The Edmonton Oilers’ interest in Kirby Dach is a strange fit on the surface, and the club’s early-season numbers only make it look more puzzling.
Edmonton is 2-0-1 through three games, and the offense has done its job with 17 goals. The issue is what’s been going the other way: 14 goals allowed.
That kind of start points pretty clearly to help needed on the blue line or in goal. Instead, the Oilers have been linked to Montreal Canadiens centre Kirby Dach.
In late September, NHL insider Frank Seravalli said the Oilers were “drooling” with interest in the 25-year-old. That buzz has not gone away, with multiple insiders continuing to connect Edmonton to a possible deal involving Dach. There’s also a familiar thread here: general manager Stan Bowman drafted Dach third overall for the Chicago Blackhawks in 2019.
Edmonton did make a forward move on Wednesday morning, sending depth defenceman Spencer Stastney to the Pittsburgh Penguins for Filip Hallander. But Hallander, 26, has appeared in only 18 NHL games, so that swap does not look like the kind of move that would change the Oilers’ broader thinking about Dach.
The appeal is easy to understand if you go back to Dach’s draft year. He was coming off 25 goals and 73 points in 62 games with the WHL’s Saskatoon Blades and was viewed as close to NHL-ready. He jumped to the Blackhawks right away as an 18-year-old.
At 6-foot-4 and 221 pounds, Dach has the frame and skill set to be a power forward. The problem is that his career has never really matched the expectations that followed him into the league.
He has not reached 40 points in any of his seven NHL seasons. Injuries have played a big role in that, since he has only topped 60 games in a season once in his professional career. That alone should give Edmonton pause.
Even when Dach has been available, the production has been ordinary. He posted eight goals and 15 points in 37 regular-season games in 2025-26, then added four goals and one assist in 19 playoff games.
That makes him a reclamation project, and that kind of gamble is harder to justify for a team trying to win now. The Oilers already have one project up front in Isaac Howard, and they do not have the luxury of taking on another.
If Edmonton is going to add a forward, a scoring winger would make more sense than another bet on upside. But even that probably should not be the main priority. The bigger problem is still in their own zone.
The Oilers have already allowed 14 goals in games against the Vancouver Canucks and Seattle Kraken, and that points to real work needed on the back end. Their blue line has struggled, and that’s where a trade should be aimed.
There are questions in goal as well, though changes there do not seem imminent. Devon Levi looked solid in his most recent start against the Kraken, and Frederik Andersen is expected back at some point in December. Edmonton will likely want to see that pair healthy before making any decisions.
For now, the smarter play looks simple: resist the urge to chase another reclamation project up front. Dach may still become the player many projected when he entered the league, but the Oilers do not have time to wait on that kind of turnaround. With a Stanley Cup still in view, their trade assets are better spent fixing the areas that are actually holding them back.
In Other News...
Former Canadiens Prospect Suddenly Has A Lot Riding On This Return
William Trudeaus path has taken an abrupt turn this fall, and it has already brought him to a place he probably could not have scripted when the season began. The former Canadiens prospect surfaced with the Nashville Predators after being cut by the New York Rangers, then claimed on waivers, and he has wasted little time getting his first NHL minutes under a new set of circumstances. Predators coach Andrew Brunette has liked what he has seen so far, which matters for a player trying to show he can stick at this level.
The next step comes with an extra layer of emotion, because Trudeau is set to line up against Montreal, the organization that once held his rights. He has been used in limited minutes in his first games with Nashville, so every shift has carried a little more weight as he tries to carve out a longer look. For a young defenseman trying to turn an opportunity into something more permanent, this return carries the kind of stakes that can quickly shape the rest of his season. [Read more 🡒]
Canadiens Suddenly Face A Goaltending Decision That Could Last Awhile
Samuel Montembeaults status has suddenly put the Canadiens in a familiar spot, with the team waiting on more information after the goalie dealt with a right leg injury and went through medical tests recently. The next step is an evaluation by team doctors, and that examination will help determine just how serious the issue is and what kind of timetable Montreal may be looking at for its starter.
For the moment, the Canadiens are moving ahead with a different crease plan. Jacob Fowler has been recalled and will get the start against the Nashville Predators, while Jakub Dobes is there to back him up as Montreal braces for the possibility that this could affect its goaltending picture for more than just one night. [Read more 🡒]
Canadiens Blew Another Lead But Two Lineup Bright Spots Emerged
The Canadiens had a chance to settle things down after jumping out to a 2-0 lead against Nashville, but the game slipped away late when the Predators scored three unanswered goals, including two empty-netters. The loss fit an early-season pattern for Montreal, which has had trouble protecting leads and has also been stuck in some rough second periods, where momentum has tilted away from the group far too often.
Still, there were a couple of encouraging signs buried in the defeat. Adam Engstrom, in his first appearance of the season, looked solid alongside Arber Xhekaj on the third defense pair despite limited ice time, and the second forward line posted the best expected goals-for percentage on the club. For a team searching for cleaner minutes and more stability, those are the kinds of details that matter even when the final score does not cooperate. [Read more 🡒]