Ohio State’s playoff life is hanging by a thread, and Greg McElroy thinks Saturday’s trip to Nebraska could turn into a grind.
The Buckeyes moved up six spots to No. 14 in Tuesday’s College Football Playoff rankings, but they’re still sitting just outside the top 12. With two games left, the path is narrow: beat Nebraska, beat Michigan, and hope the committee likes the résumé enough to keep them in the mix.
There’s no room for a slip in Lincoln. A loss would shut the door.
McElroy said on his Always College Football podcast that Ohio State has “lost two of the last three” since quarterback Julian Sayin hurt his right arm at Indiana, and the Buckeyes have been trying to steady themselves ever since. Ryan Day said Tuesday the team is still in the process of putting itself back together.
“When you lose two weeks in a row, you don’t have any momentum, so you have to build it,” Day said Tuesday.
Day has already been preparing for the postseason without Sayin, and true freshman Luke Fahey has been the next man up. Fahey has started three games, and Ohio State has put up 18, 28 and 28 points in those outings. In last week’s 28-19 win over Northwestern, he completed passes for 201 yards with three touchdowns and an interception.
Day described Fahey as “pretty unflappable,” but he also made it clear the challenge gets bigger this week.
“I think he’s learned from each game, but he still hasn’t played a whole lot of football, and so this is the next challenge for him to go win a game on the road,” Day said.
That challenge comes in a place McElroy expects to be difficult. He pointed to Nebraska’s ability to force opponents into long third downs, noting that teams convert just under 24% of their third downs against the Huskers. Nebraska is also tied for third nationally in third- and fourth-down success rate allowed.
McElroy also took aim at Ohio State’s run game. “The offensive line just doesn’t move anybody off the ball,” he said, while noting the Buckeyes are averaging 4.1 yards per carry.
That leaves a lot on Jeremiah Smith, who enters the game as the Heisman Trophy betting favorite with 1,317 receiving yards and 15 touchdowns. McElroy still sees danger in Ohio State leaning too hard on the pass. “When Ryan Day’s team throws it 40 or more times, he’s just 5-5,” he said.
Nebraska, meanwhile, has had a strange season arc. The Huskers started 5-0, dropped four straight, and three of those losses came by seven points or fewer. They bounced back with a 31-0 win at Rutgers that secured bowl eligibility.
The injury situation adds another layer. McElroy identified cornerback Andrew Marshall as a key defender for Nebraska against Smith, but Matt Rhule said Monday that Marshall is out for the season after surgery for a stress fracture. Defensive tackle Jahsear Whittington, who leads the team with six sacks, also left the Rutgers game with an apparent knee injury.
“One of the main things from that game to take away is just the amount of guys that stepped up with injuries,” Rhule said.
Special teams could matter too. Nebraska is 6 of 13 on field goals, and McElroy said that when drives bog down, “it’s a coin flip on whether or not they walk out with points.”
Even so, he still sees the Buckeyes escaping. McElroy picked Ohio State to win 19-17, saying, “I do, however, think that Nebraska will make a mistake or two, which ultimately gives Ohio State the victory.”
That kind of result would keep Ohio State’s hopes alive, though it wouldn’t exactly scream playoff team to a committee that had the Buckeyes at No. 20 just a week ago.
Ohio State and Nebraska kick off at noon ET Saturday on Fox.
In Other News...
Nebraskas Bowl Outlook Suddenly Brings A Matchup Fans Will Notice
Nebraska is bowl eligible for the second straight season at 6-4, and that alone makes the final stretch of November worth watching with a little more than just pride on the line. The Huskers have put themselves back into the conversation for a postseason trip, and with a number of bowl destinations still in play, the possibilities are starting to feel a lot more real for a fan base that has been waiting for this kind of December relevance to return.
Several potential matchups are already being discussed, and one of them would carry the kind of name recognition that immediately jumps off the page for Nebraska fans. Between the bowl options and the history attached to some of the possible opponents, there is plenty of room for intrigue, even if no official assignment has been made yet. For now, the only certainty is that Nebraska has earned another shot at the postseason, and the destination could come with a familiar face across the field. [Read more 🡒]
Trev Alberts Could Reopen A Nebraska Debate Fans Never Settled
A familiar name is suddenly back in the conversation around Nebraska athletics, and it comes with plenty of baggage from his time in Lincoln. Reports say Michigan is considering Trev Alberts as a candidate to replace athletic director Warde Manuel, which would put the former Huskers AD in line for another major Power Five job after a stint that included hiring Matt Rhule and pushing ahead with stadium renovations.
For Nebraska fans, the possibility is less about what Alberts might do next and more about what his departure would mean in hindsight. His tenure left a clear mark on the program, but it also stirred debate that never fully settled, and the prospect of him moving on to Michigan would reopen questions about how his Nebraska run should be judged. Nothing is confirmed yet, but the speculation alone is enough to pull an old argument back into view. [Read more 🡒]
Ole Miss Just Landed A Massive Future QB Talking Point
Rivals latest 2027 update gave Ole Miss a major boost in the long view, with commit Keegan Croucher now sitting atop the quarterback board as the class top signal-caller. The new rankings also underscored just how early the race is taking shape nationally, with 28 five-star recruits in the mix and only three quarterbacks earning that top-tier label so far.
For Nebraska, the update is a reminder that the recruiting conversation around the position is already getting crowded, even this far out. Trae Taylor remains one of the more notable quarterback names in the class for the Cornhuskers to watch, while Notre Dames early haul and the presence of other highly regarded passers like Jake Nawrot show how quickly the top of the board can shift before these prospects ever reach campus. [Read more 🡒]
