DeMarcus Cousins recently said the Pelicans didn’t get better after he tore his Achilles during the 2017-18 season, and the numbers tell a more complicated story than that.
New Orleans was sitting at 27-21 with Cousins in the lineup, which matched the ninth-best record in the NBA at the time of the injury. From there, the Pelicans went 21-13 the rest of the regular season without him. That pushed their winning percentage from .563 to .618.
The team’s profile changed in a noticeable way, too. Before Cousins went down, New Orleans ranked 14th in net rating and 22nd on defense.
Over its final 34 games, it moved up to 10th in net rating and sixth defensively. The offense dipped only a little, and the Pelicans actually scored more because they played at a quicker pace, jumping from 100.48 possessions per 48 minutes to 102.89.
That wasn’t a case of replacing Cousins’ production one-for-one. It was a rework.
Anthony Davis slid to center, Nikola Mirotic arrived before the trade deadline, and Jrue Holiday took on a bigger share of the offense. New Orleans became faster, more adaptable, and a lot tougher on the defensive end.
By the regular-season numbers, the conclusion is pretty clear: the Pelicans were a better team after Cousins’ injury.
The playoff-caliber competition paints a less dramatic picture, though. With Cousins, New Orleans went 12-12 against teams that eventually made the postseason.
Without him, it went 8-11. A lot of that success came against the Eastern Conference.
Against Western Conference playoff teams, the Pelicans were 6-9 with Cousins and 4-8 without him in the regular season. Without Cousins, they did go 4-3 against Eastern Conference playoff teams. That doesn’t exactly scream major breakthrough against the West’s top tier.
The most telling matchups are the ones that came in the playoffs. With Cousins, New Orleans went 2-1 against Portland and 0-3 against Golden State. In those three losses to the Warriors, the Pelicans lost by an average of 11 points.
Without Cousins, including the playoffs, New Orleans went 4-1 against Portland and 2-4 against Golden State. The Pelicans swept the Trail Blazers in the first round before falling to the Warriors in five games.
There isn’t much in that to suggest a healthy Cousins would have flipped either series. New Orleans had already shown it could handle Portland with him, and Golden State was a much steeper challenge. Cousins hadn’t solved that matchup during the regular season.
Still, that doesn’t mean he would have been useless. A healthy Cousins would have given the Pelicans another elite scorer, rebounder, and passer at a time when Golden State was forcing them away from their preferred actions. Over a longer series, that kind of presence might have raised their ceiling.
But the evidence says the 2017-18 Pelicans were better without him in the regular season. They won more often, posted a better net rating, improved sharply on defense, and kept the offense productive while playing faster.
What never got answered was the bigger question: how high could that team have climbed with Cousins still in the mix? They looked good enough to beat Portland. They still didn’t look good enough to take down the defending and eventual champions from Golden State.
That’s why the injury still hangs over the season. Cousins was one of the most gifted offensive centers the league has seen, and his pairing with Davis never got the full test it deserved. The injury altered Cousins’ career, and Davis’ later departure closed the book before the experiment could be revisited.
So yes, the Pelicans were better after Cousins got hurt. Whether they could have become greater with him is still one of the franchise’s biggest what-ifs.
In Other News...
Zion Williamsons First Response Just Raised The Stakes For Pelicans
Zion Williamsons first public response to the lawsuit now hanging over him only deepens the uncertainty for the Pelicans, who are once again watching a major storyline unfold around the player the franchise is built around. The allegations involve a relationship that allegedly stretched from 2018 to 2023, and Williamsons camp has already pushed back hard, saying the relationship was consensual and denying that he physically or sexually harmed the woman.
The legal fight now becomes as important as the basketball fallout, because Williamson is also arguing the case should be thrown out because of the statute of limitations and the way the relationship is being portrayed. For New Orleans, the issue is less about the courtroom language than the larger cloud it creates around a centerpiece player whose availability and focus are always part of the conversation. [Read more 🡒]
Zion Williamsons First Response Puts Pelicans Back In Ugly Spotlight
Zion Williamsons off-court situation has pushed the Pelicans back into an uncomfortable spotlight, with the star forward now dealing with serious allegations from a woman who says their relationship included multiple incidents between 2020 and 2023. Williamson has denied the claims and, through his legal response, has characterized the relationship as a consensual friends with benefits arrangement while seeking dismissal on statute-of-limitations grounds.
For New Orleans, the timing only deepens the distraction around a player the franchise has long built around. The situation has already drawn fresh attention beyond the legal filing, including reports tying Williamson to a separate personal matter involving an OnlyFans creator, and it leaves the Pelicans navigating another headline that is likely to linger well beyond the court documents. [Read more 🡒]
Pelicans Enter Camp With One Starting Spot Under Real Pressure
As the Pelicans open training camp under a new coaching staff, the early read on the starting five already points to the direction this group wants to take. Dejounte Murray is projected to handle point guard duties, with Trey Murphy and Herb Jones fitting into the guard-forward mix, Zion Williamson anchoring the frontcourt at forward and Yves Missi in the middle. It is a lineup built around length, versatility and defense, and it gives the team a clearer sense of how the pieces might fit than it had at this stage a year ago.
Still, a projected five does not make the job safe for everyone, and camp will be the first real test of how rigid those roles are. The new staff is expected to evaluate fit and competition closely, which leaves at least one opening for a player to force the issue before the season begins. For a team trying to define its identity quickly, the pressure is already on whoever wants to turn a good camp into a guaranteed starting role. [Read more 🡒]