The number that matters most for Jordan Stout isn’t the eye-popping 78-yard blast. It’s the nine punts he’s placed inside the 20 on 16 attempts, the kind of field-position work the Giants clearly had in mind when they handed him a three-year deal worth $12.3 million.
That kind of commitment at punter doesn’t come cheap, and it usually doesn’t get much attention unless something goes sideways. Four games in, there’s no reason to call the deal a steal. But there is reason to like the idea behind it: a punter who can consistently pin opponents deep is worth more than one who just occasionally puts on a show.
Stout’s early numbers point in that direction. He’s averaging 50.6 gross yards and 44.2 net yards, with one touchback.
Those two averages tell very different stories. Gross yards show the leg.
Net yards show what the defense actually gets after the return and the touchback are factored in.
That’s where John Harbaugh’s view comes in. In his Saturday interview with Giants.com, he tied the whole operation to the coverage unit and said, “You can’t just punt the ball down there and not have great coverage.” He also praised Elijah Campbell and the gunners, making it clear the result is bigger than the punter alone.
The Arizona game last Sunday fit that idea neatly. Stout punted three times, landed two inside the 20 and avoided any touchbacks.
His longest boot was 51 yards. It was a productive outing, even without anything close to the 78-yard kick he uncorked against the Rams.
That Rams game is the other side of the coin. New York got six punts that averaged 52.5 gross yards, but the net average settled at 43.8, and none of that kept the Giants from losing 28-6. A booming punt can improve the next drive for the defense, but it won’t patch over problems elsewhere.
So the better way to read Stout’s value is through the field position he creates, not the replay-friendly distance of one monster kick. A shorter punt that lands safely and stays out of the end zone can be the smarter play than a longer one that gives yardage back. The right answer depends on the situation - the line of scrimmage, the coverage, the returner - not just a simple urge to kick it as far as possible.
Stout also has the benefit of familiarity with Harbaugh, his former coach in Baltimore. That helps explain the interest, but it doesn’t finish the evaluation. Sixteen punts is still a small sample, and net average is as much about what happens after the kick as the kick itself.
There are always cheaper options at this spot if the coverage is sound enough. If the Giants are going to keep paying a premium, Stout has to keep proving he can deliver in different situations.
So far, the best evidence isn’t the 78-yarder. It’s the steady pile of punts that have put opponents in a hole.
Washington gives him another chance Sunday to keep doing exactly that. Pinning a team deep matters even more when the defense has little room to absorb a long possession, and the next kick doesn’t need to travel 78 yards to show why Harbaugh wanted him.
In Other News...
Giants Suddenly Have A Pass Rush Problem They Couldnt Afford
The Giants defensive front took another hit this week when Chauncey Golston was placed on injured reserve, a move that only sharpens the concern around a unit already leaning thin. New York has been trying to piece together enough reliable depth up front, and losing another lineman forces the team to reshuffle again just as the schedule keeps asking more of the pass rush.
To help cover the immediate need, the Giants elevated outside linebacker Trace Ford and receiver Dalen Cambre from the practice squad for Sundays game. Fords call-up gives the defense another body on the edge for now, though it does not lock him into anything beyond this week, leaving New York still searching for a cleaner answer to its depth problem. [Read more 🡒]
Arvell Reese Has A Chance To Change This Giants Rivalry Fast
Arvell Reese has already given the Giants a useful early-season jolt on defense, and now the rookie linebacker is stepping into a game plan that could test him in a bigger way. Through the first four weeks, Reese has looked like a player the Giants can trust, and Week 5 brings a divisional setting that puts a premium on discipline, pursuit and making one of the leagues most dangerous young quarterbacks work for every yard.
Washingtons passing game is not at full strength, which only heightens the importance of keeping Jayden Daniels from turning broken plays into momentum-shifting gains. If the Giants can limit his ability to improvise, Reese could end up at the center of a fast-moving rivalry game where one rookie defender has a chance to shape how the whole afternoon feels. [Read more 🡒]
Malik Nabers Just Gave Giants Fans One Big Reason To Watch Sunday
Malik Nabers gave the Giants exactly the kind of spark they have been looking for in Week 4, piling up 112 yards and a touchdown in the win over Arizona. Even with that production, there was still a sense that his role could be even bigger, especially after he came away feeling like he wasnt targeted enough in the second half.
That makes Sundays matchup with Washington worth watching closely, because the Commanders have had a hard time handling top receivers and the Giants passing game suddenly has less room to spread the ball around. With some roster shuffling already thinning the group behind Nabers, the easiest path for New York may be the simplest one: keep feeding its most dangerous pass catcher and let the game tilt his way. [Read more 🡒]