The Giants took a swing on Darnell Mooney hoping a familiar face could spark a comeback, but the results have been flat from the start.
New York signed Mooney to a one-year deal worth up to $10 million after bringing him in because he had previously been coached by Matt Nagy in Chicago. The idea was simple enough: see whether that reunion could help him rediscover the form that once made him an intriguing option. The Giants were also hunting hard for receiver help behind Malik Nabers, and they believed Mooney could step into the WR2 role despite a rough season in Atlanta that was hampered by injuries.
That bet has not paid off. Through the first seven weeks, Mooney has only nine catches for 113 yards and has added three carries for 32 yards, even though he’s been healthy and had a clear path to a starting job.
At one point during OTAs, there was at least a hint that he might be on the way to a turnaround. Instead, he has become the one obvious miss in what was otherwise a strong first free-agent class in New York for John Harbaugh.
The numbers around him only make the disappointment louder. Players such as Josh Cuevas, Efton Chism, Dohnte Myers, Konata Mumpfield, Elijah Higgins, and Jordan Watkins have all produced more receiving than Mooney in 2026.
For the Giants, that’s a rough outcome even by modest standards. A 500- or 600-yard season would have been enough to make bringing him back at least a consideration.
Instead, the long-term picture points elsewhere. Even with only $3 million guaranteed in the deal, the investment is looking shaky, and Mooney’s starting spot may now be in danger despite the team having moved on from Darius Slayton and Odell Beckham Jr.
What’s pushing him further out of the picture is the rise of Malachi Fields. The rookie has started earning more trust from the coaching staff, and he’s doing it while offering traits Mooney simply doesn’t.
In the Giants’ 27-21 overtime win over the Houston Texans, Mooney managed one catch for four yards. Fields, on the other hand, hauled in four of five targets for 83 yards, highlighted by a 47-yard catch-and-run after J.J.
McCarthy fit one into a tight window and Fields kept driving forward. His chances have not come in a steady flow, but when they have come, he’s made them count.
At 6-foot-4 and 220 pounds, Fields brings a bigger frame than Mooney, more value as a red-zone target, and more willingness as a run blocker. And with the rookie nearly six years younger, the Giants’ preferred path is pretty clear if they want a receiver to grow alongside this offense behind Nabers.
Mooney has had every chance to seize the job, but he hasn’t made himself indispensable. Right now, the Giants look better off building around Nabers and Fields and looking elsewhere for another receiver down the line than holding onto Mooney for the long haul.
In Other News...
Giants Suddenly Have A Jonathan Taylor Debate Fans Can't Ignore
Jonathan Taylor has suddenly become one of the biggest names on the trade market, and the Giants are right in the middle of the conversation. According to Adam Schefter of ESPN, the Colts are willing to deal the running back, and New York is among several teams with reported interest. For a Giants team always looking for ways to raise the ceiling of its offense, the idea of adding a proven back of Taylors caliber is the kind of possibility that naturally gets attention.
The harder part is figuring out what it would actually take to make it happen. A player of Taylors profile is not the kind of target teams usually land cheaply, and any pursuit would likely require serious draft capital along with some salary-cap maneuvering. For the Giants, that creates the real debate: whether the upgrade at running back would be worth the cost in assets and flexibility, especially with other roster needs still demanding attention. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Suddenly Have A Linebacker Problem They Can't Ignore
The Giants linebacker room took a serious hit when Tremaine Edmunds went on injured reserve with a shoulder injury, leaving a position group that had already been under a microscope suddenly much thinner. With Edmunds out, Micah McFadden and rookie Arvell Reese have been pushed into the lineup, and the team is now trying to steady a spot that carries a lot of responsibility in the middle of the defense.
What makes the situation harder is that the Giants do not just need bodies there, they need reliability and communication. The depth chart is unsettled enough that a veteran addition before the trade deadline is at least on the table, even if no move has been made yet. For a defense that has already had to adjust on the fly, the next decision at linebacker could say plenty about how urgently the Giants view the problem. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Deadline Approach Could Say Everything About This Playoff Push
The Giants enter Week 8 in a spot they have not occupied often enough in recent years, sitting atop the NFC East and staring at a deadline that could help define whether this start turns into something more. For Joe Schoen, the question is less about making a splash than about whether this is the time to be a little bolder than usual, especially with a roster that could use help without requiring the kind of heavy price tag that usually comes with deadline shopping.
Schoen has generally been cautious in-season, and the organization has not exactly built a deep reservoir of impact from late-round draft picks. That is why the most practical path may be the simplest one, using modest draft capital to bring in a veteran who can strengthen the roster right away and fit a team trying to turn first-place positioning into staying power. [Read more 🡒]