Patriots Star Drake Maye Sparks Doubt With One Alarming Stat

Despite Drake Mayes breakout season, a closer look at his usage in high-scoring games raises questions about the Patriots' ability to sustain a deep playoff push.

Drake Maye’s Breakout Season Has the Patriots Buzzing - But There’s More to the Story Than Just the Rookie QB

Drake Maye has officially arrived in New England. The rookie quarterback has injected life into a Patriots offense that, just a year ago, looked like it was stuck in neutral.

With 3,567 yards, a 70.9% completion rate, 27 total touchdowns, and just 7 interceptions, Maye isn’t just playing well - he’s playing like a star. He’s second in MVP odds, trailing only Matthew Stafford, and it’s hard to argue against that.

He’s elevated players like Mack Hollins and Kayshon Boutte, turning them from role players into real threats. But as the season hits its stretch run, there are some interesting - and slightly concerning - trends that are starting to surface.

The Patriots Are Scoring Big - But Not Through the Air

Let’s start with this: the Patriots are averaging 27.3 points per game, good for seventh in the NFL. That’s a full 10.3 points higher than their 2024 average.

So yes, the offense is humming. But here’s the twist - it’s not all on Maye’s arm.

In fact, in five of the six games where New England has topped 30 points, Maye has attempted fewer than 25 passes. That’s not a typo. When the Patriots are lighting up the scoreboard, they’re not leaning on their rookie QB to throw them there - they’re leaning on efficiency, balance, and a whole lot of complementary football.

Take a look at the numbers:

  • @ MIA: 33 points / 23 pass attempts
  • vs CAR: 42 / 17
  • @ TEN: 31 / 23
  • vs CLE: 32 / 24
  • vs NYG: 33 / 31 (the outlier)
  • vs BUF: 31 / 23

In those six games, the Patriots are 5-1. The only loss came this past weekend against Buffalo.

And when Maye throws fewer than the team’s average of 29.4 pass attempts per game? They’re 6-1.

So what’s driving the scoring if it’s not high-volume passing? A few things: a strong run game, opportunistic defense, and special teams that have been more than just serviceable - they’ve been game-changing.

In four of those six 30+ point outings, either the defense or special teams found the end zone. Against the Browns, they even forced a safety.

That’s impact football in all three phases.

Efficiency Over Volume

Maye may not be tossing it 40 times a game, but when he does throw, he’s been sharp. In four of those six high-scoring wins, he posted a passer rating north of 125.0.

That’s elite efficiency. He’s not padding the stat sheet - he’s managing the game like a veteran, making the most of his opportunities, and avoiding costly mistakes (for the most part).

But this past Sunday against Buffalo showed what can happen when the game script flips and Maye is asked to do more.

A Rough Second Half in Buffalo

Maye started strong - 9-for-11 for 108 yards in the first half. But the second half was a different story.

He went just 5-for-12 for 47 yards after the break. The Patriots managed only two first downs in the entire second half, and one of those came on the same drive that ended in a Maye interception.

The other drives? Two punts, a turnover on downs, and a 65-yard cutback touchdown run by TreVeyon Henderson - the only real offensive spark after halftime.

Maye’s interception wasn’t a backbreaker - it came on a 3rd-and-25 heave that essentially functioned like a punt - but there was another throw, a near-pick dropped by Jordan Poyer, that could’ve been far more damaging. It was a reminder that while Maye has been excellent, he’s still learning how to close games at the NFL level.

What It Means Moving Forward

The Patriots don’t need Maye to be Superman - at least not yet. When they’re playing from ahead, leaning on the ground game, and letting the defense and special teams do their thing, they’re a tough out. But as the season tightens up and the games get bigger, there will be moments when Maye has to take over with his arm.

The question isn’t whether he can make the throws - we’ve seen the arm talent, the poise, and the accuracy. The question is whether he can carry the offense when the run game stalls, the defense bends, and the game script demands more.

So far, the Patriots have found a winning formula that doesn’t require Maye to throw 35 times a game. But sooner or later, that moment will come. And when it does, we’ll find out just how ready this rookie really is.