Don Mattingly has spent a long career with one huge question hanging over him: Hall of Fame or not? But if you ask him what would matter more, the answer comes fast.
Now managing the Phillies, Mattingly said a championship would top even Cooperstown.
“A ring for sure,” Mattingly said to New York Post’s Jon Heyman when asked if he’d rather a championship or the Hall of Fame. “One hundred percent for me … yeah, the ring.”
That answer carries some weight coming from a man who built a decorated baseball résumé as a player and manager without ever getting the one prize that still slips through his hands. Mattingly was an MVP and a six-time All-Star as a Yankee, but he reached the playoffs only once as a player, and that came when he was 34.
His managerial path has brought more chances, though not the final payoff. Over 12 combined seasons managing the Dodgers and Marlins, he got to the postseason four times and never made it to the World Series. Last season, he was on the Blue Jays’ staff as bench coach, and Toronto came within two outs of knocking off the Dodgers in the World Series.
Now he’s trying to finish the job in Philadelphia after taking over on April 28, when Rob Thomson was fired following a 9-19 start. Since Mattingly arrived, the Phillies have gone 45-24 and pushed themselves into the race. At the All-Star break, they held a two-game lead for the second wild-card spot and sat two games behind the Braves in the NL East.
The Phillies also brought six players - not including ace Zack Wheeler, who turned down the invite - to Citizens Bank Ballpark for the 2026 All-Star Game, a sign of the talent Mattingly has at his disposal.
And he isn’t shy about what he thinks that group can do.
“If we play our best baseball, we don’t worry about anybody else,” Mattingly said. “We feel like we can beat anybody.”
In Other News...
Giants CB2 Battle Just Took A Turn Bigger Names Wont Like
The Giants second outside cornerback job has already been one of the more interesting camp battles on the roster, with Paulson Adebo, Greg Newsome II, Colton Hood and Deonte Banks all in the mix for a spot that carries real weight in the secondary. New York has spent draft capital on the position and kept the competition open, which only adds to the pressure on a group that is trying to sort out roles before the season gets too far along.
Greg Newsome II has the clearest path because of his experience, but the race has widened enough that the Giants are at least taking a longer look at Art Green as well. Green has made his name mostly on special teams, so any push into the cornerback conversation would be a notable development for a defense still trying to settle its best combination on the outside. [Read more 🡒]
Giants May Have Finally Found The Answer Chicago Gave Up On
The Giants have spent enough time trying to stabilize the middle of their defense that any credible upgrade at linebacker was always going to draw attention, and Tremaine Edmunds fits that description. After Chicago moved on from him, New York stepped in with a three-year, $36 million deal, betting on a player whose size, range and experience should give the defense more juice in the second level.
Edmunds arrives with a reputation for covering ground and piling up tackles, which is exactly the sort of profile the Giants have been missing when offenses start testing them between the hashes. He also gives the team a veteran presence in a room that needs it, especially with rookie Arvell Reese now settling into a full-time off-ball role and learning what it takes to handle the position every week. [Read more 🡒]
Bill Parcells Earned His Flowers But Giants Fans Will Still Bristle
Bill Parcells keeps piling up the kind of recognition that makes his Hall of Fame case feel even more untouchable. CBS Sports recently put together a list of the 20 greatest NFL head coaches of all time, and Parcells landed at No. 13 after receiving votes from all six reporters who took part. For Giants fans, the placement is easy enough to understand. Parcells led New York to two Super Bowl titles and helped establish the franchise as a heavyweight, while also leaving his mark by quickly reviving other struggling teams along the way.
Still, any ranking of Parcells tends to stir up a little New York grumbling because it invites the old comparison game. The Giants have another championship coach in Tom Coughlin, and he did not make CBS Sports list at all despite drawing votes from half the panel. Parcells earned his flowers here, but for a fan base that remembers both eras well, the debate over where he belongs among the all-time greats is never going away. [Read more 🡒]