The Giants have spent 45 years waiting for another Defensive Rookie of the Year, ever since Lawrence Taylor took the honor in 1981. Arvell Reese is making that drought look a lot less safe.
Nine games into his NFL career, the 21-year-old has surged into the conversation as the betting favorite for the award, and his impact has helped give New York’s defense the look of a unit built for January under new defensive coordinator Dennard Wilson. The rookie’s rise has been strong enough to invite a fresh comparison, this one against Browns linebacker Carson Schwesinger, last season’s Defensive Rookie of the Year.
Schwesinger won the award in 2025 after piling up 156 tackles and beating out Seattle’s Nick Emmanwori and Atlanta’s James Pearce Jr. in the voting. He collected 40 of 50 first-place votes, so the result was never really in doubt. Through the same first nine games of their careers, though, Reese has already put together a case that stacks up favorably.
The numbers tell the story plainly. Reese has tripled Schwesinger’s sack total through nine games and added 23 more solo tackles.
He’s also flashed as a pass rusher, most notably with his three-sack explosion against the Philadelphia Eagles in Week 9. That kind of production gives New York options, whether the Giants keep him as an off-ball linebacker or lean more into his ability to attack the quarterback.
The award’s recent history only makes Reese’s start look more impressive. Before Schwesinger claimed it last season, an off-ball linebacker hadn’t won DROY since Shaq Leonard in 2018. Reese now has a shot to make it back-to-back wins for the position for the first time since Jerod Mayo and Brian Cushing did it in 2008 and 2009.
There are still hurdles ahead. Schwesinger did some of his best work in the second half of his rookie year, so Reese still has plenty of season left to navigate.
Jets edge rusher David Bailey is already up to 7.5 sacks, and the race isn’t limited to one type of defender. Pearce Jr. finished with 10.5 sacks last year and still didn’t win, which is a reminder that this award isn’t simply about piling up pass-rush numbers.
Even so, last year’s voting showed that double-digit sacks aren’t a requirement. Reese has already outperformed Schwesinger in nearly every major statistical category through nine games, and if that keeps up, the argument for him only gets stronger. After 45 years, the Giants finally have a rookie defender with a real chance to end the wait.
In Other News...
Giants Get An Encouraging Jaxson Dart Update Fans Needed To Hear
The Giants have managed to show real offensive improvement this season even while cycling through three different quarterbacks, and that alone has made the year feel a little more stable than many expected. J.J. McCarthy has put together strong statistical work, while linebacker Arvell Reese has quickly become one of the leagues more intriguing defensive rookie candidates, giving the team a few legitimate building blocks on both sides of the ball.
Jaxson Darts knee situation now offers another reason for optimism, even if the bigger picture still points to a cautious approach. The latest update on the injured quarterback was encouraging, and for a team that has spent much of the season navigating uncertainty under center, any positive sign on Dart matters. A return this season still looks unlikely, but the news at least gives the Giants something to carry forward as they keep sorting out the long view at quarterback. [Read more 🡒]
Jaxson Dart Just Reached A Recovery Point Giants Fans Needed To See
Jaxson Dart is officially off crutches and walking again after surgery to repair the torn MCL, PCL and meniscus he suffered in Week 2, a small but meaningful step for a Giants team that has spent the season moving on without him. For a quarterback whose injury quickly became one of the defining setbacks of the year, simply getting back on his feet offers a visible sign that the recovery process is moving in the right direction.
The bigger picture still hasnt changed much for New York, though. Darts recovery is expected to take four to six months, which makes a playoff return look unlikely, and the Giants have had to keep pushing ahead with J.J. McCarthy at the controls. Even so, seeing Dart out of crutches gives the organization and its fans something they have not had in a while: proof that the next stage of his comeback is underway. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Draft Projection Ties Them To Two Fits Fans Will Debate
A fresh mock draft has the Giants looking ahead to 2026 with a clear theme: fortify the trenches and give the passing game another weapon. The projection has Oregon defensive tackle A'Mauri Washington going in the first round, a move that fits the long-running push to keep adding size and disruption up front, while Rutgers wide receiver KJ Duff is slotted in the second round as a way to help a receiving corps that still needs more juice.
It is the kind of pairing that will spark debate because it speaks to two different kinds of need, one built on defense and one on offense. The reasoning behind both picks is straightforward enough, but for Giants fans, the real intrigue is how those fits would reshape a roster that has spent too long trying to patch holes instead of filling them with premium talent. [Read more 🡒]
