The Saints’ kicker job is going to come down to something a lot less glamorous than leg strength.
When New Orleans opens training camp on July 29, Charlie Smyth and Tanner Brown will be fighting for a roster spot, and both can boom the ball well beyond 65 yards. That part is not really the issue. What matters is whether either one can be steady from 30 to 49 yards, because that’s where this battle is going to be decided.
Smyth enters camp as the favorite. He’s been on the roster since 2024 and showed some promise in the second half of last season.
His overall line - 12-for-16 - doesn’t jump off the page, but only two of those misses came from inside 50 yards. He also was perfect on extra points, going 13-for-13.
Brown, though, is not just there to fill a camp slot. The former UFL kicker is a real challenger, and his numbers back that up.
Last season with the Louisville Kings, he hit 29 of 32 field goals and missed only once from under 50 yards. The UFL has already produced kickers who made it in the NFL, with Brandon Aubrey of the Dallas Cowboys and Jake Bate of the Detroit Lions serving as examples, and Brown is trying to be the next one in that line.
For the Saints, the standard is simple: make the “easy kicks.”
Last season’s kicking situation, especially with Blake Grupe, was a mess. New Orleans finished last in the NFL by converting just 71.4% of its field-goal tries. That kind of production is hard to live with, even if the rest of the roster had bigger problems at the time.
This year, the margin for error is much smaller. The Saints are trying to compete in the NFC South in 2026, and three points can swing games. That means the kicker has to be dependable, especially from inside 50 yards, where the expectation is that those attempts should be going through.
There’s recent history here, too. In 2025, the Saints held a similar camp competition between Blake Grupe and Smyth.
Both had strong legs, but Grupe won out by doing the basics well and knocking down the short kicks. Smyth had trouble in that area, and that made Kellen Moore’s decision straightforward.
Now the roles are flipped. Smyth is the front-runner instead of the challenger, but he still has to prove he can handle the routine work. If he doesn’t, Brown is right there to take the job.
This won’t be the loudest storyline in camp, but it could end up mattering plenty. The Saints’ next kicker won’t be judged by 60-yard fireworks. He’ll be judged by whether he can keep the “easy kicks” easy.
In Other News...
Ranking The Saints Rookies Who Could Force Their Way Into Week 1
Training camp is where a rookie class starts to sort itself out, and the Saints have a few newcomers who could make the opening-week conversation more interesting than expected. The group includes draft picks and undrafted free agents, and the early evaluation is less about pedigree than about who can handle the competition at their position, earn trust quickly and make the most of the chances in front of them.
Among the names worth watching, some have clearer paths than others because of contract guarantees, college experience and the depth chart they are walking into. A few could push their way into real roles if they translate their traits fast enough, whether that means adding value in a crowded backfield, holding an edge in a camp battle or challenging a veteran starter if the right details come together. [Read more 🡒]
Saints Camp Is Already Testing Kellen Moores New Offensive Vision
The first days of Saints training camp are already offering a look at how Kellen Moore wants this offense to take shape, with Tyler Shough opening as the starting quarterback and a cluster of rookies pushing for early roles. New faces are everywhere in the mix, including first-round pick Jordyn Tyson, while the team also has to sort out how to distribute touches in a backfield that now includes Alvin Kamara and Travis Etienne Jr.
There is some longer-term business hanging over camp as well, with Chris Olave still in contract discussions even as he remains part of the offensive picture. And while the Saints will get multiple practices in front of fans, they will do so without Demario Davis, leaving one of the defenses most trusted voices on the sideline as the offenses new identity starts to come into focus. [Read more 🡒]
Former Saints First Round Pick Just Got One More NFL Chance
Clyde Edwards-Helaire is still trying to find a foothold in the NFL, and the former Saints first-round pick got another look this week when the Dolphins brought him in for a workout. Miami is heading into training camp with six running backs in the mix, so any addition at the position would have to earn its way onto a crowded board rather than walk into a clear path.
For Edwards-Helaire, the appeal is simple enough: he has enough NFL experience to be more than just a camp body, but recent seasons have made every chance matter a little more. He has played in only four games over the last two years, and the Dolphins broader workout session, which also included quarterbacks, receivers and even a rugby player, showed they were casting a wide net while sorting out the back end of the roster. [Read more 🡒]