Great players are nice. Great teams are better.
That’s the tension running through the New York Giants discussion after Ed’s Monday piece on the Pro Football and Sports Network’s Top 100 list. The Giants had three players on it, which at first glance sounds respectable enough in a league with 32 teams and 100 slots. But once you remember that one of those three, Malik Nabers, played fewer than three games before a season-ending injury, even that total starts to feel a little generous.
It also raises the bigger question: does stacking enough top-end talent automatically produce a contender? The answer, at least from PFSN’s 2025 Top 100, looks like no.
The teams with the most players on the list were supposed to be the league’s elite, but the playoff results didn’t line up cleanly. Only eight of the top 12 teams in great players in 2025-26 even reached the postseason.
The Lions finished second on the list with seven Top 100 players and still missed the playoffs. The Eagles led everyone with nine, while the Packers, Steelers, and Chargers each had four - and none of those three got past Wild Card Weekend.
The 49ers and Texans fell in the Divisional Round. The Rams and Broncos made it to the Conference Championship games before losing.
And then there were the Super Bowl teams. Neither one cracked the PFSN Top 12.
Super Bowl champion Seattle had only three Top 100 players - Jaxon Smith-Njigba, Leonard Williams, and Sam Darnold - the same number as the Giants. New England also had three: Drake Maye, Christian Gonzalez, and A.J.
Brown, who wasn’t even a Patriot last year.
That’s why the Giants’ 2026 outlook is such an interesting puzzle. If you want to be optimistic, you can start by assuming Nabers, Brian Burns, and Andrew Thomas land on the list again. After that, the field gets thin fast.
PFSN’s rankings seem to reward the positions the modern NFL values most. Quarterback, wide receiver, edge rusher, and offensive tackle sit near the top; safety, tight end, linebacker, and center are closer to the bottom.
That tracks with how teams pay players, too. The list was also tilted toward offense, with 61% offensive players and 39% defense.
One thing that stood out: no rookies appeared on the Top 100, though several second-year players did. That opens the door for the Giants’ 2025 first-round picks to move into the conversation.
Jaxson Dart finished 23rd among quarterbacks with an impact score of 73.4, which put him 3.2 points behind Jalen Hurts in 16th. Drake Maye led the NFL at 91.8.
PFSN’s quarterback formula weighs EPA/dropback, success rate, average net yards per attempt, completion rate over expected, and designed run value. Dart ranked 12th in rush EPA but only 23rd in overall EPA/dropback, a sign that his passing efficiency - especially on deep throws, which carry the most weight in EPA - still has room to grow.
And of course, he didn’t play a full season.
Abdul Carter landed 38th among edge defenders. PFSN’s edge ranking leans on pass-rush disruption and sacks, with run defense added in. Carter’s rookie sack total wasn’t enough to push him onto the list, but his fourth-place finish in QB hits hints that he’s not far off.
Beyond those three current Giants and those two young first-rounders, the roster is harder to sort into true Top 100 territory. Sisi Mauigoa and Arvell Reese could eventually get there, but they haven’t played a down in the NFL yet.
Cam Skattebo is intriguing and fun, but he still has to get through a full season. Colton Hood or Malachi Fields might surprise.
Outside of that, the star power is tough to spot.
Still, the broader lesson from Seattle is hard to ignore. The Seahawks won the ring with only three Top 100 players.
That’s the reminder here: the NFL doesn’t always reward the team with the flashiest collection of stars. Sometimes it rewards the one with enough quality across the roster, plus coaching that gets the most out of it.
If John Harbaugh and his staff can squeeze real value out of the draftees and free-agent additions who underwhelmed in 2025 and before - even if that value is only solid or simply competent - then 2026 can still turn into a success where it matters most: the win-loss column.
In Other News...
Giants CB2 Battle Just Took A Turn Bigger Names Wont Like
The Giants competition for the second outside cornerback job has already been one of the more interesting camp battles on the roster, with Paulson Adebo, Greg Newsome II, Colton Hood and Deonte Banks all in the mix. Newsome has the edge on paper because of his experience, and the Giants have made clear they want real competition at a position theyve invested in heavily with multiple draft picks.
Art Green is the latest name to surface in the conversation, which adds another wrinkle to a race that already had a few. Mostly known for his work on special teams, Green is now at least being mentioned as someone to watch, and that alone says plenty about how open the Giants want this job to remain as the summer unfolds. [Read more 🡒]
Giants May Have Finally Found The Answer Chicago Gave Up On
The Giants spent the offseason looking for more speed and steadiness at linebacker, and Tremaine Edmunds gives them a proven answer on paper. His size, range and experience should fit a defense that has been searching for more consistency in the middle, and his track record of piling up tackles suggests he can handle a heavy workload right away.
There is also a developmental angle here that could matter just as much for New York in the long run. Edmunds arrives with the kind of veteran presence that can help settle the room while the Giants sort out how their younger linebackers fit, and the hope is that his arrival raises the floor for a unit that needed a reset. What happens next will depend on whether the fit on the field matches the promise of the move. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Face A Defining Question Around Jaxson Dart And This Offense
The Giants 2026 offense is shaping up as one of the more interesting internal tests in the league, because the future of Jaxson Dart is tied to how well Matt Nagy, Brian Callahan and Greg Roman can blend their ideas into something coherent. Dart is still the centerpiece of the conversation, and the organization is clearly trying to build an environment that helps him grow rather than burying him under a system that asks too much too soon.
There is also a little edge to the evaluation around him, since Dart was left out of ESPNs annual survey of top quarterbacks and did not draw a vote from league executives, coaches or scouts. For a young passer trying to establish himself, that kind of omission can linger, and it only adds to the pressure on a staff that has to turn all that offensive input into real progress while the rest of the roster, from Kayvon Thibodeaux to Tyler Nubin, keeps trying to push the team forward. [Read more 🡒]