Anthony Mantha’s free agency finally ended Wednesday, and the deal he landed with the New Jersey Devils said plenty about how the market viewed him.
Mantha signed a two-year, $9.5 million contract with New Jersey, carrying a $4.75 million average annual value. The money is front-loaded in 2026-27, when he’ll make $5.4 million, before dropping to $4.1 million in 2027-28.
On the surface, it’s a solid payday. In the bigger picture, it’s a far cry from what his camp seemed to be targeting after a career year.
The winger is coming off a 33-goal, 64-point season with Pittsburgh, both career highs, on a one-year “prove-it” deal worth $2.5 million. That production had him positioned as one of the more interesting unrestricted free agents on the board, but as the summer moved along and other names disappeared, Mantha remained unsigned.
The word was that he was seeking around $24 million over four years. Instead, he got two years and change, with less than half the term.
That disconnect came down to the same thing teams have always wrestled with when it comes to Mantha: the talent is real, but the consistency hasn’t been. He can score.
Nobody doubts that. What has kept him from cashing in is when and how often it shows up.
He has zero playoff goals, and his production has a way of rising and falling depending on the stage. He finished the regular season with seven goals in his final nine games, then went quiet in the playoffs.
That kind of stretch-and-disappear profile is exactly why the market settled where it did.
There was some chatter about Montreal, but according to the reporting, they never made a real offer. Edmonton was also viewed as a fit, though they likely had a two-year ceiling and less money available. In the end, the market delivered the same verdict from all directions: this was the contract range Mantha was going to get.
For the Devils, the fit is straightforward. Mantha gives them a big, natural shooter who can work alongside Jack Hughes and Jesper Bratt.
New GM Sunny Mehta is betting that a shorter-term deal in that role can bring value without tying the team down if it doesn’t work out. The lack of trade protection reinforces that thinking.
It’s a movable contract, and if the fit goes sideways, New Jersey won’t be stuck.
Josh Yohe of The Athletic wrote:
“Mantha let the Penguins know during the regular season that a three-year deal was his starting point for extension talks. The Penguins didn’t want to give him three years or more.
Neither did anyone else, apparently. Penguins probably would have considered bringing Mantha back if they had known that would be the price…”
In Other News...
NHL Just Blew Another Huge Chance With Devils Rangers Rivalry
The Devils-Rangers rivalry still has the kind of juice the NHL should be leaning into. Their 2023 Stanley Cup Playoff series drew strong viewership and reminded the league how much attention a Hudson River showdown can command when both teams matter at the same time. But instead of building on that momentum, the schedule has kept the matchup oddly sparse, with only three meetings last season and all of them tucked late in the year, when the buzz had already faded.
This season brings a little more of what fans want, with four games on the calendar between New Jersey and New York. The catch is in the timing: every one of them lands before Christmas, leaving the rivalry front-loaded and then disappearing from the schedule for the rest of the season. For a pairing that has proven it can sell itself, it feels like a missed opportunity to stretch out one of the leagues best natural draws. [Read more 🡒]
Devils Fans Wont All Agree With This Mikhail Yegorov Ranking
Mikhail Yegorovs stock is still very much a work in progress, which is why his place in the goalie-prospect conversation is going to draw some debate around the Devils. The Boston University netminder took a step back statistically from his freshman to sophomore season, but evaluators are still trying to balance that against the long view with a young goalie who has obvious physical tools and room to grow.
Scott Wheeler of The Athletic helped sharpen that discussion by placing Yegorov ninth among goalie prospects in his summer rankings, a spot that will feel too low to some and just right to others. Wheelers view is rooted in upside, not just results, and the real question for New Jersey is whether Yegorovs profile eventually points to a legitimate NHL starter or simply another intriguing name in a crowded pipeline. [Read more 🡒]
One Bizarre Ruling Changed Devils History Forever
A strange bit of early-1990s NHL business ended up reshaping the Devils for years to come. The chain started when St. Louis signed Scott Stevens to an offer sheet from Washington, which cost the Blues draft-pick compensation, and it got even messier when they later tried to pry Brendan Shanahan away from New Jersey. Because those picks were already spoken for, the matter went to arbitration and turned into one of the most unusual roster rulings the league has ever seen.
The fallout from that case reached far beyond a single transaction. New Jersey came out of it with a cornerstone defenseman who helped define the franchises identity, and the whole episode became part of the reason the NHL eventually tightened its offer-sheet rules. For Devils fans, it remains one of those bizarre what-if moments in league history, the kind that still hangs over how a dynasty can be traced back to a decision no one saw coming. [Read more 🡒]