Jaxson Dart’s looming knee surgery has already pushed J.J. McCarthy back into the trade conversation, and the New York Giants suddenly look like the cleanest fit if Minnesota decides to listen.
That doesn’t mean a deal is brewing. NFL Network’s report on Dart only adds a possible landing spot to the chatter; it does not say the Vikings and Giants are talking.
But it does explain why McCarthy speculation picked up so quickly. New York needs a quarterback who can help right away, and with Dart expected to miss the rest of the season, the Giants’ urgency just got a lot more real.
Minnesota, meanwhile, has its own quarterback situation sorted out for Sunday. Kyler Murray cleared concussion protocol and will start against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.
Carson Wentz filled in when Murray was hurt in Week 1 and started the win at Chicago. McCarthy, 23, sits behind both of them.
That’s why the idea of moving him is more complicated than it sounds. If the Giants called, there’s at least a case for picking up the phone.
But Dart’s injury alone should not be enough to make Minnesota ship out a young quarterback the moment the market stirs. McCarthy hasn’t shown he can be a dependable answer yet, and New York would be asking for help now, not later.
The Giants already turned to Jameis Winston after Dart went down against the Los Angeles Rams, and the results were rough: 11-for-27 for 111 yards and an interception. Jake Haener is also on New York’s practice squad. Winston’s outing gave the Giants plenty to worry about, even if he was thrown into the game without first-team reps.
One poor performance from the former No. 1 overall pick doesn’t suddenly make McCarthy the obvious upgrade. McCarthy went 6-4 in 10 starts last season, but Minnesota still went with Murray to run Kevin O’Connell’s offense, with Wentz as the backup.
Where this gets interesting for New York is the timeline. Dart is the starter when healthy, which changes the logic of any move.
McCarthy could be attractive because he’s young enough to develop while competing with Winston, and a change of scenery might help after his uneven stint in Minnesota. But if the Giants are trading for a quarterback, they’d be spending assets on a player who might only be filling in until Dart returns.
That’s a much tougher sell than bringing in veteran insurance.
Minnesota has reasons to be patient, too. Murray’s concussion ended his Vikings debut after 11 snaps, and Wentz had to guide the offense through two division wins.
McCarthy’s move to QB3 puts him squarely in trade territory, but the first two games also showed how quickly that third quarterback spot can matter. If New York makes a serious offer, general manager Nolan Teasley should at least hear it out.
What Minnesota shouldn’t do is give away depth just because Murray is back for Week 3.
The Giants’ next checkpoint comes Sunday against the Tennessee Titans, with Winston expected to start. How he performs in a full game, and whether New York looks for another quarterback after that, will tell the story better than Dart’s injury alone.
In Other News...
Vikings Young Talent Is Already Separating After Ugly Week 2
The Vikings may be sitting at the top of the division after a 9-3 win over the Bears, but the bigger story for Minnesota has been how quickly the young roster is starting to sort itself out. A few early standouts helped steady a sloppy game, with Banks turning in six tackles and Donovan Jackson continuing his strong start at guard, giving the team reasons to feel better about the future even in a grind-it-out divisional fight.
Elsewhere, the picture is less settled. Tai Felton and Claiborne are still trying to carve out meaningful roles, while Brett Thorson has looked useful as a punter but is now dealing with a hamstring injury. For a team trying to build depth around its core, the early season is already separating the players who are moving forward from the ones still waiting for their chance. [Read more 🡒]
Rob Brzezinski's Tough Call Helped Spark The Vikings Pass Rush
When Minnesota moved Jonathan Greenard to the Eagles in exchange for two picks late in the third round of the NFL Draft, it was the kind of deal that looked more like a long view than a quick fix. Interim general manager Rob Brzezinski made clear it was not an easy call, and he also understood the obvious downside: the move did not make the Vikings better right away.
Dallas Turner has helped explain why the front office was willing to endure that short-term discomfort. After the trade, Turner emerged as one of the teams most important pass rushers and has given the defense a much-needed edge off the edge. For a Vikings team always chasing pressure and disruption, the return on that gamble is beginning to show up in a hurry. [Read more 🡒]
Bears QB Trouble Just Got Worse After That Vikings Game
The Bears left their matchup with the Vikings already dealing with quarterback uncertainty, and the situation has only become messier heading into Week 3. Tyson Bagent is now in the NFL's concussion protocol, putting his status in doubt for Chicago's game against the Philadelphia Eagles, while Caleb Williams is also sidelined with a hamstring issue and is considered week to week.
If both young quarterbacks are unavailable, the next option could be Case Keenum, a veteran who has not been asked to carry a full-time starting role in quite some time. For a Bears team trying to steady itself early in the season, that kind of depth chart shuffle is hardly ideal, and it leaves one of the league's most watched quarterback situations hanging over the week. [Read more 🡒]