Tyler Shoughs Struggles Are Forcing A Saints Debate Fans Know Too Well

Despite recent setbacks and growing criticisms, Tyler Shough still holds promise as he navigates challenges at quarterback for the Saints.

Tyler Shough’s rough Sunday against the Carolina Panthers was enough to set off the usual NFL overreactions, but it shouldn’t be the end of the conversation about his future as a starter.

Shough had the worst outing of his young career in the loss, missing wide-open targets, struggling to push the ball downfield and getting squeezed by clean pockets. Those were the kinds of mistakes he largely avoided last season, which is why the recent dip stands out so sharply. Instead of building on that progress, he’s looked more like a quarterback sliding backward over the past few weeks.

That’s why some are already pushing the New Orleans Saints toward another quarterback this offseason. But that kind of rush to judgment ignores how much Shough has been asked to carry. He has been forced to play like a hero nearly every week, and that’s a brutal assignment for any quarterback - especially one still early in his development.

The Saints’ lack of a run game has only made things harder. So has Shough’s broken hand.

Add in the offensive line’s pass-blocking issues, and the picture gets even messier. It’s easy to say a quarterback is making excuses, and eventually those excuses run out, but right now it’s difficult to separate Shough’s mistakes from the pressure around him.

Even when the pocket looks manageable, he appears to feel it closing fast, which has led to quicker checkdowns.

Kellen Moore deserves credit for helping Shough develop last season. The gap between Shough’s preseason play and what he showed as a starter was significant, and that growth matters.

It also raises the possibility that moving on from Moore midseason could hurt Shough’s progress. At the same time, the recent lack of support around the quarterback - especially in the run game and in pass protection - has not helped him.

For now, Shough is not the Saints’ long-term answer at quarterback. A new staff would be right to explore options.

But there have also been stretches where Shough has played like a top-15 quarterback, and that is no small thing for any coach walking into the job. Before anyone makes a final call on what he is in New Orleans, he needs to be seen in another offense first.

In Other News...

Saints Fans Have A New WR Reason For Hope After Week 10

Jordyn Tysons second NFL game gave Saints fans a fresh reason to keep watching the receiver room a little more closely. After a delayed debut because of a hamstring injury, the rookie wideout stepped into the matchup with Carolina and immediately looked like a player the offense could lean on, catching 11 passes for 80 yards while leading New Orleans in both receptions and receiving yards.

Arizona State coach Kenny Dillingham took notice, too, after reviewing Tysons targets through PFF and coming away impressed with what he saw. For a Saints team still sorting out its passing-game hierarchy, that kind of early production from a rookie is the sort of development that can change the conversation quickly, even if there is still plenty left for Tyson to prove. [Read more 🡒]

Saints May Have Found Alvin Kamaras Most Dangerous New Role

Alvin Kamaras usage in the Saints recent game against Carolina offered a different look at how New Orleans may want to deploy its most versatile weapon going forward. He played just 16 snaps, with most of them coming on the final drive, but the touches he did get were concentrated in the spots where he can do the most damage. In a game where the Saints needed efficiency more than volume, Kamara was used as a change-of-pace back in red-zone and late-game situations, and he made the approach look awfully practical.

For a player who has long carried a heavy workload, the shift could be a welcome one for both Kamara and the offense. It gives New Orleans a way to preserve him while still putting him in position to tilt games when the field shortens and the pressure rises. The bigger question now is whether this was just a one-game wrinkle or the start of a more deliberate role adjustment that could change how the Saints handle their most dangerous offensive piece. [Read more 🡒]

Saints Have A Bigger Problem Than Falling Behind In The NFC South

The NFC South picture after Week 10 still leaves room for movement, but New Orleans is dealing with a more basic problem than the standings. Tampa Bay is sitting in second during its bye, with Baker Mayfields status still unsettled, Carolina has nudged into first and gets Baltimore next, and Atlanta is heading into a bye after another rough defensive showing against Kansas City. For the Saints, though, the issue is less about chasing the division and more about whether the offense can find any kind of rhythm at all.

New Orleans has been stuck trying to patch together a run game while Tyler Shough plays through a broken hand, and the results have only sharpened the bigger concern around the franchise. When a team is fighting for traction in the division and still cant get its offense organized, the conversation quickly moves beyond play-calling and personnel. In this case, it has started to sound like the Saints may need more than a midseason fix. [Read more 🡒]