The chatter around Michael Porter Jr. and the New Orleans Pelicans makes sense on the surface. He’s a proven scorer, a 6-foot-10 mismatch, and a player who can bend a defense just by floating into open space.
Coming off a career-best season with the Brooklyn Nets, Porter averaged 24.2 points, 7.1 rebounds and 3.0 assists. He also brings championship experience from his time with the Denver Nuggets.
But the Pelicans have to look past the name value. Porter’s talent is obvious. The real question is whether he fits New Orleans better than what it would take to get him.
And that’s where the conversation gets ugly for the Pelicans. Any meaningful trade talks would likely send Brooklyn straight to Trey Murphy III. If Murphy is the asking price, New Orleans should shut it down.
The numbers don’t separate them enough to justify that kind of move. Over the past three seasons, Porter has put up 19.6 points, 7.0 rebounds and 2.1 assists while hitting 38.5% from three.
Murphy has averaged 19.3 points, 5.3 rebounds and 3.3 assists, and he’s made just about 37% of his threes. Porter has been the slightly better shooter and rebounder.
Murphy has become the better passer and offers more defensive versatility. He’s also two years younger and already locked in through the 2028-29 season.
That contract situation matters. Porter is scheduled to make approximately $40.8 million this season, and it’s the final year of his current deal.
Murphy is set for $27 million. New Orleans couldn’t simply swap one for the other without moving more salary or dragging in another team.
So the Pelicans would be doing a lot of roster gymnastics for what looks like only a marginal upgrade.
There’s also the broader fit issue. Porter would come into a locker room already carrying a few important financial questions.
Saddiq Bey is in the final year of his contract. Bennedict Mathurin is on a two-year deal with a player option for the second season.
Zion Williamson still has two years left, but the franchise will eventually have to decide whether to make another long-term commitment to him.
Porter would be arriving with his own contract clock ticking too. He’s in the final year of his deal and looking for what could be his last major payday.
That doesn’t automatically mean trouble, but it does mean pressure. Touches matter.
Production matters. Security matters.
And that can get messy on a roster with Zion, Murphy, Mathurin, Jeremiah Fears and Derik Queen all in the mix.
Porter has shown he can play alongside stars. In Denver, he fit behind Nikola Jokic and Jamal Murray.
In Brooklyn, he got more freedom and his scoring climbed. The question is whether he’d accept a smaller role again in New Orleans, or whether he’d view the Pelicans as just another stop before free agency.
There’s another complication: Porter has publicly said he wants to stay in Brooklyn. That makes any New Orleans pursuit even shakier, because the Pelicans could end up surrendering real assets for a player with no guarantee he sees them as a destination.
Health has to be part of the evaluation too. Porter has reached at least 70 games only twice in his career.
Those came in back-to-back seasons with Denver, when he played 81 games in 2023-24 and 77 in 2024-25. He was limited to 52 games last season and has had three back surgeries in his career.
Murphy has had availability issues of his own, appearing in 57, 53 and 66 games over the last three seasons. That’s not a case for pretending he’s indestructible. It is a case for not paying extra and giving up assets to take on another major medical risk.
What New Orleans really needs is not just another scorer. The Pelicans need players who connect the lineup, defend consistently and stay useful when the offense isn’t built around them.
Porter is a sharp shot-maker, but he isn’t a defensive stopper or a natural facilitator. Murphy is still growing, but his game fits that kind of roster better.
Porter could lift the offense on certain nights. Murphy gives New Orleans shooting, length, transition scoring, defensive versatility and the kind of contract stability that matters for a team trying to settle itself. He can grow with the Pelicans instead of forcing them to rearrange the roster around another looming negotiation.
If Porter could be had without Murphy, that’s a different conversation. But that doesn’t sound likely.
For the Pelicans, the more accomplished player is not automatically the better investment. In this case, keeping Murphy is the smarter move.
In Other News...
Pelicans Give A Familiar Hustle Forward A Real Shot To Impress
Christian Shumate is getting another look in New Orleans, this time with a training camp deal that gives the familiar hustle forward a chance to make his case in a more meaningful setting. He already knows the organization from his time with the Pelicans G League affiliate, and he has been around the teams orbit through the last two Summer Leagues, so this is less of a fresh introduction than a renewed opportunity.
With Micah Peavy no longer in the picture, there is a path for a player who brings energy, effort and the kind of edge that can help him hang around the edges of a roster. Shumates style has long made him an intriguing fit for a team that could use those traits, but the real test now is whether he can turn familiarity into a stronger camp showing when the competition gets more serious. [Read more 🡒]
Pelicans Still Have One Roster Battle Worth Watching Closely
The Pelicans still have one open two-way contract spot, and the competition for it gives training camp a little extra edge. Kobe Bufkin, Christian Koloko and Christian Shumate are all in the mix, and each brings a different kind of appeal as New Orleans sorts through its final roster business before the season gets rolling.
This is the sort of battle that can turn on the details, since the Pelicans are not just looking for talent but for the right fit in a limited role. Camp and preseason will sort out who makes the strongest case, and with three players chasing one opening, there is at least one roster decision worth watching closely as New Orleans keeps trimming toward opening night. [Read more 🡒]
Cooper Flagg Is Already Facing Big Expectations In Dallas
While the attention around the Mavericks has been fixed on Cooper Flagg and the expectations already building around him in Dallas, there was also more roster movement across the league that matters to the Pelicans corner of the map. Bennedict Mathurins new two-year deal with New Orleans came in at $15,375,000, a commitment that gives the team another young scorer to fold into its plans while the rest of the league keeps sorting out how its own young talent will be managed.
The broader offseason picture keeps pushing down the same path for New Orleans: teams are locking in pieces, coaches are setting standards, and the competition for young players only gets sharper. Duke coach Jon Scheyer says he is staying put rather than chasing an NBA job, while Flaggs trainer is already talking about the expectations awaiting him under Dusty May in Dallas. For the Pelicans, the more immediate question is how quickly Mathurin can settle into his new role, especially with other clubs around the league making similarly decisive moves. [Read more 🡒]