Mississippi State Suddenly Has A QB Decision That Changes Everything

Mississippi State faces an unexpected quarterback dilemma against Tennessee Tech as key players are sidelined, leaving the role open to less experienced but eager candidates.

Mississippi State will head into Saturday’s game against Tennessee Tech without AJ Swann, and that pushes the Bulldogs even deeper into quarterback uncertainty.

Coach Jeff Lebby said on Nov. 18 that Swann will not be available because of an unspecified injury. Swann left the previous game against Auburn twice and wore a boot on his left foot for the second half. With star quarterback Kamario Taylor also sidelined after his Oct. 28 season-ending surgery, Mississippi State is left with a third-string answer under center.

Lebby still hasn’t named a starter for the Nov. 21 matchup at Davis Wade Stadium, but the most likely options are former walk-on Billy Puckett and freshman Brodie McWhorter. They are the only other quarterbacks who have seen game action this season. Jaden Rashada, a Sacramento State transfer, has not played, though he was in uniform against Auburn.

When asked about McWhorter, Lebby said "there will be an opportunity" for the freshman to play against the Golden Eagles.

"For us, it is going to be about who gives us the best chance to go get first downs and score touchdowns," Lebby said. "But, again, most importantly, take great care of the football.

Brodie has continued to get better and better. I think I mentioned it on Monday, a guy that's been on scout team all year long has just gotten some of his first work with us the last 2-3 weeks.

He's continued to get better. We're going to need that from him as we get ready to finish it out."

McWhorter, a three-star in the 2026 recruiting class, made his first appearance in Mississippi State’s 41-9 loss to Auburn. He took three possessions in the middle of the game, completed one pass for 10 yards and was sacked once for a 10-yard loss.

The Bulldogs went three-and-out on two of those drives and also lost a fumble by Kolin Wilson while McWhorter was on the field.

Lebby said McWhorter got the opportunity because of Puckett’s turnover problems. Puckett, who joined the team as a walk-on last season, has played more often than McWhorter and started at LSU on Oct. 17, but he fumbled twice in the second quarter against Auburn. Auburn recovered one of those fumbles and scored four plays later.

McWhorter handled the first drive of the third quarter, which ended in another three-and-out, and Puckett finished the game.

Puckett’s season numbers include a 61.4% completion rate, 458 passing yards, one touchdown, two interceptions, 97 rushing yards and no rushing scores.

McWhorter has completed all of his passes so far, going 1-for-1 for 10 yards, with two interceptions, minus-10 rushing yards and no rushing touchdowns.

Lebby also said starting safety Isaac Smith will not play against Tennessee Tech. Smith has been out since Oct. 17 with an unspecified injury, and Kendel Dolby has been starting in his place.

Mississippi State is 4-6 and will try to snap a six-game losing streak against Tennessee Tech, which is 9-2. After that, the Bulldogs close the regular season at Ole Miss on Nov. 27.

In Other News...

UCFs First Loss Exposed A Problem Knights Fans Cant Ignore

UCFs first loss of the season came with a little extra edge for Mississippi State, which held on for an 86-83 win after weathering a second-half push from the Knights. The Bulldogs had to dig out of a deficit before the game tightened late, and they steadied themselves at the line in the final seconds to close it out.

For UCF, the bigger concern may be how the night unfolded around Dior Johnson. He poured in 20 points in the first half and finished with 26, but his production dipped after the break as Mississippi State adjusted and made the Knights work harder for every clean look. The loss exposed how quickly a hot start can cool when a game turns into a halfcourt grind, and it left UCF with a first blemish that will stick with them for a while. [Read more 🡒]