How should the Giants read Abdul Carter right now? The short answer is that the rookie edge rusher looks far better than the sack column says.
Joe Schoen’s first-round track record in New York has given the Giants a little bit of everything. Kayvon Thibodeaux has been useful even if he hasn’t quite lived up to the expectations attached to a No. 5 pick.
Evan Neal was a major miss. Deonte Banks looked like he might wash out, but under Dennard Wilson he’s playing like a Pro Bowler.
Malik Nabers looks headed for another Pro Bowl level season. Arvell Reese has been everything you could want so far, and Jaxson Dart has also delivered, even with imported first-rounder J.J.
McCarthy starting to push him. Sisi Mauigoa has needed an adjustment period, though he played well against Houston.
That leaves Carter, and he’s the puzzling one.
On the eye test, he’s constantly showing up in the backfield. On the stat sheet, though, the sacks aren’t piling up the way you’d expect. That creates the basic question: is he actually dominating, or just flashing without finishing?
For an edge defender, the job is bigger than sacks. There’s run defense, coverage on some snaps, and taking on blocks so someone else can get home. But when you take a player at No. 3, the main expectation is still clear: affect the quarterback.
PFF’s numbers say Carter is already doing that at a high level. In his rookie year, he posted an 84.5 pass rush grade, which ranked 11th among NFL edge defenders.
The names above him were the usual monsters: Myles Garrett, Micah Parsons, Will Anderson Jr., Aidan Hutchinson, and the rest of the league’s top-tier rushers. In 2026, he’s climbed even higher.
According to PFF, Carter is No. 4 in the NFL overall in pass rush grade. Narrow the lens to true pass sets - which strip out plays like screens, rollouts, and play-action looks that can muddy the evaluation - and Carter rises all the way to No. 1 among edge defenders.
The tracking data backs that up. ESPN Analytics, using RFID tags in players’ shoulder pads, had Carter tied for No. 1 among edge rushers in pass rush win rate as of Oct.
- He’s also being double-teamed a bit more often than some others in that top group, though the rate is still in line with what top-20 players around the league tend to see.
So the issue is not whether Carter is winning against his blocker. He is. The issue is what happens after that win.
That’s where the story gets more interesting. A thread from Ben Linsey of Sumer Sports points out that Carter’s pass-rush wins aren’t showing up as sacks and pressures at the same level as the other elite rushers. But the wins are still changing the game.
When Carter beats his man, the defense’s EPA per play is three times more negative than it is on the average pass rusher’s win, which is a good thing for the defense. In other words, even when Carter isn’t the one collecting the sack, he may still be forcing the offense into a quicker decision than it wants.
The logic is pretty simple: if he’s winning that fast, quarterbacks and coordinators have to react. That can mean shorter routes, quicker throws, less room to operate, or rushed passes that are less accurate. Either way, the offense is working under pressure even when the box score doesn’t fully show it.
That’s why Carter’s lack of sack totals may be more misleading than concerning. If the numbers are telling the truth, opponents are already adjusting to him. And if that holds, his visible production could tick up in the second half of the season.
In Other News...
Giants In First Place But One Roster Decision Just Got Tougher
The Giants have spent enough time grinding through quarterback uncertainty and lineup shuffling that first place in the NFC East feels earned rather than accidental. J.J. McCarthy gave the offense a lift in his first start, Jaxson Dart is still working his way back in rehab, and the defense has continued to hold up its end, with Deonte Banks turning in effective coverage against the Texans as the team kept building momentum.
A few roster calls have helped shape that rise, too, including the decision to move on from running back Najee Harris before the recent win. But the next layer of roster management is where things get trickier now, especially with Tyrone Tracys situation putting added pressure on the backfield picture and forcing the Giants to weigh depth against the urgency of staying on top in a division race that suddenly looks very real. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Bye Week Lead Faces Its Biggest Test Yet
The Giants spent their Week 8 bye in a place they have not been in for a while: sitting atop the NFC East with a 4-2-1 record and a two-game cushion. It has not been a comfortable kind of lead, though. Their wins have come by narrow margins, and the defense has had to keep finding answers through takeaways even while dealing with injuries to key players.
Now the schedule tightens fast, with division games looming that could reshape the race in a hurry. For a team that has already lived on close calls, the next stretch is the real measure of whether this early advantage means something lasting or just a brief turn in the standings. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Face A Defining NFC East Stretch With Pressure Suddenly Rising
The Giants head into their bye week on the heels of a win over the Houston Texans, but the break only delays what looks like a pivotal stretch for their season. With the NFC East still within reach and John Harbaugh stressing how important the coming division games are for the teams place in the race, the next few weeks carry a different kind of weight for a club that has spent much of the fall trying to establish itself at the top of the standings.
The pressure only grows because the Cowboys have recently moved ahead of the Giants as the betting favorite in the division, even though New York still holds the lead in the standings. The schedule coming out of the bye leaves little room to settle in, and the Giants will also have to manage their backfield depth after placing Tyrone Tracy Jr. on injured reserve, a reminder that every edge matters as the division chase tightens. [Read more 🡒]