The Giants may have landed the kind of defensive talent that changes a draft conversation overnight, and the Cardinals and Titans are the teams left staring at what got away.
When New York used the fifth overall pick in the 2026 Draft on Ohio State linebacker Arvell Reese, the reaction came with both excitement and questions about where he fit. Eight games into his rookie year, the fit talk is fading fast. Reese is looking like one of the best defensive players in football, and he’s doing it at 21 years old.
The numbers tell the story in a hurry. Through nine weeks, Reese has piled up 68 tackles, 4.5 sacks, eight tackles for loss, an interception, four passes defensed, and a forced fumble. He’s the only player in the NFL this season with at least 65 tackles, eight tackles for loss, and a pick.
Then he turned Sunday’s 19-11 Week 9 win over the Philadelphia Eagles into his own highlight reel. Reese finished with 12 tackles, three sacks, and a forced fumble, becoming the youngest player in NFL history to record three sacks in a game.
That kind of production is exactly why Arizona and Tennessee are the teams under the microscope. The Cardinals went with Notre Dame running back Jeremiyah Love at No. 3, while the Titans took Ohio State wide receiver Carnell Tate at No.
- Neither pick is ready to be stamped a mistake this early, but Reese’s start has made the comparison impossible to ignore.
Love has 268 rushing yards on 3.5 yards per carry in six games and is now on injured reserve with a high ankle sprain. Arizona’s defense is also giving up 28.3 points per game, second-worst in the league behind only the Las Vegas Raiders. In that kind of setup, a player with Reese’s range and impact looks awfully tempting in hindsight.
Tennessee’s situation is a little different. Tate has been productive right away, with 34 catches for 413 yards through seven games, and he already looks like Cam Ward’s top option. For a young quarterback, that kind of dependable target is valuable, and Tate has done enough to justify the fourth pick.
Still, Reese has already had his chances to make the Cardinals and Titans feel the miss. The Giants beat both teams, and Reese showed up in both games. He had 13 tackles against Tennessee in Week 3, then followed that with nine tackles, three pass breakups, and an interception against Arizona in Week 4.
There’s a long way to go before the 2026 Draft gets its final verdict. Love could still turn into a star, and Tate is clearly trending in the right direction. But if Reese keeps playing like this, Arizona and Tennessee may be stuck thinking about what they passed on for a very long time.
In Other News...
Giants Still Hover Over Jonathan Taylor As Trade Market Tightens
The Colts are still trying to move Jonathan Taylor before the NFL trade deadline, and the market has not exactly rushed to meet them. Denver, Green Bay and Minnesota all reportedly checked in, but the price Indianapolis has been asking has kept those conversations from getting very far, leaving the running back situation in a holding pattern as the deadline approaches.
For the Giants, the possibility has not gone away entirely. New York remains in the mix as a potential trade partner, but the talks have reportedly stalled, which leaves the team hovering rather than advancing toward a deal. With other suitors backing off and the deadline drawing closer, the Giants are still one of the names to watch if the Colts decide to soften their stance. [Read more 🡒]
J.J. McCarthy Is Making The Vikings Look Worse By The Week
J.J. McCarthys exit from Minnesota has only sharpened the scrutiny on the Vikings quarterback choices, and the ripple effect has been felt all the way to New York. The Giants picked up McCarthy for a fifth-round draft pick after he was ruled out for the season with a knee injury, a low-cost move that suddenly looks a lot more interesting as the former Viking settles into a new opportunity.
Minnesota, meanwhile, has been trying to steady its own quarterback picture by turning back to Kirk Cousins, a reset that underscores how unsettled the position has become. For the Giants, McCarthys arrival offered a chance to take a flier on a talented passer at the right price, while the Vikings are left weighing what went wrong and what comes next after letting him go. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Made One Late Call That Felt Bigger Than A Week 18 Win
The final snap of the Giants Week 18 win carried a little more weight than the scoreboard suggested, because it showed something about how this staff wants to finish games. Philadelphia quarterback Joe Milton had pushed a late drive to midfield, but New York didnt sit back and protect the boundary. Defensive coordinator Dennard Wilson kept the pressure on, and the result was a game-ending stop that fit the more aggressive tone the Giants have been trying to establish.
Darius Alexander was the one who got home to end it, and the call behind that moment stood out as much as the play itself. Instead of retreating into conservative coverage and hoping the clock would run out, the Giants trusted their rush to close the door. For a team looking for signs of a different identity, that final decision felt like more than a routine finish to a late-season win. [Read more 🡒]