The Saints don’t need to keep debating Daniel Carlson. They need to move on.
New Orleans brought him in late in the offseason after Charlie Smyth and Tanner Brown both lost the job, hoping a nine-year veteran and former first-team All-Pro selection would steady the kicking game. Instead, Carlson has given them the opposite: inconsistency, missed opportunities, and no real reason to trust him in big moments.
The numbers tell the story plainly. Carlson is tied for the lowest field goal percentage in the NFL at 66.7%, and he has also missed two extra points. For a Saints special teams unit that already dealt with struggles from Blake Grupe and Charlie Smyth last year, that’s a fresh low.
It hasn’t been a one-game issue, either. Carlson has missed a kick in six of the Saints’ seven games and is 3/7 from 50+ yards.
In a career that once included high-level reliability, he has only had one season below 80% on field goals, finishing at 73.1% in 2019. Right now, though, he isn’t playing like the kicker New Orleans thought it was getting.
That’s why this should not drag on any longer. The Saints played Sunday, and there’s no reason Carlson should still be on this team Tuesday morning.
Kellen Moore should have made the switch earlier, but the bye week makes the decision even cleaner now. Bringing in another kicker sooner rather than later would give New Orleans time to evaluate the new option and get him ready before the next game.
The Saints also wouldn’t be breaking new ground by making a midseason move. The Los Angeles Rams cut Harrison Mevis on October 13, two weeks ago.
What New Orleans is looking for now is simple. It’s not a franchise kicker, but a dependable one - somebody who can handle extra points and finish late-game field goals. Carlson hasn’t done either with enough consistency to justify sticking with him.
There’s no reason for Moore to spend the entire bye week wondering about the position. Waiting only shortens the adjustment window for whoever comes next, and it also gives other kicker-needy teams a chance to shop before the Saints do.
So the answer is obvious. The Saints should stop delaying the inevitable and make the change as soon as possible. There’s no rational case for keeping Daniel Carlson after this start.
In Other News...
Tyrann Mathieus Frustration Just Raised A Bigger Saints Roster Question
After the loss to Pittsburgh, the Saints found themselves dealing with more than just another frustrating result. Tyrann Mathieu made his irritation plain, pointing to the offensive lines inability to help in the run game and tying it to the bigger roster sacrifices he has made in recent seasons to give New Orleans more flexibility.
The running attack never got going, with the Saints finishing with just 18 rushing yards on 17 carries and the line creating no room before contact. For a team trying to make every roster decision count, that kind of production only sharpens the questions around how much support the offense can realistically expect up front. [Read more 🡒]
Saints Hit A Trade Deadline Crossroads With Bigger Stakes Than One Move
With the trade deadline approaching, the Saints find themselves in an awkward spot: close enough to a reset to consider selling, but still under pressure to show progress in a season that has not gone the way anyone in the building wanted. The roster has already been part of deadline chatter before, with previous moves involving Rashid Shaheed and Trevor Penning serving as reminders that New Orleans is willing to make decisions with both the present and the future in mind.
Now the focus shifts to whether the front office tries to create more flexibility by moving veteran pieces, even as the coaching staff and general manager Mickey Loomis are feeling the heat if the season does not stabilize. Davon Godchaux has emerged as the likeliest name to watch, with Justin Reid and Cesar Ruiz also mentioned as possible options, which tells you the Saints are not just deciding on one deal but on what kind of message they want to send about the rest of the year. [Read more 🡒]
Saints Season Already Feels Like An NFL Cautionary Tale
The Saints season is drifting into that uneasy territory where every week seems to carry a fresh reminder of how little margin they have left. After a rough stretch that included a loss to Pittsburgh, the conversation around New Orleans has shifted from early hope to damage control, with the schedule now giving the team a needed breather as the league moves into another slate of matchups.
This weeks bye at least offers a pause, but it also leaves plenty to sort through when the Saints return. The bigger picture around the NFC still demands attention, and with a full set of Week 8 predictions and a few more games on the calendar for later in the week, there is no shortage of context for where New Orleans stands and how quickly the season can turn from cautionary to outright bleak. [Read more 🡒]