The Montreal Canadiens came awfully close to a deal in the 2009 offseason that would have changed the franchise’s path in a major way, and Carey Price was right in the middle of it.
Former Lightning co-owner Oren Koules recently revisited the story on Oilers Now with Bob Stauffer, saying the sides had agreed to a trade that would have sent Price, P.K. Subban, Tomas Plekanec, Chris Higgins, and a first-round pick to Tampa Bay in exchange for Vincent Lecavalier and Mike Smith.
“The trade stopped the league we did,” Koules said. “What we negotiated was Carey Price, who was not their starting goalie in the playoffs that year in Montreal, and P.K. Subban, who was playing down in the minors at the time, [Tomas] Plekanec, [Chris] Higgins, and their first.”
Koules said the Canadiens were pushing for the move as George Gillett was in the process of selling the team to the Molson brothers, and Montreal wanted the “most prominent French player by a mile,” who at the time was the captain of the Tampa Bay Lightning.
“George Gillett, who owned Montreal at the time, was looking to sell them to Molson and was adamant to get the most prominent French player by a mile, which was the captain of the Tampa Bay Lightning.”
The deal never made it through because Gary Bettman stepped in and nullified it over a potential owner change. Koules didn’t put an exact date on when the talks happened, but the timeline points toward the 2009-10 season. Higgins was later traded to the New York Rangers that summer, and the sale of the Canadiens to the Molsons was completed in October.
Koules also explained that the Lightning were dealing with their own ownership mess at the time. He and co-owner Len Barrie were headed for a split, and Barrie had a prospective buyer lined up. That buyer, Koules said, would only come in if Lecavalier stayed put.
“Lenny was convinced, and not his fault as I think he was snaked by someone, who said he could afford to buy me out and buy out all the limited and keep him and Lenny in. However, he wanted Lecavalier and as part of the deal, Lecavalier had to stay,” Koules said.
“Gary took him at his word, and I don't blame Gary, and the trade was nullified.”
For Montreal, the what-if is enormous. Price went on to become the franchise’s all-time leader in games started with 700 and wins with 361, and he won the Vezina Trophy, Hart Memorial Trophy, and Ted Lindsay Award in his standout 2014-15 season. Subban, meanwhile, had not yet played an NHL game at the time of the proposed swap and later delivered a Norris Trophy season in 2012-13.
Lecavalier, for his part, was still coming off a 52-goal season two years earlier, but he never really reached that level again. In the end, the Canadiens dodged a deal that might not have aged well for them, and Bettman’s intervention kept Price in Montreal.
In Other News...
Canadiens Fans Face Another Frustrating Change To Watching Their Team
Canadiens fans are staring at another shift in how they will watch their team, with the NHL and Gary Bettman confirming a 12-year broadcast agreement with Rogers Communications that deepens the leagues long-term move toward streaming in Canada. The new setup will bring English and French coverage into the mix, a reminder that the viewing experience for Quebec audiences is once again changing along with the leagues media landscape.
The biggest immediate wrinkle for Montreal supporters is the timing: Wednesday night NHL games in Canada are set to move to Prime Video beginning in the 2026-27 season. For the Canadiens, that means seven games will be part of the package, adding another layer of adjustment for fans who have already seen the way they follow the team evolve in recent years. [Read more 🡒]
Canadiens Just Showed Exactly What They Value In This Rebuild
Mike Mathesons new five-year extension says plenty about what the Canadiens are trying to build, and what they expect from the veterans helping steer the rebuild. Montreal has leaned on Matheson as more than a puck-moving defenseman, using him in a variety of jobs as the roster around him has changed, and the organization clearly values that kind of adaptability as much as any highlight-reel offense.
He has gone from top power-play quarterback to a second-unit role and then into penalty-kill duty, all while remaining a steady presence for a team still sorting out its long-term blue line. Kent Hughes has made it clear he sees Matheson as the kind of player who puts team success ahead of individual numbers, and the extension gives Montreal a reliable piece whose value could shift again if the lineup changes around Lane Hutson or Noah Dobson. [Read more 🡒]
Canadiens Fans Wont All Agree On This Kirby Dach Trade Twist
Kirby Dachs name is back in the rumor mill, and for Canadiens fans that alone is enough to split opinion. Reports have linked Montreal to trade discussions involving the young center, with the idea that his inclusion could help the club reshape its forward group as it looks for a different kind of fit in the lineup.
The twist is less about whether Montreal is listening and more about what Dach represents in those talks. His injuries, uneven play and uncertain availability have all fed into a murky valuation, and any move would almost certainly need more than just one player going the other way. The Canadiens would likely have to add more to the package, and for now the whole thing remains speculative, which is why the debate around Dach feels so much bigger than a simple trade rumor. [Read more 🡒]