Arvell Reese is making the kind of early splash that changes the conversation fast.
A quarter of the way into the season, the New York Giants linebacker has not only lived up to the hype around him - he’s pushed himself to the front of the Defensive Rookie of the Year race. The No. 5 overall pick was viewed as a consensus top-five talent during the 2026 NFL Draft process, but he’s already playing like a player who might have gone even higher.
That’s the part that stands out most: Reese has been everywhere the Giants need him. He looks comfortable handling different responsibilities, and he’s living up to the “chess piece” label he gave himself. After helping New York move into sole possession of first place in the NFC East for the first time since 2020, his case is only getting louder.
The Giants’ rookie isn’t the only first-year defender making noise, of course. There’s a real crowd at the top of the board, and the early DROY picture is starting to sort itself out after four games.
Kansas City cornerback Mansoor Delane comes in at No. 5.
He’s been a major part of the Chiefs’ 4-0 start after they traded up for him in the spring, and he’s helped soften the blow of losing Trent McDuffie and Jaylen Watson to the Los Angeles Rams this offseason. Delane missed Week 2 with a shoulder issue, but through Week 4 he still has eight defensive stops, the fifth-most among rookies, and he’s allowed a 72.9 opponent passer rating and a 56.3 completion percentage on targets among 75 corners with at least 10 targets.
Even so, positional value could work against him unless he turns this into a truly dominant season.
At No. 4 is New York Jets edge rusher David Bailey, and the early returns look exactly like the kind of pass-rushing production teams hoped for when he came out of Texas Tech. Bailey is tied for the rookie lead in total pressures with 11, ranks second in hurries with seven, and is the only rookie with more than one sack, sitting at 2.0.
He’s also added a forced fumble and a pass deflection. The rush is there; the all-around impact just hasn’t been enough yet to climb higher.
Washington Commanders linebacker Sonny Styles checks in at No. 3, and the athletic profile is impossible to miss. The Giants considered him, and it’s easy to see why.
With veteran Frankie Luvu sidelined, Styles became Washington’s primary on-field play-caller and handled it well. He turned 22 in November, but he’s playing like a veteran.
Against the Seattle Seahawks, he matched a running back step for step in Washington’s upset win, and that kind of range keeps showing up.
Jacob Rodriguez sits at No. 2, and he’s the current betting favorite to win the award. The Miami Dolphins linebacker has already become the defense’s field general, becoming the only rookie to wear the green dot in Week 1.
He’s second in the league in combined tackles with 46, behind only Alex Singleton of the Denver Broncos, and he piled up 18 tackles in a 15-10 loss to the Minnesota Vikings. The Texas Tech product has done plenty to keep Miami from completely falling apart, but the team’s record remains a major obstacle in the award race.
That brings it back to Reese, who is sitting at No. 1 for now. Team success matters in these debates, and the Giants’ 3-1 start gives his candidacy a strong lift.
Still, the numbers are doing plenty of work on their own. Reese leads the league with 27 solo tackles and is allowing just 6.6 yards per reception in coverage.
New York is using him all over the field, and he’s responding like an every-down difference-maker. His sideline-to-sideline range, physicality and elite athleticism have shown up in the run game and in coverage, where he’s limiting yards after the catch. The Giants also got a look at him in their first game without Brian Burns, and that only added to the sense that Reese’s versatility is real and his ceiling is still ahead of him.
In Other News...
Giants Add A Receiver With Ties Fans Definitely Did Not Expect
The Giants are adding another wide receiver to the mix, signing Dontae Fleming to the practice squad after bringing him in for a visit. Fleming has spent time with the Vikings, and his path to New York comes with some unusual familiar faces, including ties to Giants players Dalen Cambre and J.J. McCarthy.
The move also adds another layer to a transaction cycle that has linked the two teams in recent days, with Minnesota signing recently released Giants player Odell Beckham Jr. to its practice squad. For New York, Fleming is a low-risk depth addition, but the connections around him make this a little more interesting than your typical roster shuffle. [Read more 🡒]
Odell Beckham Jr. Just Landed Another NFL Chance After Giants Exit
The Vikings are taking a low-risk look at Odell Beckham Jr., signing the veteran receiver to their practice squad as they try to patch together depth at a position that has been hit hard by injuries, including the absence of Justin Jefferson. Beckhams latest NFL opportunity comes not long after his release from the Giants, giving him a chance to quickly move from a familiar stop back into another contenders orbit.
What happens next is still up in the air, including whether Beckham will be available for the upcoming game against the New Orleans Saints. For a player trying to re-establish himself after leaving New York, Minnesota offers a path back into the conversation, but first he has to get through the week and show he can be more than a short-term depth answer. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Keep Sending The Same Frustrating Message About Jalin Hyatt
Braxton Berrios landing on injured reserve after the foot injury he suffered in Week 4 changes the Giants special teams picture in a hurry, with Charlie Jones expected to step in as the teams primary punt and kick returner. It is another one of those early-season roster shifts that usually creates an opening somewhere else, especially for a receiver trying to climb into the mix.
Jalin Hyatt, though, still does not appear close to being that guy. Even with Berrios out and Odell Beckham Jr. gone, the Giants remain reluctant to promote Hyatt to the active roster, a sign that his limited production since entering the league is still weighing on his standing. For a team that could use more juice on offense, the message has been frustratingly consistent. [Read more 🡒]