A quarter of the way through the 2026-27 season, the Montreal Canadiens have given people plenty to argue about. That’s the whole point here: sorting the claims that sound outrageous from the ones that might actually stick.
Start with the biggest one. Jacob Fowler has not solved Montreal’s goaltending future, at least not yet.
The temptation is obvious. The 21-year-old has won over the fanbase, earned the trust of the coaching staff and his teammates, and looked calm and polished from the opening stretch of the season.
He’s technically sharp, athletic, and the kind of goalie who makes difficult stops look routine.
The numbers back up the eye test. Even after the 3-1 loss to the New York Rangers on Nov.
16, Fowler owns a 2.21 goals-against average, a .923 save percentage, and a 9-2-2 record. Those marks put him in elite company, with the save percentage sitting in the top five and the rest top-10 worthy.
Carey Price, now a recent Hall of Fame inductee, even said he sees himself in Fowler.
Still, Canadiens fans have seen this movie before. In 2024-25, Samuel Montembeault was the man in net and helped fuel hopes of an unexpected push toward a Stanley Cup Playoffs berth.
Last season, Jakub Dobes did the same thing. Both looked like the answer at the time.
Fowler may be better than either of them, but the lingering question remains until he’s the clear starter over a full season. If he starts most games next season, then the label will feel earned.
The same patience applies to Juraj Slafkovsky. He is not a bust, even if the start has been rough enough to make people squirm.
The pressure is real for anyone skating on the top offensive line and handling power-play responsibilities, and the underlying numbers are ugly. His goals scored above expected sits at minus-5.8, and his goals scored per 60 minutes versus expected is 0.31.
But he is involved, and that matters. If he weren’t driving play, those expected numbers would not be where they are.
He has 13 points, which ranks fourth on the team, and 11 of them are assists. He’s also chipped in four power-play assists on a unit that has struggled.
There’s no sign of a player drifting through shifts. Quite the opposite.
He’s creating chances, and with 63 games left, there’s time for the finishing to catch up.
Then there’s Cole Caufield, who is very much on track to make another run at 50 goals. Through 21 games, he has 12 goals.
Stretch that pace over the quarter-mark and you get 48, which is close enough to make the conversation real. He has already shown enough finishing touch to believe the rest can follow if the bounces cooperate.
Caufield’s case is simple: if anyone on this roster can do it, it’s him. His expected goals for is 8.8, which ranks 33rd league-wide, and his 3.2 goals above expected is good for 24th.
He’s already tied for ninth in the league in goals, and he keeps finding ways to score from almost anywhere. The only thing he hasn’t done this season is pull off a Michigan.
Short of injury or a major slump, he looks very much like a player who can threaten 50 again.
The one overreaction that doesn’t hold up is the idea that these Canadiens are Stanley Cup contenders. They are not, at least not based on what they’ve shown so far.
Yes, the record looks strong at 12-5-4, and yes, they are tied for first in the Atlantic Division with the Boston Bruins and Tampa Bay Lightning. Fowler has been excellent.
Caufield has been dangerous. Slafkovsky is contributing.
Nick Suzuki and Lane Hutson deserve mention too.
But contender status has to be earned against the right kind of nights, and Montreal has already had too many of those nights go sideways. The Carolina Hurricanes still look like the team to beat in the Eastern Conference, and they already handled the Canadiens in the Eastern Conference Final last season and spoiled this season’s home opener. Montreal also dropped a 2-1 decision to the Minnesota Wild on Nov. 10, lost 4-1 to a Colorado Avalanche team that was supposed to be weakened without Nathan MacKinnon and Cale Makar, and fell 5-4 in overtime to the Winnipeg Jets.
That’s not the profile of a team that should be handed the contender label just yet. Could they win the Stanley Cup?
Sure. With their goaltending, top-end talent, captaincy, and depth, the path exists.
But calling them contenders right now goes too far.
And that’s the real lesson of the quarter-mark: it’s too early to overreact in either direction. The Canadiens are 21 games into an 84-game grind, not to mention whatever comes after that. Nobody needs to declare this team finished or crowned based on what’s happened so far.
Some people are already ready to go all in on the hype. That’s premature. Absolutely not.
In Other News...
Canadiens Make A Risky Lineup Shift Before Hurricanes Test
The Canadiens are turning to Jakub Dobes in goal for their matchup with the Carolina Hurricanes, choosing to rest Jacob Fowler after his strong showing in the previous game. It is a notable switch for a team heading into the second half of a back-to-back, especially with Carolina looming as one of the leagues toughest opponents.
Montreal may also have to shuffle its skaters again, with Zachary Bolduc expected to miss the game because of injury. That opens the door for Florian Xhekaj to potentially get back into the lineup, giving the Canadiens a different look as they try to manage the workload and survive a demanding test against a top-ranked team. [Read more 🡒]
Islanders Fans Can Already See Why This Noah Dobson Move Is Debated
When Montreal paid a steep price to land Noah Dobson from the Islanders in the summer of 2025, the move came with the kind of expectations that follow an eight-year deal at $9.5 million annually. The Canadiens sent two first-round picks and Emil Heineman to New York, betting that Dobsons previous offensive production would help anchor the blue line and give the club a true difference-maker on defense.
So far, the fit has not been as straightforward as the price tag suggested. Dobson has yet to deliver consistent offense for Montreal, and his role has been complicated by the presence of other young defensemen in the mix as well as Mike Mathesons injury. It is the sort of early uncertainty that can make a bold summer acquisition look very different once the games start piling up. [Read more 🡒]
Canadiens Had A Postgame Gesture In New Jersey Fans Needed Explained
After the Canadiens left Prudential Center with a win, a small postgame moment drew extra attention from the crowd and from anyone watching closely. Jacob Fowler and Cole Caufield made a point of acknowledging Alexandre Carriers parents in the stands during the celebration, a gesture that fit the mood of a team that had just put together a solid road result and wanted to share it.
Carrier had earned the spotlight in his own way, logging more than 24 minutes and doing important work on the defensive side as Montreal tightened things up late. Fowler stopped 28 shots, Jake Evans supplied the game-winning goal, and the Canadiens picked up a result that helped their position in the Atlantic Division, even if the family connection in the stands ended up becoming one of the nights more memorable details. [Read more 🡒]
