Before the Saints even got to the Giants game, Ed Werder floated Chase Young as a trade name worth watching, tied to New Orleans’ lack of success. That idea didn’t hold up for long.
The post Werder was responding to had the better read. It pointed to Young’s dominant stretch over a 17-game span, with the edge rusher missing the first five games of last season, so the numbers were adjusted to give him a full-season sample. In that window, Young piled up 14 sacks, which ranked third in the league.
At first glance, the trade chatter may not sound outrageous. For the Saints specifically, though, it makes almost no sense.
New Orleans is struggling, yes, but moving Young would be a painfully short-sighted decision. It also isn’t going to happen.
Shipping off Chase Young would amount to the Saints waving off the season and the Kellen Moore era before it really has a chance to settle in. Young is a foundational piece on this defense for the years ahead.
He has produced at a high level, and he has also shown himself to be a phenomenal leader. He’s the kind of player a team is supposed to build around, not cash out on.
If a club is heading into a rebuild, then trading away top talent can be part of the plan. That’s when teams move their best players to save money or collect picks. The Saints are in the middle of one, and Young is a central part of it.
And this isn’t about some rebound after the Giants game, either. New Orleans didn’t win and suddenly spark a turnaround there. The larger point is the state of the franchise right now.
National media has a habit of wanting good players on good teams, but that logic doesn’t always fit the reality of rebuilding. Young has only been in New Orleans for three seasons, and he does not fit the old image of Joe Thomas grinding through a decade with the Browns.
The bigger issue is simple: if good players are pushed off struggling teams every time things get tough, those teams never get the chance to climb out of the hole. The Saints would be fools to trade Young, even if they dropped every game before the deadline. He’s the kind of player you expect to help pull a team back in the right direction, and New Orleans does not seem talent-starved enough to justify letting him go.
In Other News...
Kellen Moores Late Decision Put Saints Fans On Edge
The Saints were in control against the Giants with a 24-point cushion and just 10 minutes left, the kind of lead that should let a team spend the final stretch cleaning things up and getting out healthy. Instead, the fourth quarter turned into an uneasy finish, with head coach Kellen Moore making late substitutions to manage soreness and keep his starters from taking unnecessary hits.
Once the backups were in, the game took on a different feel and the margin of error vanished quickly. New Orleans then had to watch the Giants seize momentum, turning a promising ending into a postgame conversation about both the collapse itself and the timing of Moores decision to juggle the lineup when the outcome still needed to be secured. [Read more 🡒]
Saints Finally Found An Offensive Formula Fans Have Been Waiting For
The Saints finally leaned into a ground game that looked far more like the one fans have been waiting to see in Week 6 against the Giants. New Orleans ran the ball 38 times for 175 yards, with Alvin Kamara, Kendre Miller and C.J. Donaldson giving the offense a steadier rhythm and providing the kind of balance that can take pressure off a young quarterback.
Jeremiah Wright also emerged as a factor after stepping in for an injured lineman, helping the front settle in as the night went on. Tyler Shough added 32 rushing yards of his own, and even with backup Giants quarterback J.J. McCarthy pushing late through the air, the Saints had enough on the ground to finish the job and leave a much different offensive impression than they have in recent weeks. [Read more 🡒]
Saints Game Just Intensified The Giants J.J. McCarthy Debate
Adam Thielens take on J.J. McCarthy after the game offered a glimpse into why the Giants sideline and locker room left with far more optimism than the final score suggested. New York was still chasing the Saints when McCarthy was inserted late, and the quarterbacks arrival changed the tone of the night enough that even in defeat, there was a clear sense of momentum around what he had just done.
Thielen also framed the moment as part of McCarthys fresh start in New York after the trade from Minnesota, which only adds to the intrigue for Saints fans who watched the comeback effort unfold. The loss still stings for the Giants, but the way McCarthy finished the game has already pushed the conversation beyond one result and into what comes next for a team trying to find stability at quarterback. [Read more 🡒]