The Giants may have found the kind of rookie defender who can tilt a season.
Arvell Reese put another stamp on his early NFL run Sunday, helping New York beat the Arizona Cardinals 36-24 and move to 3-1. The win pushed the Giants into sole possession of first place in the NFC East for the first time since 2015, and the defense had plenty to do with it. Abdul Carter and Deonte Banks made their presence felt, but Reese kept forcing his way into the conversation.
The rookie linebacker was all over the field against Arizona. He played 63 defensive snaps and finished with nine total tackles, three pass breakups, two quarterback pressures, one tackle for loss and an interception.
In Dennard Wilson’s game plan, Reese handled whatever was thrown at him, and he’s already outpacing the expectations attached to him on draft night. He was seen as a project prospect despite the freakish athletic ability that made him so intriguing in the first place.
That’s what makes the Giants’ decision to land him look better by the week. Four games into the season, Reese is looking like the steal of the draft - and the Jets are part of the reason he ended up in blue.
Heading into the first night of the draft, the second-overall pick belonged to New York’s other team. With a weak quarterback class in 2026, the Jets were in position to take the best impact player on the board. Their choice came down to Reese and Texas Tech pass rusher David Bailey.
Reese offered more versatility. At Ohio State, he was used as a jack-of-all-trades defender who could rush the passer but also do plenty more.
Bailey, by contrast, was viewed as the class’s best pure edge rusher. The Jets had to decide whether to go with the safer pass-rushing profile or bet on the higher-upside athlete.
They went with Bailey. Reese slid past the Jets, then past the Cardinals at No. 3 and the Tennessee Titans at No. 4 before the Giants stepped in. New York wasted no time making the pick, and the Giants even released behind-the-scenes video showing Harbaugh stunned and fired up that Reese had fallen to them.
There was some initial uncertainty about where Reese would fit on the Giants’ defense. With Brian Burns, Kayvon Thibodeaux and Carter already in place as pass rushers, the fit wasn’t obvious on paper. Harbaguh answered that quickly, saying Reese would be used primarily as an off-ball linebacker.
So far, that role has worked beautifully.
The Giants are also watching the player the Jets chose instead. Bailey looked strong in the preseason and carried that into Week 1, when he posted six quarterback pressures and one sack in a win over the Tennessee Titans.
He added the second sack of his career in a Week 2 loss to the Green Bay Packers. But his production has cooled since then.
Against the Chicago Bears in a 23-12 loss, Bailey had six total tackles, including two solo and four assisted, but he didn’t record a single pressure while rushing backup Tyson Bagent. That’s a sharp drop-off for a player who started hot.
Connor Hughes of SNY noted that Bailey’s pass rush win rate sits at 9.1 percent, which ranks 29th out of 36 eligible edge rushers.
Reese, meanwhile, has been surging. The Cardinals game came on the heels of a huge Week 4 outing against the Titans, when he piled up 13 total tackles and one pass breakup. Over those two games alone, he has 22 total tackles, four pass breakups and an interception.
The Giants bet on upside, but they probably didn’t expect Reese to adjust this fast. Right now, he looks like a force on defense. And with Bailey struggling in recent weeks, the choice to let Reese slip by looks harder to explain by the day.
In Other News...
Giants Win Got Overshadowed By A Viral MetLife Officiating Moment
The Giants Week 4 win over the Cardinals came with the usual mix of physical play and sideline frustration, but the postgame conversation quickly drifted away from the final score. A video from MetLife Stadium began making the rounds on social media after a line judge appeared to direct an expletive at Cardinals tight end Trey McBride during the game, turning a routine officiating scene into the sort of viral clip that can swallow the aftermath of a Sunday afternoon.
McBride still had a quiet but steady day in the passing game, finishing with seven receptions for 31 yards as Arizona fell 36-24. For the Giants, the result was the headline they wanted, but the officiating moment became the one people kept replaying, adding an awkward layer to a game that was supposed to be remembered for New York controlling the scoreboard. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Fans Just Got An Officiating Controversy Theyll Want To See
A sideline moment from MetLife Stadium is drawing as much attention as the game itself after a line judge was caught on video appearing to use profanity directed at Cardinals tight end Trey McBride during Arizonas Week 4 meeting with the Giants. The clip spread quickly on social media and added an odd officiating wrinkle to a game that already had plenty going on for both sides.
McBride still managed seven catches for 31 yards, but the Cardinals could not turn that work into enough offense in a 36-24 loss. For Giants fans, the incident is less about the final score than the kind of officiating controversy that can linger long after the game is over, especially when it plays out in full view on a viral clip. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Win Came With A Cost And A New Line Question
The Giants latest win over the Cardinals gave them a clean home mark for the first time since 2008, but it came with more than a few reminders of how fragile a season can feel in the NFL. New York came out of the game dealing with three injuries, with Jason Pinnock in concussion protocol, Braxton Berrios sidelined by a foot issue and Chauncey Golston hurt in the neck area, turning a satisfying afternoon into one that demanded an immediate injury check.
There was at least one encouraging development up front, where Bryan Hudson made his first NFL start at center and held up well enough to draw praise from John Harbaugh. Harbaugh also made it clear the move was temporary because John Michael Schmitz was out, but it still leaves the Giants with a familiar offensive line question as they move deeper into the schedule and try to keep building on their early home success. [Read more 🡒]