An ugly loss to the Jaguars has left the Patriots heading into Week 4 with a mess on their hands, and Drake Maye is right in the middle of it.
The road trip to Buffalo was already going to be a rough one against an undefeated Bills team. After Sunday’s performance, the noise around New England only got louder. There’s plenty for the Patriots to clean up, but the biggest concern is Maye himself - specifically, the way his confidence seems to be slipping from one week to the next.
His game against Jacksonville was his worst of the season, and that’s pushed the conversation into uncomfortable territory. Some analysts and even some Patriots fans are already calling for a benching, and now a former NFL quarterback is saying the same thing.
Boomer Esiason said Monday morning on WEEI’s "The Greg Hill Show" that he would sit Maye for a week.
"It's gotta be a psychological thing, and he's gotta be held accountable somehow. I don't think they'll do it, but I would make him sit this week.
That's how bad it's gotten, and it's been bad since last postseason. And we all know it.
We all see it. But the interception to Travis Hunter was mind-blowing to me, especially after the interceptions that he has thrown in the previous two games."
There’s no arguing with the tape from Sunday. Maye made mistakes that were hard to make sense of in real time, and the Jaguars game only deepened the concern about where his head is at.
Still, sitting him down isn’t a clean solution. The Patriots don’t have a proven veteran waiting to steady things. Tommy DeVito is next up, and when he replaced Maye on Sunday, he didn’t exactly change the feel of the game.
There’s also the risk that a benching does the opposite of what New England wants. If Maye’s biggest issue is confidence, then taking him off the field could make that even harder to rebuild. The Patriots have already seen how damaging that kind of spiral can be from the way Bill Belichick handled Mac Jones.
Esiason’s point isn’t without logic, though. Maye has to be held to the same standard as everyone else, and poor play can’t just be waved away. That was part of what made Belichick’s approach so effective in New England, with players still talking about how he treated Tom Brady like everyone else.
But the Patriots also have to think about what gives them the best chance to win right now, and it’s tough to make the case that DeVito is the answer.
So New England is stuck with a difficult balancing act. The team has work to do across the board, but getting Maye’s confidence back may be the hardest part of all.
In Other News...
Patriots Rookie Shares Heartbreaking Family News After Breakthrough Moment
Eli Raridons first NFL touchdown came during a season that has already asked a lot of the rookie tight end away from the field. The Patriots pass catcher has appeared in two games this year, and while that breakthrough on the field offered a glimpse of his role in New England, his family has now shared the far more personal news behind the scenes.
Raridon and his wife, Anna, announced the loss of their newborn son, Peter James, who was diagnosed with anencephaly during a 20-week ultrasound. Anna carried Peter to term, he was born on Sept. 11, and he passed away shortly after birth. [Read more 🡒]
Drake Maye And Mike Vrabel Rumors Add New Concern For Patriots
A shaky start to the 2026 season has already put Drake Maye under an uncomfortable spotlight, with the Patriots quarterback battling multiple turnovers and uneven performance. For a team still trying to settle its long-term direction, that alone would be enough to fuel plenty of conversation around New England, especially with the offense searching for steadier footing early.
Now the discussion has widened beyond the field. A broadcast on The Greg Hill Show added another layer of concern by relaying rumors of tension between Maye and head coach Mike Vrabel, including the suggestion that Vrabel never fully backed Maye as the franchise quarterback. The reporting is coming from unnamed team sources and commentary rather than official confirmation, but even as rumor it gives the Patriots another unresolved issue to manage while the season is still taking shape. [Read more 🡒]
Cam Newton Just Turned Drake Maye Into A Patriots Debate
Drake Mayes early-season start has become a talking point far beyond Foxborough, and Cam Newton added another layer to the discussion during a recent podcast appearance. The former Patriots quarterback pointed to Mayes interceptions and the lack of touchdowns through three games, framing the performance against the kind of expectations that follow a team with a Super Bowl pedigree. Newton also acknowledged the context around the rookie passer, including injuries to Mayes receivers, but made clear his opinion was rooted in what he has seen on film and in the numbers.
For the Patriots, the debate is less about one harsh critique than about how quickly the conversation around Maye can shift from patience to scrutiny. Newton has raised the bar before when he talks about New England, and his latest comments fit that pattern, especially with a young quarterback still trying to find his footing in a less-than-ideal setup. The broader question hanging over the situation is whether the early issues are just part of the learning curve or the start of a more uncomfortable conversation about where this offense is headed. [Read more 🡒]