Giants Fans Have Seen This Patriots Quarterback Problem Before

Can New England rely on Tommy DeVito to save their season after losing starter Drake Maye to injury?

The New England Patriots are about to find out what the New York Giants already lived through with Tommy DeVito.

Drake Maye’s ankle injury in Week 10 has reportedly put him on track to miss multiple weeks, and possibly the rest of the season. With the trade deadline already behind them, the Patriots are expected to turn to DeVito as their starter for the stretch ahead.

That’s a problem New York fans know all too well. DeVito had his brief run of magic with the Giants in 2023, when he started three straight wins and sparked a wild following around Big Blue. But that surge didn’t last, and the shine wore off fast.

His first four starts with the Giants were the good version of the story. The last two were the part everyone wanted to forget. An undrafted rookie at the time, DeVito flashed enough to win over the fan base before reality hit and he was eventually benched for Tyrod Taylor.

He’s still good enough to belong on an NFL roster, but he was never built to carry a team as a starter.

The Patriots got a taste of that in Week 10, when DeVito came in for Maye during a loss to the Detroit Lions. He completed only half his passes, averaged 3.4 yards per attempt, and threw one touchdown and one interception.

His -0.48 ranked 25th of 27 qualifying quarterbacks in Week 10, pending Monday Night Football. Only Daniel Jones and Carson Beck were worse.

Now New England is staring at a brutal stretch with DeVito at the controls, unless the team brings in another quarterback. Over the next month, the Patriots are set to face the Buffalo Bills, the Minnesota Vikings, and the Kansas City Chiefs. It’s a tough path to navigate for any backup, and especially one with DeVito’s limitations.

The bigger issue is how the Patriots got here. Maye takes a lot of hits, and the decision to trust DeVito as the backup looks like a roster-building mistake that’s already coming due.

Meanwhile, the Giants took a different approach. Joe Schoen and John Harbaugh made sure they wouldn’t be left scrambling at quarterback this season.

Jameis Winston entered the year regarded as one of the league’s best backups, and when Jaxson Dart went down, New York moved quickly to trade for J.J. McCarthy.

That gave Harbaugh a fallback when Winston struggled, and it left the Giants positioned for a playoff push. The Patriots, by contrast, appear headed in the other direction, with DeVito now carrying the burden of a stretch that could knock them out of the race.

In Other News...

Giants Fans Have Every Reason To Worry About Matt Nagy

The Giants offense has started to look like a unit that opponents can diagnose before the snap, and a big reason is the way Matt Nagy has handled the playbook. The passing game has leaned on a narrow set of concepts, which has made New York easier to defend and has left too little room for the kind of creativity that can stress a defense over four quarters.

For a team trying to find consistency, the bigger concern is whether Nagy is willing to open things up and put more on J.J. McCarthys plate. The Giants need more than a cautious script and a handful of familiar looks if they want the offense to become functional, and until Nagy shows more trust in his quarterback, the same questions are going to follow this group every week. [Read more 🡒]

Giants Try To Fix A Costly Problem With Veteran Help

The Giants turned to a familiar kind of midseason fix by adding safety Tavierre Thomas from the Vikings practice squad, a move aimed at strengthening a secondary that can use more depth and a special teams unit that has been under pressure. Thomas arrives with veteran experience and a clear role in mind, giving New York another body in the defensive backfield while also bolstering a phase of the game that has been a problem.

Special teams is where Thomas may matter most right away, particularly as a gunner on the punt team, where speed, discipline and reliability can change field position in a hurry. For a Giants roster trying to steady itself, the addition is less about splash and more about plugging a leak, with the hope that a proven, versatile defender can help clean up one of the teams more costly issues. [Read more 🡒]

Giants Face Another Brutal Test After Costly Loss

After a costly loss to Washington, the Giants are back in the spot they have too often found themselves this season: trying to steady things against a tougher-looking opponent. Jacksonville comes to MetLife Stadium in Week 11 as a 6.5-point favorite, and the matchup arrives with New York still searching for a cleaner response after letting one get away.

The Jaguars also bring a defense that has changed shape in recent weeks, adding Jordan Davis, Jesse Bates and Devon Godcheaux to the mix, with Godcheaux already seeing action in the previous game. For the Giants, that means another test of how much margin they really have at home, and whether a rough stretch can be interrupted before it starts to snowball further. [Read more 🡒]