The Giants are walking into Sunday’s matchup with Houston as a sizable underdog, but the Texans come in with more questions than their 2-4 record might suggest. Houston was supposed to start faster than this, stumbled out of the gate at 0-4, then steadied itself with back-to-back wins. That’s enough to create some hope, but not enough to erase the unease around a team that keeps needing time to find itself.
That’s the read from Scott Barzilla of SB Nation’s Battle Red Blog, who sees a Texans team that has been through this kind of slow start before. He pointed to the possibility of a softer stretch in the schedule helping Houston climb back to 6-4 and, from there, into the kind of ten-win finish that could put it in the playoffs. But he also said there are deeper issues that seem to show up every year, including an effort to force a hard-nosed running identity that has never really fit the roster.
The defense has its own problems. Even after DeMeco Ryans reclaimed play-calling duties two weeks ago, Houston has not looked like the dominant unit it was last season.
Barzilla said one strong week was followed by a much rougher one, and his view is that opposing coordinators have started to crack the code. He believes Ryans has the ability to adjust, but said the Texans now need “new wrinkles” because “Superior schemes win in the league and his scheme is no longer superior.”
If the Giants are looking for a player who could swing things in Houston’s favor, Barzilla named Arvell Reese as the first choice, with linebacker help badly needed in the middle of the Texans defense. He also mentioned Malik Nabers as a tempting option because he might be the best overall player on the field Sunday, but said Houston already has a strong receiving group. He brought up Skattebo, too, while noting the fumbling issues that worry him even though he likes the running style.
A big part of Houston’s turnaround, Barzilla said, has been C.J. Stroud simply being used the right way.
He compared the Texans’ offensive approach to forcing a square peg into a round hole, saying the last two seasons have often asked Stroud to operate as a running-game quarterback and a ball-control manager when that is not really what fits him. In recent weeks, Houston has opened things up, spread the field and played with more tempo, and Barzilla said that suits Stroud better.
He described him as not quite as athletic as other quarterbacks and not having the strongest arm, but said he is extremely accurate when he has time.
For the Giants, the path to an upset starts with speed and precision. Barzilla said the middle of the field is there to be attacked, even against Derek Stingley and Kamari Lassiter, whom he said have not played to their Pro Bowl-level pedigree this season.
He pointed to CeeDee Lamb’s 17-catch day against Houston and said other top receivers and tight ends have had success there too. That opens the door for Malik Nabers to make an impact, as long as the Giants get the ball out quickly before the Texans’ pass rush closes in.
On the other side, the Giants’ own pass rush is the wild card. Barzilla said it worries him and believes New York has a real chance if it can make Houston one-dimensional. The betting line has climbed to 10 points, which he called insane, and he doesn’t think the Texans should be double-digit favorites until they prove they deserve that kind of respect.
In Other News...
Giants Are Betting Big On A QB Trait Winston Couldnt Offer
J.J. McCarthy arrived in New York with the kind of arm talent that can change the feel of an offense before he even takes a snap. After a difficult run with the Vikings, he has landed with the Giants, and the early word from teammates and people around him is that the deep ball is the trait that stands out most. Even after some statistical issues on throws downfield last season, McCarthys physical gifts give New York a different kind of passing threat than it had before.
For a Giants offense that has been looking for ways to stress defenses beyond the short game, that matters. McCarthys arm strength and athletic ability open doors the team simply did not have with Jameis Winston, and the staff is weighing how much of that can be built into the plan. The next question is how far the Giants are willing to go in leaning into those possibilities, especially if they want to make the most of what McCarthy can do outside the pocket. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Backfield Suddenly Feels Like A Problem They Can't Ignore
With the Giants trying to steady themselves before a matchup with the Texans, the problems are piling up in every phase, from penalties to the broader offensive unease that has followed J.J. McCarthy into his first start. John Harbaugh and Matt Nagy have already talked about making adjustments, and the backfield is part of that conversation now, especially with Cam Skattebo set to rejoin the mix after working through the issues that pushed him to take a hard look at his approach.
The timing matters because this is no longer just about cleaning up a depth chart or getting through one game. The Giants are weighing whether the current group is enough to stabilize a sputtering offense, and league chatter is starting to connect their running back situation to bigger possibilities as the Nov. 10 deadline approaches. For a team already searching for answers, the next move at that spot could say a lot about how urgently they see the problem. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Suddenly Have A Tough Tight End Decision To Make
The Giants tight end room got a little thinner on the practice report, with Chris Manhertz missing work because of a calf injury and Theo Johnson still limited as he deals with a neck issue. That left the team looking closely at its remaining options, especially with Thomas Fidone II back on the field as a full participant despite a shoulder designation.
Fidone is still listed fourth on the depth chart, and he has yet to make his mark in the passing game, but the coaching staff appears open to using him in a limited receiving role to get a better read on what he can bring. No changes have been announced to snap counts or play calls, so the situation remains fluid as the Giants sort through a position group that suddenly feels much less settled. [Read more 🡒]