Mike Vrabel has spent most of his Patriots tenure earning praise, not heat. He delivered a Super Bowl trip in his first season, then followed that up by winning Coach of the Year.
That kind of run buys a coach a lot of goodwill. But after the Patriots’ brutal loss to the Seahawks on Wednesday night, one preseason choice is suddenly drawing a loud round of second-guessing.
The decision in question was simple: Vrabel kept his starters out of all three preseason games. At the time, it looked like a reasonable way to reduce injury risk in a shortened exhibition slate.
Plenty of coaches around the league have pushed for fewer preseason games, and some would rather skip them altogether. But in New England, that approach stood out.
Even during the dynasty years, Tom Brady usually got at least one drive to get back into game rhythm after seven months without meaningful football.
This year’s situation made the choice feel even more notable. The Patriots had just lost the Super Bowl and turned over parts of the roster, so many expected Drake Maye and the rest of the first team to get at least a little live work before the real games began.
Instead, nearly every starter sat through the entire preseason. Now, after a shaky showing in Seattle, some are wondering whether that left the team too rusty, too jittery, and too far removed from game speed.
That theory is easy to reach for, especially after a loss this ugly. Maye’s fourth-quarter stretch is the obvious flash point, with three interceptions on consecutive drives fueling plenty of the criticism.
Romeo Doubs also looked like part of the group trying to find its footing. Still, the idea that preseason inactivity alone caused the collapse doesn’t hold up all that well when you look back at the recent history.
Maye did play in two preseason games in 2025, and he played in all four as a rookie. That didn’t prevent the Patriots from looking awful against the Raiders in Week 1 last season.
It also didn’t stop them from dropping another game two weeks later to the Steelers, a contest they had a real chance to win for most of the afternoon. And yet that rough opening month didn’t define the season.
The Patriots ripped off nine straight wins, took the AFC East, and got back to the Super Bowl for the first time in six years.
That’s why the preseason debate feels more like a convenient target than a clear explanation. Teams rarely point to a lack of preseason snaps as the reason they struggled once the real games start. And if the Patriots had pulled out the win against Seattle, this probably wouldn’t be a discussion at all.
What remains is the harder truth: Maye had a chance to steal the game, and he didn’t get it done. That’s the part people are reacting to now, even if some are trying to wrap it in the safer excuse of preseason rust. The Patriots can still recover from one bad night, but the questions around Vrabel’s decision are going to linger until they do.
In Other News...
Drake Mayes Costly Pick Raises A Bigger Patriots Question
Drake Mayes first game of the season gave the Patriots plenty to sort through, and not just because of the final score against Seattle. The rookie quarterbacks three interceptions immediately turned the conversation toward how New England is trying to build around him, and whether the offense is helping him enough when defenses start showing him different looks. One of the swings came on a familiar concept the Patriots kept leaning on, even as the Seahawks settled into Cover 8 and made the picture tougher to read.
The more revealing part is how the play unfolded in real time, with Mayes timing, decision-making and throw all under the microscope on the same snap. New England had reasons for calling it, but the result raised a bigger question the Patriots will have to keep answering as the season goes on: when the same idea keeps showing up and the defense is waiting on it, how much of the blame belongs to the play call, and how much lands on the quarterback making the choice? [Read more 🡒]
Drake Maye's Struggles Shouldn't Shake What Patriots Believe He Can Be
Drake Mayes Week 1 line was rough enough to jar anyone watching, with 187 passing yards, one touchdown and three interceptions, and it continued a stretch of uneven play that has now lingered for several games. For a Patriots team still trying to define itself, those struggles can feel magnified, especially when the quarterback is expected to be the centerpiece of everything that comes next.
Still, the bigger picture around Maye in New England has not changed much. He remains the quarterback the Patriots believe can lead them into the future because of the talent that made him such a promising prospect in the first place, along with the success he has already shown at his best. He is still young, still developing, and the errors have been treated less like a final judgment than part of the learning curve that comes with that responsibility. [Read more 🡒]
Romeo Doubs Patriots Debut Raised A Bigger Question Than One Bad Game
Romeo Doubs first game in a Patriots uniform did not go the way anyone in New England hoped, and the reaction was immediate. A disappointing debut was enough to spark criticism from fans and a fresh round of questions about whether he fits what this offense needs, even though one game is hardly enough time to draw a real verdict on a player who arrived with a broader rsum than that showing suggested.
Freddie Boston, who covers the Packers, pushed back on the urge to write Doubs off so quickly, pointing to the trust he earned in Green Bay and the role he played there before arriving in New England. Even Doubs own postgame comments, which rubbed some people the wrong way, appear to have been an awkward attempt at accountability rather than a reflection of his effort, leaving the bigger question less about one rough outing and more about how quickly Patriots fans are willing to let him settle in. [Read more 🡒]