Matthew Schaefer didn’t just beat the Wild on Thursday night. He left them talking.
The Islanders’ 19-year-old defenseman put on a show in Minnesota, scoring the game-tying goal in the first period and then finishing it off with the overtime winner in New York’s 4-3 victory. By the end of the night, he had added another layer to the growing buzz around his game - and he had plenty of people around the Wild giving him major respect.
Minnesota defenseman Quinn Hughes was especially struck by how advanced Schaefer already looks at 19, going so far as to say the teenager could eventually become one of the league’s very best players.
“He’s really impressive. I mean, when I was 19, I was a sophomore at Michigan.
And when Cale [Makar] was 19, he was a freshman and did one more year, or two more, I forget. But same with Fox, he did three years.
Werenski, too. Like, all those guys I just mentioned were in college at this kid’s age.
So he’s obviously really good.”
Hughes didn’t stop there. He made it clear he sees a much bigger ceiling ahead for Schaefer, especially as the defenseman matures through his early 20s.
“Yeah, really like his game. But I think for him, being 19, this is all gravy right now.
Like, when he’s 22, 23, 24, 25, all the way up, I mean, those are the years where he can really - he should be a top-three, top-five player in the league. So he’s just got to keep climbing.
But it’s obviously impressive with where he’s at at 19.”
That kind of praise matters coming from Hughes, who knows exactly what elite offensive defensemen look like.
Wild coach John Hynes echoed the sentiment, pointing to Schaefer’s skating and his ability to drive offense as the traits that jump out first.
“He’s good. He’s hard to play against.
He’s a great skater. You saw what he can do with the puck, and he’s an offense driver and he was good tonight,” Hynes said.
“Yeah, he has the ability, he’s got good size, but I think the thing that helps him is his skating is elite. He’s able to hold onto the puck and do some things at the offensive blue line and some of the things that you see with the premier offensive defensemen in the league he has that skill set.”
That was the difference-maker again Thursday. Schaefer’s skating helped him control the puck, stay alive in dangerous areas and create chances from the blue line, exactly the kind of traits that make established offense-first defensemen so tough to handle.
Wild forward Nico Sturm said Schaefer’s confidence at this age is part of what stands out, and he drew a comparison to Hughes.
“I think that’s pretty fair to say. I just admire the guys coming into the league at 18, 19, and the confidence that they have and just looking like they’ve been in the league for eight years,” Sturm said.
“I don’t know what these guys do growing up, to be honest with you. It’s kind of insane.
They just all get good hands, good skating, elite shot. I think I missed that part growing up.
Minnesota forward Matt Boldy had a similar read after the game, saying the Wild never really found a way to slow Schaefer down.
“Yeah, he’s a heck of a player for sure. He showed it tonight.
I don’t think we did a good enough job of slowing him down, making his life a little bit harder,” Boldy said. “But credit to him, he plays the game like he’s been playing for 10, 15 years.
It’s pretty fun to watch. Future is obviously pretty bright.
They’re pretty lucky to have him over there.”
The numbers keep backing up the eye test. Schaefer now has four goals, ten assists and 14 points in 13 games.
Thursday was his fifth career multi-goal game, which tied Phil Housley for the most by a teenage defenseman in NHL history. He also became the first teenage defenseman in league history with three career overtime goals, breaking a tie with Cam Fowler, who had two.
For the Islanders, it was another night where Schaefer looked anything but ordinary. For the Wild, it was a front-row look at a teenager already playing with the confidence, skill and poise of a much older player.
In Other News...
Wild Fans Should Be Worried About This Dylan Larkin Push
The idea of the Wild chasing Dylan Larkin is the kind of rumor that naturally gets attention in Minnesota, especially with the club looking for ways to sharpen its long-term outlook. Larkin is a productive center and a legitimate top-end player, but the discussion around him is less about star power alone and more about what kind of roster shape Minnesota would be buying into if it pushed hard for a deal with Detroit.
The problem is that a move like this would not come cheap, and the Wild would have to weigh immediate help against the cost of thinning out a prospect pool that still matters to their future. Any serious pursuit also comes with the usual trade-off questions about whether a team is adding the right piece for contention or overpaying for a player who raises the floor without changing the ceiling in the way a true franchise centerpiece would. [Read more 🡒]
Wild Blue Line Crisis Makes One Recent Decision Look Much Worse
The Wilds blue line has been under constant strain, and a decision from late October looks a lot shakier in hindsight. Minnesota put Daemon Hunt on waivers on Oct. 23 because of salary cap constraints and roster management, a move that came when the defense group still had more breathing room than it does now. Since then, the Wild have been forced to keep patching together their back end, with Carson Lambos recalled and Cameron Crotty brought in as the injuries and lineup shuffling piled up.
What makes the Hunt move stand out is how quickly the situation changed around it. Jared Spurgeon and Brock Faber have both been unavailable, leaving Minnesota thin on the blue line and searching for answers while it continues to juggle roster moves and trade discussions. In that context, losing a young defenseman for nothing has become another reminder of how narrow the margin has been for the Wild as they try to stabilize the position. [Read more 🡒]
Hurricanes Fans Will Recognize The Trade Problem In Quinn Hughes Situation
Quinn Hughes has put the Wild in a familiar kind of waiting game, one that leaves front offices trying to read tea leaves without much help from the player side. His future in Minnesota remains uncertain, with no clear sign yet on whether he will commit to an extension or drift toward free agency, and that uncertainty is already shaping how the team has to think about its next move.
Elliotte Friedman pointed out the wrinkle that makes this situation especially tricky: unlike Mikko Rantanen, Hughes has not given Minnesota a list of teams he would be willing to sign with. That leaves the Wild with a hard choice between holding onto him and exploring a trade, but any deal would still come with the uncomfortable possibility that a new team could pay the price and still end up watching him walk away. [Read more 🡒]