The Washington Commanders are still carrying the fallout from that Week 5 mess against the Giants, and not just because of how it ended. When these teams meet again Thursday, the conversation around Washington is still centered on the same thing: the decisions, the coaching, and the unease that’s followed them ever since.
The last time these teams played, the Giants had a chance to win in overtime and let it slip away by fumbling. Even so, the attention landed squarely on Washington.
The final play drew heavy criticism for both the Commanders’ coaching and Jayden Daniels, who was faulted for not having better situational awareness. Then came another late-game issue the very next week against the 49ers, and that only sharpened the focus on the Commanders’ operation.
What’s really bothered fans, though, is that it hasn’t felt like one isolated mistake. It’s been a string of questionable choices, especially from the coaching staff and the offense.
A big share of the blame has fallen on offensive coordinator David Blough, who moved from Assistant QB Coach to OC much faster than some around the team thought he should have. That promotion, according to Andrew York of Hogs Haven, was probably too much too soon. He pointed more directly to Dan Quinn for making the move.
The quarterback matchup has changed since Week 5, too. Back then it was Jameis Winston.
This time it’s J.J. McCarthy, and that does alter the plan a bit.
McCarthy brings mobility, which means Washington’s defense has to account for his scrambles, and he’s also been better throwing deep this season. Still, York didn’t see that as a dramatic leap in difficulty compared with quarterbacks the Commanders have already seen, including Brock Purdy.
The bigger concern is McCarthy’s legs, especially after Washington let Jalen Hurts scramble for 46 yards earlier this year and convert several key first downs.
The bigger question around Washington may be whether Dan Quinn can survive a season that goes off the rails. York didn’t think so.
He said the Commanders’ main issue has been coaching, pointing to the most yards erased by penalty in the NFL, slow playcalls, players taking too long to get set, and repeated mistakes in situational awareness and game management. He also noted that the defense has looked better in recent games since Steve Wilks was brought in as a defensive consultant, which only makes the overall picture look worse for Quinn, a head coach known for his defensive background.
There’s also the matter of what Washington has become since that Week 5 meeting. The roster has taken a hit.
Terry McLaurin suffered a patellar tendon tear and may never be the same player again. Defensive tackles Javon Kinlaw and Daron Payne are both on IR and likely done for the year.
Running back Jacory Croskey-Merritt is also on IR and won’t be back for a few weeks. York put that total at $74M in salary cap on injured reserve.
At the same time, he said one area has improved: the defense’s organization. The addition of Steve Wills as a defensive consultant several weeks ago appears to have helped, especially in the secondary, where players have looked less confused and less out of place after big plays.
York also pointed out that Washington didn’t add or replace any defensive position coaches in the offseason even after hiring a new defensive coordinator, leaving Daronte Jones to work with the same staff that coached a historically bad defense last year. That, he said, made the midseason help from Wilks even more important.
And when it comes to the Giants’ skill players, York said he’d fear Arvell Reese more than Malik Nabers, simply because Reese could directly injure Jayden Daniels on a play. That, he said, matters most for a team that is on the outside looking in when it comes to postseason relevance.
In Other News...
Giants Enter A Pivotal Stretch With Two Roster Updates Looming
The Giants have spent the last stretch leaning on flexibility and depth, and it has helped keep them competitive while the coaching staff continues to make strategic adjustments. Rookie Arvell Reese has already shown how valuable that can be by moving around the defense, while veteran D.J. Reader has backed up the eye test with strong play that has stood out in the grades.
Now the bigger roster picture is starting to come into focus with J.J. McCarthy and Cam Skattebo reportedly ready to return. For a team that has had to piece things together on the fly, those two reinforcements could give the Giants a different look at a time when every move matters, even if the exact timing of their comeback still leaves a little to be sorted out. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Trade Deadline Looks Better Thanks To An Unlikely Rookie
When the trade deadline came and went, the Giants decided against spending draft capital on a veteran defensive tackle, choosing instead to see what they already had in-house. That call looked a little more questionable at the time, but sixth-round rookie Bobby Jamison-Travis has helped change the conversation with a steady rise in playing time and some encouraging recent work against the run.
The bigger picture for the Giants is that the defensive line has started to look more settled, and not just because of one player. Jamison-Travis has been part of a group effort that has improved the teams ability to limit rushing yards, giving the front office at least some evidence that patience may have been the right play while the season moves forward. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Could Revisit One Missed Upgrade Fans Wont Forget
The Giants went into the trade deadline looking for a possible upgrade at running back, and Jonathan Taylor was one of the names they pursued before Indianapolis shut the door. New York reportedly offered draft picks for the Colts star, but no deal got done, leaving the Giants to stand pat while other teams around the league shuffled their rosters.
Jonathan Taylor remains a name worth watching beyond this deadline, especially if the Colts make changes in their front office. For now, the Giants move forward with their current running back group, but this is the kind of missed swing that can linger if the position remains an issue later in the season. [Read more 🡒]