Who Should the Saints Target in the NFL Draft to Replace Alontae Taylor?
The New Orleans Saints are facing a significant challenge after losing Alontae Taylor to the Indianapolis Colts with a hefty three-year, $58 million deal. Taylor was a cornerstone in Brandon Staley’s defense, playing a unique role that combined elements of safety, cornerback, and linebacker.
With free agency options dwindling, the Saints need to look towards the 2026 NFL Draft to fill this pivotal position. Here’s a breakdown of three prospects who could step into Taylor’s shoes.
Caleb Downs
Ohio State’s Caleb Downs is a standout candidate to fill the hybrid role left by Taylor. Downs is a versatile player, having logged snaps across the defense: 241 in the box, 240 as a free safety, 146 as a slot cornerback, 44 on the defensive line, and nine as an outside cornerback. His elite football IQ allows him to adapt seamlessly to various positions, making him a perfect fit for the Saints' needs.
Downs excels in all facets of the game. He’s aggressive against the run, a lockdown presence in coverage, and possesses remarkable athleticism. Selecting Downs with the eighth overall pick would be a strategic move, as his skills align perfectly with the demands of the star role.
Keionte Scott
Keionte Scott is often likened to Alontae Taylor for his similar playing style. Last season, Scott was a force from the slot, influencing every play with his dynamic presence. His impressive stats include 51 tackles, 20 pressures, 13 tackles for loss, five pass deflections, five sacks, and two interceptions returned for touchdowns.
While Scott projects as a mid-day two pick, he’s not without flaws. His footwork in coverage needs refinement, particularly against agile slot receivers.
Additionally, his tackling consistency is a concern, with 15 missed tackles last season. Despite these issues, Scott’s potential as a day-one contributor for the Saints is undeniable.
D’Angelo Ponds
D’Angelo Ponds may not have played the star role in college, but his versatility suggests he could adapt well. Standing at 5-foot-9 and 173 pounds, Ponds is undersized but compensates with elite athleticism, sound technique, and a fierce competitive spirit. His refined mechanics enable him to neutralize larger opponents effectively.
Ponds is a day-one talent, though his size might push him to the second round. If available at pick 43, he would be an exceptional value for the Saints, offering the potential to thrive in New Orleans’ defense.
As the Saints look to the draft, these prospects offer promising solutions to fill the void left by Alontae Taylor. Each brings unique strengths that could help maintain the dynamic edge of the Saints' defense.