Predators Playoff Push Is Reviving A Tough Long Term Debate

As the Nashville Predators face fierce competition in the Western Conference, experts weigh in on whether a potential playoff run could be a step forward or simply a fleeting distraction.

The Nashville Predators’ seven-game surge came to a halt Sunday night, and with it came a bigger question than one loss in San Jose. After a 4-2 defeat to the Sharks, the Predators are left weighing whether a push for the postseason is actually worth the grind in a crowded Western race.

That was the focus on Monday’s episode of Daily Faceoff LIVE, where Tyler Yaremchuk and former NHL goaltender Carter Hutton dug into what Nashville’s recent run really means. The Predators had climbed into the top three of the Central Division before the streak ended, but Hutton made it clear he’s uneasy about what comes next.

“My worry is: are you going to be able to hold a playoff spot with the likes of the Utah Mammoth pushing? It’s been a really good run, I’m just concerned with where they go from here.

Are they setting themselves up for failure, where they could have moved a few pieces as they start to age? We talked about Ryan O’Reilly before, we talk about so many different players.

Even if you get in and squeak into a playoff spot, it’s probably a first-round exit, at best.”

Yaremchuk agreed that a playoff appearance can mean something different depending on the team. He pointed to clubs like the Winnipeg Jets, who could still benefit from simply getting in, and the San Jose Sharks, for whom a postseason berth would be more about experience than expectation.

But Nashville, he said, sits in a tougher spot.

“For the other teams in the mushy middle, including the Nashville Predators, I’m with you … I think for some teams it would be great to make it, but for others, I think it’s a little bit like, “Are you just spinning your tires?””

Hutton brought the conversation back to the bigger picture in Nashville, where the Predators carry more weight than just their standings position. With the NFL’s Tennessee Titans struggling, he said the Predators matter even more to the local sports scene.

“For them, it’s just the age of their team. Getting in is always great, and it’s the view of the market.

We touched on this last weekend: A lot of teams want that rebuild to take them where they want to go, but for Nashville, it’s the center of attention in town. The NFL’s Tennessee Titans are awful this season, so the NHL’s Predators are a big draw.

If you have a losing team, you start to feel it across that whole fanbase and area, so for them, staying good and relavent becomes a priority.”

In Other News...

Shane Wright Is Giving Predators Fans A New Trade Debate

Shane Wrights arrival in Nashville has already given Predators fans something to chew on, and not just because the trade brought a fresh young center into the mix. After being dealt from Seattle in exchange for Matthew Wood, Wright has produced three points in six games with the Predators, a quick enough start to get the conversation moving again about what Nashville got and what it gave up.

Matthew Wood, meanwhile, has yet to score in Seattle, which only adds another layer to the comparison as both teams wait to see how the swap settles in. For Nashville, the early returns are enough to make this more than a routine post-trade check-in, especially with the kind of long-view questions that follow any move involving two promising players who still have plenty of runway ahead of them. [Read more 🡒]

Predators Just Faced A Worry They Couldn't Ignore In San Jose

A seven-game surge can make a team feel like it has found its footing, which is why Nashvilles loss in San Jose landed with extra weight. The Sharks did more than just snap the streak. They controlled enough of the night to hand the Predators a reminder that even during a hot run, there are still nights when the margin for error disappears quickly.

Will Smith, Nils Hoglander and Macklin Celebrini all played key roles in a four-goal Sharks effort, while Steven Stamkos provided a late consolation goal for Nashville. Juuse Saros made notable saves to keep the Predators within reach, but the bigger concern was how thoroughly San Jose pushed the pace. For a team trying to build something lasting, this was the kind of loss that can linger a little longer than the final score. [Read more 🡒]