A new ranking of the NHL’s top-six center duos has given New Jersey Devils fans plenty to side-eye.
On Tuesday, The Athletic’s Harman Dayal ranked every team’s top two centers, splitting the league into eight tiers. Edmonton stood alone at the top, Calgary sat alone at the bottom, and everyone else landed somewhere in between. The Devils, with Jack Hughes and Nico Hischier leading the way, were placed in the third tier and finished fourth overall.
That placement is hard to square with the talent New Jersey has down the middle.
Hughes and Hischier are a nasty combination: one is a game-breaking offensive force, the other a two-way workhorse who does just about everything well. Yet they were ranked behind the Colorado Avalanche duo of Nathan MacKinnon and Brock Nelson, and the Florida Panthers pairing of Aleksander Barkov and Sam Bennett.
There’s no argument with Edmonton being untouchable here. But Colorado and Florida are a different story.
MacKinnon is the driver of the Avalanche case, and there’s a real argument that he’s the second-best player in the league. That kind of star power carries weight.
Even so, Brock Nelson, at 34, should drag the pairing down some. Hughes is much closer to MacKinnon than Nelson is to Hischier, and not by a little.
When healthy, Jack is a top-seven player in the NHL at worst, and he’s only entering his prime. Hischier, meanwhile, is seven years younger than Nelson, has outproduced him consistently, has posted stronger underlying numbers across his career, and has taken tougher matchups, too.
The Panthers ranking is even tougher to buy.
Barkov is a phenomenal two-way center and absolutely deserves recognition. But he doesn’t stack up to Hughes in overall talent, and Bennett is barely a second-line center. Dayal pointed to the intangibles both Florida centers bring, which may work in some evaluations, but it feels flimsy when the question is pure center talent at this level.
Dayal also noted that the Devils are one of only two teams with two top-20 centers in the NHL, and suggested Jack’s health and faceoff issues were the main reasons New Jersey didn’t land higher. But if health is part of the conversation, Barkov has had his own injury issues over the years.
That concern doesn’t seem to apply only to No. 86.
And the gap between Hischier and Bennett is wide enough on its own to push New Jersey well ahead of Florida.
Does the exact spot in a ranking like this change anything for the Devils? Not really.
But it does reinforce a bigger point: New Jersey’s centers are still being undervalued. Even so, the expectation here is clear.
With a fully healthy 2026-27, Hughes and Hischier should have no trouble proving the list wrong. They’re the NHL’s second-best center duo.
In Other News...
Devils Finally Have A Reason To Care About Utica Again
Utica has not been much more than a distant outpost for the Devils in recent seasons, but this summer gave the organization a reason to pay closer attention. Sunny Mehta, who oversees hockey operations in New Jersey, has pushed through a meaningful reset of the Comets roster and management structure, starting with the hiring of Braden Birch as assistant general manager and general manager in Utica.
The roster work has been just as notable, with the Comets adding several players who bring real AHL scoring potential while also keeping important pieces from last season in place. For New Jersey, the hope is straightforward: make Utica more competitive, more stable and more useful as a development stop for the next wave of NHL talent. [Read more 🡒]
Tomas Nosek Leaves Devils After Sudden Career Turnaround
Tomas Nosek is heading back to where it all started, signing with HC Dynamo Pardubice for the upcoming season after a long NHL run that included stops with the Devils and Panthers. For New Jersey, he was a veteran forward brought in for depth and experience, and for Florida he became part of a championship group, finishing with a Stanley Cup win in 2025.
The move sends Nosek back to Czechia and to the club where he launched his career, a full-circle decision that fits the stage he is at now. After more than 500 NHL games, the jump to Europe likely marks the final stretch of his professional playing days, closing out a career that took an unexpected late turn into a title run. [Read more 🡒]
Devils Suddenly Have A New Samu Salminen Dilemma
Samu Salminens next move is suddenly a real talking point for the Devils, because the forward is nearing free agency after four years of NCAA hockey and still has not signed with New Jersey. For a team that always has one eye on the pipeline and the other on the clock, that leaves his path hanging in the balance at just the moment his college career appears to be reaching its natural end.
A recent Colorado court ruling has made the situation more complicated by opening the door for some athletes who began college sports in the 2022-23 season and used up four years of eligibility to return to NCAA athletics. Salminen now has a wider menu of choices than the usual pro-hockey decision tree, with the ability to sign with any NHL team, go back to college hockey, or keep his career moving in Europe, and that uncertainty is exactly what makes his case worth watching for New Jersey. [Read more 🡒]