The Minnesota Vikings had high hopes when they drafted J.J. McCarthy as their franchise quarterback with the 10th overall pick in the 2024 NFL Draft. But two seasons in, things haven't exactly gone as planned.
McCarthy's rookie season was a washout due to injury, and his second year was marred by more injuries and accuracy issues. With only 10 starts under his belt, the question arises: should the Vikings consider moving on? While it's unlikely, ESPN's Aaron Schatz suggests that a fresh start could benefit McCarthy.
Schatz argues that despite McCarthy's first-round potential, a change of scenery might be what's needed for his career to take off. Although staying with an offensive-minded coach like Minnesota's Kevin O'Connell is ideal for a young quarterback's development, the shadow of Super Bowl winner Sam Darnold looms large, and last season's struggles might warrant a new beginning elsewhere.
As the offseason unfolds, the Vikings are expected to bring in another quarterback to challenge McCarthy during training camp. One name making the rounds is former Vikings QB Kirk Cousins.
Whoever they choose, it's crucial for the Vikings to solidify their quarterback situation. With such a talented roster, they can't afford another year of subpar QB play in 2026.
McCarthy's leash is short. The Vikings need more from their quarterback position, and the pressure is on to deliver.