The Devils are already giving themselves a familiar problem, and it’s the kind that can quietly wreck a power play if they let it linger.
New Jersey’s first look at its man-advantage groups pointed straight back to the same issue that showed up last season: too much of the burden on Jack Hughes. Amanda Stein noted on September 19, 2026 that the initial setup had Hughes, Jesper Bratt, Nico Hischier, Luke Evangelista and Luke Hughes on PP1, with Timo Meier, Evgenii Dadonov, Anthony Mantha, Arseny Gritsyuk and Dougie Hamilton on PP2. Mercer, Stein added, looked like he was preparing to slide into PP2, but was not out with the first unit.
That first group is loaded with skill, but it also leaves Hughes as the clear engine again. New Jersey leaned on him in the same way after his injury last season, and opponents responded by loading up on him with two defenders on the power play.
The Devils could get the puck to Hughes and ask him to solve everything from there. He could do it at times, because he’s that kind of player, but the approach itself was the problem.
There’s also a broader concern with how the pieces fit if that group stays intact. With Ted Donato on the bench and likely handling the power play, the Devils should be exploring more than one look.
The source of the issue isn’t a lack of talent. It’s how that talent is being deployed.
One thing New Jersey should not do is put Hischier at the net front. That would be a mistake for two reasons.
First, it would expose him to more punishment at a time when he already does plenty of shot-blocking on the penalty kill. Second, it doesn’t maximize what he can offer on the power play.
If Hughes, Luke Hughes, Bratt and Evangelista are all on the same unit, the roles become too rigid: Hughes drives the attack, Luke Hughes serves as the outlet, Evangelista helps pull attention away from the puck, Bratt works the bumper, and Hischier is left cleaning up near the crease.
The question is whether that’s really the best use of Hischier when he could be the player forcing defenders to pay attention to someone other than Hughes. That would help prevent the double-teams that have led to turnovers for Hughes in the past.
Anthony Mantha looks like a cleaner answer for the top unit. He’s coming off a 33-goal season with the Penguins, and seven of those came on the power play. In this offense, that production could climb even higher.
It’s still early, and these combinations are going to change. The Devils have time to adjust. But if they want to avoid repeating last season’s mistake, they need to stop feeding the same overreliance on Hughes before it becomes the story again.
In Other News...
Devils Camp Is Starting To Reveal Who Fits This New Standard
The Devils third day of training camp brought another round of new line combinations and a closer look at how the roster is taking shape under a different tone. Special teams work was part of the mix, and Declan Chisholm continues to stand out in a pairing with Brenden Dillon, a familiar face from their time together that has helped ease his transition into the group.
Dillon has noticed the shift around camp, too, and he sees a team carrying more energy and a clearer sense of expectation after missing the playoffs last season. With the coaching staff still sorting through who fits best in which role, these early practices are starting to show which players can handle the standard the Devils want to set before the real tests begin. [Read more 🡒]
Brett Pesce Holds A Big Key To The Devils Blue Line
Brett Pesces first season in New Jersey gave the Devils a glimpse of why they targeted him for their blue line. He got into 37 games in 2025-26, chipped in a goal and six assists, and still managed to show the steady, shutdown presence the club wanted before injuries took him out of the lineup for a significant stretch. Now, with the 2026-27 season approaching, the expectation is that he slides into a key spot on the second defensive pairing and helps stabilize a group that needs reliability on the back end.
The larger question is whether Pesce can stay on the ice long enough to make that impact over a full year. He is entering the third season of his six-year contract, and if health cooperates, he is also on track to clear 800 NHL games, a milestone that speaks to how much experience he brings. For the Devils, the value is obvious: a veteran defenseman who can absorb tough minutes, settle the rotation and give the rest of the blue line a more dependable structure - if the injuries finally stay out of the way. [Read more 🡒]
Seamus Casey Could Force A Tough Devils Blue Line Decision
Seamus Casey heads into a pivotal stretch with the Devils as he enters the final year of his entry-level contract and tries to earn a spot on the opening night roster. The young defenseman has already shown flashes of the offensive skill that made him worth watching, even as injuries have complicated his path and limited his runway at times.
Sunny Mehta will have some blue line sorting to do before the season begins, and Casey is part of that conversation if he stays healthy and makes his case in camp. For a team that will be weighing both immediate depth and long-term upside, his preseason performance could make this a harder decision than it first looks. [Read more 🡒]