Patriots Suddenly Face A Familiar QB Decision With Real Stakes

Deciding whether to bring back quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo puts the Patriots at a critical crossroads as they navigate injury challenges and playoff hopes.

The Patriots are at a crossroads after Drake Maye’s ankle injury, and Jimmy Garoppolo has suddenly been pulled back into the conversation.

NFL insider Jordan Schultz reported that Garoppolo, the Patriots’ 2014 draft pick and a backup on two Super Bowl teams, could be an option as New England starts sorting through its quarterback situation. For now, Tommy DeVito and Behren Morton are the only quarterbacks on the roster, and no outside move has been made.

Mike Vrabel didn’t exactly shut the door, but he also didn’t sound like a decision had been reached.

"I don't see that being the case right now," Mike Vrabel said. "But we'll have conversations, and we'll discuss it, and we'll look and see."

That leaves the Patriots weighing whether Garoppolo makes sense as a real solution or just a familiar name.

On the football side, the fit is easy to understand. Garoppolo knows Josh McDaniels’ system, having spent the first three-plus seasons of his career with the Patriots offensive coordinator in New England and later a short stint with him in Las Vegas in 2023. He’s the kind of quarterback who can run that offense without looking lost, which matters in a week where the team is re-evaluating everything.

That said, the version of Garoppolo the Patriots would be getting is not the same one as Maye. He’s 35, has already thought about retirement, and hasn’t started a game since 2024.

He also hasn’t made more than one start in a season since the year before that. For a team that still has postseason expectations, that’s not exactly the cleanest answer.

His last run as a full-time starter came in 2023 with the Raiders, before injuries and McDaniels’ firing pushed him to the bench. In seven games, Garoppolo completed 110 of 169 passes for 1,205 yards, seven touchdowns and nine interceptions. Since then, there hasn’t been much productive football to point to.

The idea of Garoppolo back in New England does carry some irony. At one point, he looked like the future behind Tom Brady.

Then Brady kept rolling, Garoppolo was dealt to San Francisco in 2017, and the Patriots moved on. Nearly 10 years later, the possibility of bringing him back would be a strange full circle.

There’s also the emotional angle. Patriots fans have long had a soft spot for Garoppolo’s game, at least before injuries in 2016 changed the way some people viewed him. If he were to step in now and steady things, it would be a pretty fitting twist for a team that suddenly needs help.

Still, this wouldn’t be a move for depth alone. If New England signs Garoppolo, it would almost certainly mean it sees him as the starter over DeVito and Morton. The Patriots gave DeVito a two-year extension this offseason to make him the QB2, so adding another quarterback who would expect to play could complicate things fast.

If the goal is simply to add experience behind the scenes, there are cheaper options out there, including Will Levis, a former Vrabel draft pick in Tennessee who is currently on the New York Jets’ practice squad.

But the Patriots are 5-5, and the roster still looks capable on paper of making a playoff push. Injuries have taken a toll, but the expectations haven’t gone away. If Garoppolo is the best shot to keep that run alive, then New England has a real decision to make.

After what DeVito showed against the Detroit Lions following Maye’s injury, the bar for improvement isn’t exactly high. The Patriots have a chance to become a surprising second-half team, and Jimmy Garoppolo is now one of the names tied to whether that happens.

In Other News...

Patriots Already Face A Brutal AJ Brown Trade Question

A.J. Browns latest setback landed at an awkward time for New England, with the receiver leaving the game against the Detroit Lions after a hamstring injury and unable to finish. Brown had only recently worked his way back from a knee injury, and his stop-start availability has already become part of the conversation around his first stretch with the Patriots.

The larger issue now is less about one missed game than what Brown can realistically give this offense when he is on the field. Media criticism has already centered on the decision to play him while he was still dealing with physical limitations, and with the Patriots now on their bye week, his status is still unclear as the team waits to see how much more recovery time he needs. [Read more 🡒]

Patriots Loss Just Sparked A Bigger Vrabel Question In New England

The Patriots loss and Drake Mayes injury already left New England with plenty to sort through, but Mike Vrabel added another layer of unease with a postgame comment that quickly drew attention. He later apologized for the remark, yet the issue lingered because it came at a time when the Patriots are trying to stabilize themselves at 5-5 and hold onto the No. 8 spot in the AFC playoff race.

Mike Tomlins reaction only widened the conversation, as he voiced concern that Vrabels comments could point to something deeper going on inside the building. For a team still trying to define itself in the middle of the season, the question is no longer just about one loss or one injured quarterback, but whether the noise around Vrabel is becoming part of the Patriots bigger problem. [Read more 🡒]

Former Patriots Starter From A Memorable NFL Era Has Died

Damian Johnson, a former NFL offensive lineman who spent part of his career with the Patriots, has died at 63. Johnson was part of a memorable era in league history, having contributed to the Giants run to a Super Bowl XXI title, and his career connected him to two franchises that helped define different chapters of the 1980s NFL.

For Patriots fans, Johnson is one of those names that sits just off the main stage but still belongs in the story of the era. His death on November 5 leaves behind a family that includes his children, mother, siblings and extended relatives, and it also closes another chapter on a player whose work in the trenches helped shape a championship season that is still remembered decades later. [Read more 🡒]