ESPN’s latest ranking of the NFL’s top defensive tackles should land hard with Giants fans, because two familiar names are sitting near the top of the list.
Leonard Williams came in at No. 1 in a poll compiled with input from NFL executives, coaches and scouts, while Dexter Lawrence checked in at No. 7 despite what ESPN described as a down season. For a Giants fan base already worried about the interior of the defensive line, that’s a rough reminder of what once was - and what got away.
Williams drew rave reviews from the people who voted. ESPN wrote that he’s “an absolute nightmare to block,” and added that several offensive coaches called him the toughest player to guard last season. One NFL coordinator said, “He was the most important player on that Super Bowl team,” and added, “He’s the total package.”
The production backed it up. Williams finished with 7.0 sacks and a 38.0% run stop win rate, good enough for second-team All-Pro honors.
A veteran NFC defensive coach said, “You can line him up in front of the right tackle, the right guard, the center, the left guard, the left tackle -- he can beat them all,” before adding, “He’s always had game-changing ability, and he’s putting it all together now. And those around him are making plays because of it too.”
Lawrence’s slide wasn’t as dramatic as it looks on paper. ESPN noted that the gap between the third and seventh spots was tight, even though Lawrence dropped six places. Still, the numbers tell the story of a quieter year: 0.5 sacks in 2025, a career low, and his first missed Pro Bowl since 2021.
Even so, he remained a magnet for blocking attention. Lawrence was double-teamed 71.3% of the time in 2025, the highest rate in the league for players with at least 300 pass-rush opportunities.
One NFC scout said, “I think he’ll be rejuvenated there,” and added, “He wasn’t happy in New York. He’s got to keep his conditioning in check, but when he’s at his best, he’s next to impossible to block.”
That’s the part that stings for New York: both players left, and both are still viewed as elite at their position.
The Giants, though, made their decision based on where each player stood at the time. Williams was in the final year of a three-year, $63 million deal he signed after the Giants acquired him from the Jets at the 2021 NFL Trade Deadline.
He was 29, had been a steady force more than a dominant one, and his body had started to betray him. After starting 114 straight games since being drafted in Round 1 by the Jets in 2015, he dealt with knee, elbow and neck injuries in 2022 and missed five games - the first missed games of his career.
In 2023, he posted 1.5 sacks in eight games for New York. He was still useful, but the sense around him was that his best football might already be behind him, and the Giants were staring at a decision about whether to pay him or move on. They chose the latter.
That move brought back a second-round pick that became Tyler Nubin, a fifth-round pick that became Marcus Mbow, and the cap room to trade for Brian Burns, who is four years younger. Given the circumstances, the Giants came out ahead.
Lawrence’s exit played out differently. New head coach John Harbaugh wanted to build the defensive line around the three-time Pro Bowler, whom many considered the league’s best pure nose tackle.
Lawrence, though, was done with the losing and the constant resets, and he had watched players like Williams and Saquon Barkley leave and thrive elsewhere. He wanted out.
After the trade to the Cincinnati Bengals, Lawrence got a one-year, $28 million extension. The Giants, according to a reliable source, offered more years and more money than that, but it wasn’t enough. He wanted to be somewhere else.
New York accepted the reality and got the 10th pick in the draft in return, then used it to select Francis Mauigoa, helping shore up the offensive line.
Harbaugh called the whole thing “a win, win, win,” and said, “I think it was a win for everybody,” while stressing that the Giants’ side mattered most. “We wanted Dexter to be happy, but we wanted the Giants to be taken care of first. That was our responsibility.”
He also said, “To get the 10th pick in the draft, and then to see it play out tonight, it’s pretty clear cut that it’s a W for us. Not that it wouldn’t have been a W to keep Dexter, it sure would have been.
But that didn’t turn out to be possible. It wasn’t something that he was really prioritizing in the end.”
And he closed with this: “And that’s okay. That’s fine.
He got an opportunity and the Bengals got an opportunity to get a great player, and, you know, it’s going to make their defense better. So everybody’s a winner on this one.”
For the Giants, that’s the bottom line. They didn’t get to keep two elite defensive tackles, but they handled both situations as well as they could have.
In Other News...
Giants Receiver Room Suddenly Has One Safe Spot Entering Camp
The Giants receiver room has rarely looked this unsettled heading into camp, and the latest wave of additions only underscores how much is still up for grabs. With training camp set to open July 28, the group now includes a mix of established veterans and developmental pieces, all trying to carve out roles around a depth chart that has been shaken by injuries and constant turnover.
Odell Beckham Jr. is back in the building after signing on June 1, giving the Giants a familiar name and a proven presence as they sort through the competition. But the real intrigue is in how the rest of the room sorts itself out, from Darius Slayton and Darnell Mooney to Calvin Austin III and the other challengers trying to force their way into the conversation before the first pads come on. [Read more 🡒]
This Quiet Giants Addition Could Change A Familiar Defensive Problem
Ar'Darius Washington arrives in New York with the kind of background that can quietly matter over the course of a season. The Giants liked enough of what they saw to add a safety who has already shown he can do more than one job in the back end, and his 2024 season in Baltimore offered a glimpse of why. He was around the ball, made plays in coverage and even found ways to affect the quarterback and run game, which is the sort of profile that can help a defense stay flexible when injuries or matchups start forcing adjustments.
For the Giants, the appeal goes beyond simply adding another body to the secondary. Washingtons versatility gives the coaching staff a chance to mix and match more freely in 2026, especially if they want to lean into different safety looks and keep opposing offenses guessing. The bigger question is how much of that value he can bring after the injury setback he dealt with in 2025, even with the encouraging way he got back on the field late in the year. [Read more 🡒]
Leonard Williams Trade Is Suddenly A Tougher Giants Sell
When the Giants moved Leonard Williams at the 2023 trade deadline, the deal looked like a straightforward future play: a second-round pick in 2024 and a fifth-rounder in 2025, with New York leaning into the idea that it had turned a veteran defender into draft capital. At the time, it was easy to frame the move as part of a broader reset, the kind of transaction that can make sense for a team trying to balance present needs with long-term flexibility.
Williams has complicated that view in Seattle. He has settled in as a key piece of the Seahawks defense and earned his first All-Pro nomination, a reminder that the Giants did not just trade away a name, they moved a player who still had plenty left in the tank. For New York, that makes the old deadline decision a little harder to file away as a clean win or loss, especially with Williams now drawing recognition as one of the leagues top defensive tackles. [Read more 🡒]