The New Jersey Devils find themselves in an intriguing spot with defenseman Simon Nemec, who was at the center of trade rumors as the NHL Trade Deadline approached. The Devils reportedly considered moving Nemec in exchange for a superstar winger, a move that would have been understandable if it brought in a top-tier forward prospect like James Hagens or Tij Iginla. However, without such a return, parting with the second-overall pick seemed less appealing.
As Nemec's entry-level contract is set to expire this offseason, the question isn't so much if he'll play for another team, but when. Reports suggest Nemec is seeking a hefty new deal, a price the Devils might be unwilling to pay given their long-term commitments to other players.
A bridge deal seems likely, as Nemec hasn't yet proven to be the superstar expected of a second-overall pick. Earlier this season, he found himself a healthy scratch when the Devils' defense was fully fit.
While his status has improved, the notion of him commanding $9 million per season is far-fetched, even with a rising salary cap. If another team is willing to offer that, the Devils could let him go as a restricted free agent, gladly accepting the draft pick compensation.
The Devils are rich in defensive talent, having invested heavily in the position through the draft. Anton Silayev, a former 10th-overall pick, is expected to join from the KHL, though he'll likely need time in the AHL to develop.
Since Tom Fitzgerald took the helm in 2020, the Devils have drafted 14 defensemen over six drafts, including five selections in the first two rounds. Among these is Seamus Casey, a former University of Michigan standout, who despite being injured in the AHL, has shown promising offensive instincts.
Some argue that trading Nemec would mean losing an offensive catalyst, especially if Dougie Hamilton were also moved. However, Casey might be poised to step into an NHL role. Despite a rough start in his two NHL games this season, where he was on the ice for six high-danger chances against and none in his favor, Casey has demonstrated skill in the AHL with 19 points in 29 games.
Though he needs further development, Casey's potential is evident. Drafted alongside Lane Hutson, he could become a reliable puck mover on the right side, potentially filling Nemec's shoes next season. It's not a far-fetched scenario for the Devils, who have a wealth of defensive options at their disposal.