Bill Simmons didn’t hold back after watching A.J. Brown’s first season in New England unfold the way it has.
On the latest episode of his podcast, the longtime Boston sports voice said the Patriots’ move to give up major draft capital for Brown belongs in the conversation for the worst trades in the city’s history. Brown, acquired from the Philadelphia Eagles in June, has been limited to four games this season because of a string of injuries, including a high ankle sprain, a knee issue and a hamstring setback that forced the Patriots to pull him from Sunday’s 35-10 loss to the Lions in Germany.
When Brown has been on the field, the production hasn’t matched the price tag. New England sent two picks, including a 2028 first-rounder, to Philadelphia to land him, but Brown has managed only 11 catches on 26 targets for 128 yards, along with several drops that have stood out for all the wrong reasons.
“Then we have this A.J. Brown sub-plot where they decide to play him this week because what could go wrong with a guy is not 100 percent on a terrible field in Munich, right?
What could go wrong,” Simmons said. “They keep him in where it’s 28-3 or whatever it is.
He’s still out there, and finally, of course, he gets hurt, catches one ball.
“And this has been one of the worst trades in Boston sports history. If you’re just judging it by first year in, I can’t think of a trade that has just gone worse in every single respect from the moment we’ve gotten him.”
Brown arrived in New England with a résumé that made the gamble look understandable at the time. Before the trade, he had topped 1,000 receiving yards in six of his first seven NFL seasons and had established himself as one of the most productive receivers of his era.
But there were concerns attached to the deal from the start. Patriots executive vice president of player personnel Eliot Wolf told Yahoo Sports’ Jori Epstein that the team knew about Brown’s “degenerative knee condition” before making the trade.
“It’s a factor, but we examined him,” Wolf told Epstein. “He’s got a knee that has some wear and tear that we were aware of. Our training staff and medical staff signed off on it.
Simmons pointed to that issue as part of what has made the move look so bleak so quickly.
“We get him, and they’re like, ‘Oh, you know, he has a degenerative knee.” Or like, ‘Oh, well, his knee’s okay this year, right?”
All the Philly fans are like, “He either quit last year or he has a [expletive]-up knee. It’s one or the other.’
It’s like, oh, that doesn’t sound great,” Simmons said. “And then he shows up and gets hurt in an hour.
In Other News...
Patriots Fans Wont Like How The League Judged Drake Mayes Injury
Drake Mayes injury in Munich already left Patriots fans with plenty to stew over, and the leagues review only adds to the frustration. During Week 10 of the 2026 season, Detroit defensive end Aidan Hutchinson brought Maye down on a sack that resulted in a fractured ankle for the New England quarterback, a brutal sequence that also ended with Hutchinson suffering a torn ACL of his own.
The NFL officiating office later confirmed the tackle was not ruled an illegal hip-drop, a judgment that will not sit well in New England given the way the play unfolded. For Hutchinson, it is his second season-ending injury after a broken leg in 2024, while the Patriots are left sorting through the fallout from a loss that went well beyond the scoreboard. [Read more 🡒]
Patriots Suddenly Face A Serious Drake Maye Problem
Drake Mayes ankle injury has suddenly become one of the most important storylines for New England heading into Week 11, and the uncertainty is the part that stings most. The Patriots are now bracing for the possibility of being without their quarterback for some time, even though there is still no updated diagnosis on just how serious the injury might be.
For a team trying to keep its season on track, the timing could hardly be worse. Around the league, other notable names are dealing with their own injury situations, but Mayes status is the one that matters most to New Englands immediate plans, and the lack of clarity leaves the Patriots waiting for answers before they can even map out what comes next. [Read more 🡒]
Patriots Suddenly Face A Familiar QB Decision With Real Stakes
Drake Mayes ankle injury has pushed the Patriots back into a conversation they probably hoped to avoid this early, and it has brought a familiar name back into the mix. NFL insider Jordan Schultz said Jimmy Garoppolo could be an option as New England reconsiders its quarterback situation, with head coach Mike Vrabel saying no decisions have been made yet but discussions are coming.
For a team already carrying Tommy DeVito and Behren Morton on the roster, the next move matters more than a routine depth-chart shuffle. Garoppolo would not be an unfamiliar fit in New England, and the Patriots now have to weigh experience against whatever timeline Mayes recovery creates, with the quarterback picture still very much unsettled. [Read more 🡒]
