NFL instant replay chief Mark Butterworth defended the call that turned Tyler Shough’s hit into a fumble recovery for the Las Vegas Raiders, saying the replay booth had enough to stand with the ruling on the field.
The play added another layer to a rough day for the New Orleans Saints, who were already dealing with a string of missed calls from Adrian Hill’s officiating crew. New Orleans saw the Raiders escape several obvious penalties, while the Saints defense was flagged four times for automatic first down conversions. The Saints, by contrast, got only one such break after collecting five in the first two weeks.
The biggest flashpoint came when Shough was struck as he started his throwing motion. The ball came loose, the Raiders recovered, and the call stood after review - a decision that felt uncomfortably familiar to New Orleans after a nearly identical sequence in Week 1.
In a postgame pool report to the Times-Picayune | Advocate's Luke Johnson, Butterworth explained the replay process this way:
"With the ruling on the field of a fumble recovered by the defense, that is an automatic booth review which any automatic booth review is either confirmed with New York to confirm the ruling on the field, or we stop the game if we need to. On that play, we were able to confirm that the defenders' right hand hit the ball and the hand.
The quarterback clearly lost control of the ball before his hand was coming forward. We were able to confirm the ruling on the field."
Johnson then asked whether Butterworth saw any difference between that play and the “very similar play” from Week 1, when a Saints defensive touchdown return was wiped out after a fumble was ruled an incomplete pass. Butterworth answered:
"All we are looking for is the hand coming forward with control to make it an incomplete pass. In the play that happened today, the hand was not coming forward with control of the ball."
For New Orleans, the explanation didn’t do much to ease the frustration. In Detroit, the story was that Jared Goff had intended to throw forward even after being spun around and having the ball fly behind him, and the Saints paid for it when points came off the board.
This time, the same general situation broke the other way and helped swing a loss. The Saints have now been hurt by different rulings from the same type of play, and in both cases, they were the ones left absorbing the damage.
In Other News...
Saints Fans Have Every Reason To Hate This Tyler Shough Ruling
The Saints had another rough Week 3 finish against the Raiders, and one sequence involving Tyler Shough has only added to the frustration. The NFL upheld the ruling on the field, saying Shough lost control of the ball before his arm started moving forward, leaving the play as a fumble and not an incomplete pass.
For Saints fans, the irritation is obvious because the league handled a similar-looking situation differently in Week 1 when Jared Goff was involved. NFL vice president of instant replay Mark Butterworth explained why the two plays were separated, but the explanation is unlikely to make New Orleans feel any better about how the call broke in a game already going the wrong way. [Read more 🡒]
Saints Collapse Came Down To Tyler Shough And One Brutal Call
The Saints had their best early footing under Kellen Moore on Sunday, jumping ahead after the first quarter and giving themselves a chance to carry that edge into a needed win over the Raiders. Instead, the game unraveled late in a 35-27 loss, with New Orleans giving the ball away four times in the fourth quarter and watching a promising night slip into a frustrating collapse.
Tyler Shough was at the center of it, with multiple turnovers and a strip that led to one of the games most contentious moments, when Las Vegas came away with the fumble recovery. A late Juwan Johnson fumble only deepened the damage as the Raiders kept answering with offense, leaving the Saints to sort through how a game they once controlled turned so quickly in the final period. [Read more 🡒]
Saints Let A Winnable Game Slip Away For One Infuriating Reason
For most of the afternoon, the Saints looked like a team that had done enough to put themselves in position to win. They had the lead against the Lions, got solid work from Travis Etienne, Tyler Shough and Fuaga, and saw productive stretches from tight ends Juwan Johnson and Noah Fant, all of which made the game feel very much there for the taking.
Instead, New Orleans watched a winnable result slip away in a finish that left plenty to gripe about. The late interception from Shough hurt, Etiennes hamstring issue added to the concern, and the officiating only sharpened the frustration around a loss that felt far more avoidable than inevitable. [Read more 🡒]