The Minnesota Vikings moved on from JJ McCarthy in late September, and inside the building, there doesn’t seem to be any second-guessing.
That’s the big takeaway from Dan Graziano of ESPN, who reports that people around the team are comfortable with the decision even after McCarthy’s early success with the New York Giants. Minnesota, according to Graziano, was happy to see him do well in New York, and “everyone agrees it was time for a scenery change.”
McCarthy’s run in Minnesota had already become a strange, uneven chapter. He spent his rookie season on injured reserve because of a knee injury, then flashed right away by winning NFC Offensive Player of the Week in his first start, Week 1 last season in Chicago. That turned out to be the peak of his time as the Vikings’ quarterback.
The former Michigan national champion went 6-4 in 10 starts for Minnesota in 2025, throwing 11 touchdowns and 12 interceptions. Then the Vikings signed Kyler Murray and opened a quarterback battle in training camp, a competition Murray eventually won. Not long after that, McCarthy was dealt to the Giants for a 2027 fifth-round draft pick, less than three years after Minnesota had taken him No. 10 overall.
Since landing in New York, McCarthy has already given Giants fans plenty to get excited about. He has started one game, going 20-of-28 for 252 yards with no touchdowns, no interceptions and a 99.1 passer rating in a 27-21 win over the Houston Texans. The week before that, he came off the bench for Jameis Winston and nearly pulled off a historic second-half comeback.
One social media post summed up the buzz around his debut: “JJ McCarthy SHINED in his Giants debut: - 243 Passing Yards - 26 Rushing Yards - 1 TD, 1 INT All in just one quarter.”
While McCarthy was turning heads in New York, Murray was having a quieter stretch in Minnesota. He went 14-of-24 for 150 yards and a touchdown in the Vikings’ 16-10 win over the Colts in Week 7, then followed that with a rough outing in Detroit while McCarthy was on a bye.
Even with Murray’s uneven play, the Vikings still aren’t sounding regretful. In six starts this season, Murray has completed 100 of 154 passes for 1,022 yards, five touchdowns and three interceptions. Kevin O’Connell said “Yes” when asked whether Murray would remain the starter if healthy.
For now, though, Murray’s hamstring injury has clouded the picture, not just for Monday Night Football against the Buffalo Bills, but for the Vikings’ quarterback future as well. Minnesota’s first injury report of the week comes Thursday.
In Other News...
Vikings Are Wasting A Defense That Should Change Everything
The Vikings keep showing the same frustrating split: a defense good enough to change the shape of the season, and an offense that keeps making that harder than it should be. In Week 8, Minnesotas defense again did its part against Detroit, limiting a quality opponent and reinforcing the idea that this unit has become one of the leagues best at squeezing out possessions and forcing teams into uncomfortable football.
What makes it sting is how little help the defense is getting from the other side of the ball. Minnesotas offense has struggled to stay on schedule and finish drives, leaving the Vikings stuck in a familiar place where elite defensive play is being asked to cover for too much. For a team with a defense this strong, thats the kind of imbalance that can define a season if it doesnt get corrected soon. [Read more 🡒]
Vikings May Be Mishandling Ivan Pace Jr At The Worst Time
Ivan Pace Jr. has remained a familiar part of the Vikings' game-day mix this season, but mostly on special teams, even as the defense has settled into its current linebacker rotation. Through seven games, his role on defense has been limited, which stands out for a player who flashed enough as a rookie to make you wonder whether Minnesota should be doing more with him right now.
The timing matters because Pace is on a one-year contract, and the Vikings do not appear set up to make a long-term commitment at linebacker with other options already entrenched in starting spots. If Minnesota is going to consider moving him, giving him a bigger defensive platform would help clarify what kind of value he might have around the league, and the next stretch of games could determine whether he stays buried in a depth role or gets a real chance to raise his stock. [Read more 🡒]
Vikings History Still Turns On One Franchise Defining In-Season Trade
The Vikings are still sitting at 6-1 and on top of the NFC North even after a recent loss to the Lions, but the franchises history keeps circling back to one move that helped define its identity. In ESPNs look at the biggest in-season trade in team history, Jim Marshalls arrival in 1961 stands out as the kind of transaction that shaped far more than a roster spot.
Marshall went on to become one of the most durable and respected players in franchise history, setting an NFL record for consecutive games played and serving as a longtime captain. His number is retired by the Vikings, a reminder that some trades are remembered less for the moment they happened than for the standard they helped establish. [Read more 🡒]