Dexter Lawrence’s Bengals debut gave the Giants a familiar kind of validation.
The former New York defensive lineman, now wearing Cincinnati stripes after a stunning offseason deal, didn’t register a single stat in his first game with the Bengals against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. No sacks.
No tackles for loss. No tackles at all.
The box score was empty, even if the underlying grades told a different story.
That kind of split is nothing new for Giants fans, who have already seen this movie with Sexy Dexy. Lawrence spent much of his time in New York as a dominant presence who could tilt a game without always stuffing the stat sheet. But the conversation around him changed after the 2025 season, when he was coming off what was described as arguably the worst year of his career.
He had been pushing for a raise after three straight Pro Bowl seasons, and that made sense on paper. But the 2025 production was down across the board: 0.5 sacks, 31 tackles and eight quarterback hits, all career lows.
Still, the advanced numbers painted a different picture. Lawrence finished with a 75.6 PFF grade, ninth among 134 interior defenders, and his 84.5 pass-rush grade ranked seventh.
That’s the version Cincinnati is betting on after sending the 10th overall pick in the 2026 Draft to the Giants and giving Lawrence a $28 million extension through 2028. The Bengals got a player they clearly believe can anchor the middle of their defense, and his first outing did come with a 77.6 overall grade, which placed 11th among 99 interior defenders.
For Giants fans, though, the debut probably felt familiar in another way: the same old debate over how much value lives beyond the box score. New York already moved on once. Now Cincinnati gets to decide how long it can live with a stat line that says nothing, even when the analytics say otherwise.
In Other News...
Giants Have One Costly Problem To Fix Before The Rams
The Giants got the result they wanted in their season opener against the Cowboys, and they also got a reminder that the early part of a season can expose problems as quickly as it can hide them. Young players like Malik Nabers and Jaxson Dart gave the offense a jolt, but the bigger conversation coming out of the game centered on ball security, with John Harbaugh specifically flagging it as an area New York needs to clean up.
That matters even more with the Rams next on the schedule, because giveaways can erase the edge a team earns from energy and youth. Around the team, there is also growing fan chatter about possible trades now that salary cap space has opened up, but before any bigger roster talk takes hold, the Giants have a more immediate task in front of them: making sure the ball stays where it belongs. [Read more 🡒]
Drew Locks Random Giants Win Meant More Than Anyone Realized
Drew Locks odd little Giants win last season has turned into one of those results that keeps echoing well after the final whistle. For New York, it was just another late-year game in a lost season, but it also helped shape the draft board in a way the organization could never have predicted, nudging Tennessee toward the No. 1 pick it eventually used on Cam Ward.
Now Ward is trying to settle in as the Titans quarterback of the future, even as the early returns have been rough, while the Giants are already seeing a different kind of payoff from their own first-rounder in Jaxson Dart. Darts recent performance against Dallas showed why New York is so eager to build around him, and it also made Locks incidental contribution to Tennessees draft fate feel even stranger in retrospect, a small Giants win with a ripple effect that still matters. [Read more 🡒]
Jameis Winston Just Gave Giants Fans Another Reason To Love Him
The Giants win over Dallas already had the locker room feeling loose, and Jameis Winston helped keep it that way when a postgame video of him spraying cologne started making the rounds. Winston, who has quickly become one of the more visible personalities in the building, leaned right into the moment by answering the viral clip with a TikTok of his own. It was the kind of light, self-aware reaction that tends to travel well in a New York market that appreciates confidence when it comes with a sense of humor.
Winstons role remains that of a backup quarterback, but the Giants recently rewarded him with a two-year extension, a sign they value more than just the arm he brings to the room. For a team coming off a win against Dallas, having a veteran who can absorb attention without making it about himself is no small thing. The only question now is how much more of this side of Winston the Giants will keep getting as the season goes on. [Read more 🡒]