stopped 16.7% of the time.
There’s also the versatility piece. Tracy spent his early college years at wide receiver, and his 4.4 speed gives the Giants a back they can flex out wide and send on wheel routes. That kind of usage can put slower linebackers and safeties in bad spots.
The cleanest way to use both backs may be to let Tracy start the game and let Skattebo finish it. That would keep Skattebo fresh for late-game punishment and give the Giants a chance to lean into his edge when defenses are worn down.
A true split still makes sense, but not necessarily one tilted heavily toward Skattebo. A 55/45 setup with Tracy in front would make more sense than a 50/50 or 60/40 arrangement in Skattebo’s favor.
Skattebo may be the more entertaining back to watch, but Tracy looks like the better fit for what the Giants need right now.
In Other News...
Isaiah Likely Could Be The Answer Giants Fans Have Waited For
Isaiah Likelys arrival gives the Giants something they have spent plenty of time searching for: a tight end who can be more than just a body in the formation. In Baltimore, he was the secondary option behind Mark Andrews, but in New York the opportunity looks different, with the Giants expecting him to handle dependable snaps and present a tougher problem for defenses than the position has offered in recent seasons.
For a young quarterback like Jaxson Dart, that kind of target can matter quickly. Likelys ability to create space and give the offense an easier outlet should help the passing game settle in, and it also gives the Giants another piece defenses have to account for before they can load up on Malik Nabers. The fit is obvious enough, even if the full payoff still has to be earned on the field. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Fans Just Got A Wild Isaiah Likely Comparison
Former NFL player and analyst Ryan Clark floated an eye-catching comparison for Giants tight end Isaiah Likely during an appearance on NFL Live, suggesting the new addition could bring a different kind of spark to New Yorks offense. The idea is easy to understand from the Giants perspective: they signed Likely to a three-year contract this offseason, signaling they want him to play a much bigger role than he has in the past.
There is still a gap between projection and production, though, and that is what makes the discussion so intriguing. Likely has not yet put together a season that matches the kind of impact Clark was pointing toward, and the Giants are still sorting out how their passing game will look as they build around him. With Malik Nabers health still uncertain, every possible weapon matters a little more, which is why this comparison has already become such a talking point. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Still Have One Offensive Line Problem Fans Cant Ignore
The Giants have spent enough time trying to stabilize the middle of their offensive line to know the center spot matters as much as any other, and John Michael Schmitz Jr. remains the player under the brightest spotlight. New York has upgraded the group around him, including rookie Francis Mauigoa at right guard, but the bigger question is whether Schmitz fits what the line is being asked to do now, especially with a heavier emphasis on gap run-blocking.
Schmitz has looked more comfortable in zone concepts than in schemes that ask him to move and adjust on the fly, and last seasons protection issues only sharpened the concern. He enters the final year of his rookie deal with a chance to change the conversation, but also with the kind of pressure that can turn every snap into a referendum on whether the Giants have found their long-term answer at center. [Read more 🡒]