Giants fans have seen enough of the Evan Neal saga to know a bad offensive line comparison when they see one, and they weren’t eager to welcome Francis “Sisi” Mauigoa into that conversation after a Pro Football Focus post linked the two.
The setup was simple enough: through six weeks, Mauigoa and Neal were the only first-round rookie offensive linemen since 2006 to post both a sub-50 overall PFF grade and a sub-50 run-blocking grade, with a minimum of 250 snaps. For a fan base that has spent years trying to move past Neal, the optics were brutal.
Mauigoa’s numbers this season explain why the comparison got traction. He has a 46.4 overall grade, which ranks 72nd among 76 qualified guards.
His run-blocking grade sits at 49.7, his pass-blocking grade at 40.0, and he has given up 13 pressures and four QB hits. The struggles are real.
But Giants fans were quick to push back on the idea that this is already another Evan Neal situation. One fan wrote, “We honestly need to stop with the PFF grades being the end-all, be-all; this is nonsense not even close to being comparable Evan Neal was horrible."
Another response was even shorter: “Sisi has been good. PFF is just a joke.”
A more measured take pointed to the bigger issue behind Mauigoa’s adjustment: “When you actually watch the games, he struggles sometimes but for the most part he’s been solid. He’s a rookie playing in a different position than what he’s use to. He’s going to be fine.”
That positional change is a big part of this story. Mauigoa spent his college career at Miami at right tackle, then New York moved him inside after acquiring the No. 10 pick in the Dexter Lawrence blockbuster trade. Sliding from tackle to guard means dealing with bigger, stronger defensive linemen instead of the smaller, more athletic rushers he handled in college, and it hasn’t been a smooth transition for the 6-foot-6, 330-pound lineman.
The situation around him hasn’t helped much, either. Jon Runyan Jr. has been playing terribly, Andrew Thomas has been dealing with a groin injury, and Jermaine Eluemunor missed Week 6 with a calf issue.
That doesn’t mean Mauigoa has been good enough. His Week 6 outing against New Orleans was rough, and the Giants did not use a top-10 pick to see him living near the bottom of the league in so many categories. He has to improve.
Still, six games is a tiny sample, and there’s some reason for patience. Andrew Thomas didn’t exactly burst onto the scene as a rookie, and he turned out just fine. Mauigoa is only 21, and the Giants will give him time to settle in.
For now, the Evan Neal comparison works as a spicy social media post. It also hits a nerve for a fan base that has lived through enough offensive line misery already. But after six weeks, it’s still too early to lock Mauigoa into that label.
In Other News...
Giants Backfield Suddenly Has A Bigger Problem After Ugly Fallout
Najee Harris brief run with the Giants took an uneasy turn after he voiced frustration with the teams running back rotation following a rough outing against the Saints. New York had been trying to find a consistent pulse in the ground game, and head coach John Harbaugh said the unit still had not earned a rhythm, stressing the need to make the most of the chances it gets.
Instead, the conversation around the backfield shifted quickly from usage to fallout. Harris complaints put the spotlight on a situation the Giants had been hoping to steady, and the team has now moved on, closing the book on a stint that never really found its footing. The departure leaves the backfield even more unsettled at a moment when the Giants could ill afford another layer of uncertainty. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Suddenly Have A Chance To Fix Their Biggest Problem
The offensive line has been the Giants most obvious weak spot, and a surprising opening in Indianapolis could make that problem easier to attack. With the Colts moving on from general manager Chris Ballard after a rough stretch, the rest of the league will be watching to see whether the new regime is willing to listen on veterans, especially when it comes to a proven interior blocker like Quenton Nelson.
For a Giants team that has spent much of the season looking for stability up front, this is the kind of situation worth monitoring before the November 10 trade deadline. Nothing is confirmed, and no move has been reported, but the idea alone gives New York a rare chance to chase help where it needs it most. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Suddenly Have A Real Shot At Fixing Their Backfield
The Giants running back situation has become one of the clearer weak spots on the roster, and with the trade deadline approaching, it is the kind of problem that can push a front office to explore every possible angle. New York has reason to keep an eye on the market, especially if a proven back becomes available at a time when the right team might be more willing to listen than it was a few weeks ago.
Jonathan Taylor is the obvious name to watch, at least as a fit on paper. He has remained a productive player for Indianapolis, and his availability would instantly change the conversation for a Giants offense looking for more stability behind center. For now, nothing has been confirmed, but the possibility is enough to make this one worth tracking as the deadline draws closer. [Read more 🡒]