Drake Maye just keeps putting up numbers, and the noise around him keeps getting louder anyway.
That’s the strange part of this whole thing. After a rocky start to the season, the Patriots quarterback answered in Week 4 by going toe-to-toe with Josh Allen and steering New England to a season-saving win in Buffalo. Then he came back and carved up a Las Vegas defense that entered the week ranked top-five in sacks and No. 1 in defensive takeaways.
The line from that performance is the kind that should usually end a debate: five total touchdowns, no turnovers, one sack taken and a 150.9 QB rating. Instead, the skepticism only sharpened. Patriots fans are still finding themselves in the position of defending the idea that the team has found a franchise quarterback.
Some of the pushback has come from Patriots reporter Greg Bedard, who has kept digging for reasons to knock Maye down a tier. The latest version came in Boston Sports Journal under the headline: Drake Maye was great again vs. a low-rated pass defense, how does that compare to others?
Bedard compared his own film grades for Maye with the pass DVOA ranking of each defense Maye has faced. He then tried to broaden the argument by stacking the 24-year-old against Josh Allen and reigning MVP Matthew Stafford.
“I decided to compare Maye to Matthew Stafford and Josh Allen,” Bedard wrote. “Even though my grades factor in Maye's scrambling ability, I decided to take that out of the equation because it's not fair to Stafford, an older pocket quarterback.
Plus, I think when it comes to winning championships (when you have to go through the best defenses), a quarterback's ability to operate from the pocket and throw the ball becomes paramount. That being said, I included the athletic Allen to give Maye a fairer comparison.”
His bottom line was that Maye is doing most of his damage against weaker pass defenses, which means he shouldn’t be placed in the same MVP-level conversation as Allen, Stafford, Patrick Mahomes and others.
Maye missing MVP by one first-place vote last year apparently doesn’t move the needle for that crowd, but that’s not really the issue. The bigger point is that the criticism has gotten ridiculous.
Maye has played 35 games in his career. He turned 24 on Aug.
- Last year, he was playing at an MVP level while the Patriots won 10 straight games in the regular season.
That kind of week-to-week production from a quarterback that young is not normal, even if the schedule included the Cardinals, Titans, Dolphins and Jets.
He also did it after handling a rookie season that was a mess under Jerod Mayo and offensive coordinator Alex Van Pelt. And in 2025, he spent most of the year leading the offense with aging Stefon Diggs and Hunter Henry as his top targets.
That’s why Patriots fans don’t think they should be apologizing for believing in him. They’re allowed to be excited about a quarterback who belongs in MVP conversations and has started in the Super Bowl. Even during what has been the roughest and most heavily criticized stretch of Maye’s career - from the wild-card round of the 2025 playoffs to Week 4 this year in Jacksonville - the Patriots still went 4-3.
There’s no sugarcoating the ugly parts. The fourth quarter against Seattle in the season opener, plus the entire game against the Jaguars, included some of the worst throws and decisions of Maye’s career so far.
But that’s still part of the job description. A quarterback is supposed to take what a defense gives him, and Maye has done that as well as almost any 23- to 24-year-old quarterback in a generation. The strange part is watching people work so hard to turn that into a negative.
Bedard has also pushed back on outside arguments in the process. A caller on 98.5 The Sports Hub this week pointed out that Mahomes and the Chiefs had trouble with the Raiders in Week 4, a game Kansas City won 30-27. Bedard mostly brushed that aside, saying divisional matchups should be judged differently.
That’s a fair point. But it also leaves the whole thing looking even more like a moving target, especially when Bedard has also questioned Maye’s MVP case from 2025 by pointing to how Stafford played against Seattle’s defense in the NFC Championship Game.
The Rams and Seahawks are in the same division, while Maye faced Seattle for the first time in Super Bowl LX. But OK.
At some point, the simplest explanation wins. Maye is a young quarterback on the rise, and he looks like someone who’s on track to be one of the NFL’s best players over the next three-to-five years.
In Other News...
Elijah Ponder Is Changing The Patriots Pass Rush Conversation
When the Patriots rebuilt their edge-rush picture this offseason, the attention mostly went to the bigger moves, including the addition of DreMont Jones and the expectation that rookies Gabe Jacas and Elijah Ponder would have to grow up quickly at outside linebacker. With Harold Landry sidelined, the early concern was obvious enough: whether New England had enough depth to keep the pass rush from sputtering. Ponder has helped answer that in a hurry, turning what looked like a vulnerable spot into one of the more encouraging parts of the defense.
The most recent sign came against the Raiders, where Ponders disruption stood out enough to draw league-wide notice from Pro Football Focus. He has been showing up with sacks, tackles for loss and a forced fumble, all while making the Patriots look a lot more comfortable about their edge rotation than they did in the spring. For a team still sorting out its post-rebuild identity, that kind of emergence matters, even if the larger question around how far this pass rush can go is still hanging out there. [Read more 🡒]
Patriots May Have Already Won Big With This Criticized Signing
When the Patriots brought in Alijah Vera-Tucker in free agency after spending their first-round pick on Caleb Lomu, the move came with a fair amount of skepticism. Vera-Tuckers injury history made him an easy target for second-guessing, but through the early stretch of his Patriots tenure, he has looked like one of the most reliable pieces on the offensive line and has helped steady a group that needed it.
The workload is about to get a little heavier, too, with Will Campbell sidelined by a knee injury. Vera-Tucker will be asked to handle more responsibility in the days ahead, and his next assignment will be a tough one, with a matchup looming against Jets rookie edge rusher David Bailey. For a signing that was criticized at the start, the Patriots may already be seeing why it made so much sense. [Read more 🡒]
Patriots Face A Familiar Cornerback Question They Can't Ignore
The Patriots were already thin at cornerback when injuries stacked up against the Raiders, leaving the group scrambling with multiple starters and backups unavailable. New England responded by elevating safety Elliott Davison for depth and bringing rookie Al'zillion Hamilton onto the practice squad, but he was not yet active, which only underlined how quickly the room can get stretched when the injuries start piling up.
One familiar name has also re-entered the conversation after a recent roster move in Dallas, and it is the kind of transaction the Patriots tend to monitor closely when a position gets this shaky. With the secondary banged up and the depth chart under pressure, New England has a choice to make about whether to look outside the building for another answer or trust the patchwork approach a little longer. [Read more 🡒]