Kyler Murray is starting to separate himself in the Minnesota Vikings’ 2026 quarterback battle, and the gap looked even wider after Wednesday’s most intense padded practice of camp.
That’s not the view from every corner, though. National insiders who aren’t at practice have continued to say neither Murray nor JJ McCarthy has truly seized control. NFL Network’s Ian Rapoport, who was on hand at TCO Performance Center on Wednesday, repeated the earlier read that this competition could drag all the way through the preseason after speaking with sources inside the organization.
But the people actually watching these sessions day after day keep seeing something different.
Local reporters who have been at training camp, OTAs and minicamp have consistently leaned toward Murray, and Wednesday seemed to strengthen that belief. Star Tribune beat writer Andrew Krammer called it “the most lopsided practice yet in regards to first-team reps”.
Krammer’s snap counts tell the story plainly. In the six practices he has charted - not including the July 31 walkthrough - Murray has piled up 73 first-team reps to McCarthy’s 38. On Wednesday alone, Murray took 18 first-team reps while McCarthy got seven.
Matthew Coller of Purple Insider, who has covered the Vikings beat for more than a decade, also came away with Murray clearly ahead. On his YouTube channel, Coller broke down the day throw by throw and had Murray at 14 of 22 between first- and second-team work, compared with 13 of 22 for McCarthy.
On his podcast, Coller said Murray handled most of the important work with the starters.
“(5:30) Kyler Murray took the majority of the throws and reps with the first team [Wednesday], including the situational drill at the end, 1’s vs 1’s, including the most intense 11 on 11, he took every one of those. It was only in the red zone and the early part of practice in 7 on 7s when we saw JJ McCarthy work with the 1s.”
He added:
“(11:35) After this day off, I’m curious if we start to see the total passes - because McCarthy [has gotten the same number of total passes] - if that starts to shift and we start to see Kyler Murray take all the 1’s and all the 2’s for a lot of the segments of practice into the future, and we will pretty much have our answer.”
And later:
“(12:17) Things could change into next week, you never know what could happen. But when, now, the totality of the first seven days of Vikings practice has Kyler Murray leading with a lot more first team reps totally and a lot better performance”
Coller said Murray produced seven positive plays on the day, including three deep completions that traveled 20 or more yards in the air. McCarthy, by contrast, had just one positive play and four negatives. Coller said McCarthy’s biggest issue remains his ability to push the ball downfield, noting that he leaned heavily on screens and shorter throws.
He also went a step further on the latest Purple Insider episode, saying 2026 training camp has been McCarthy’s worst to date. After “asking around”, Coller said the feeling around camp matched his own.
“There’s just a lot of [passes] that did not get past the line of scrimmage [for JJ McCarthy]. And some of that was because they were running swing passes and screens with him, with the, the 1st and 2nd team. But even when it was 7 on 7, there just was not a lot pushed down the field and hasn’t been for this entire camp.”
“You know, just asking around, are other people seeing what I’m seeing? Do we think that this has looked worse for JJ McCarthy than either of his last two camps?
And the answer I’ve gotten from everybody is pretty much yes. And, you start to wonder at this point, is it more about confidence for JJ McCarthy than it is maybe trying not to make a mistake or, or whatever, that he can’t actually get it done, because I don’t think it’s knowledge of the offense.”
The Vikings clearly hoped the addition of Murray would bring out the best in McCarthy. Instead, the early read from camp is that McCarthy may have slipped even further.
There’s still preseason football ahead, and that’s where this battle could get its final answers. But right now, the signs point one way: Murray is pulling away.
In Other News...
Charles Demmings Is Giving Vikings Fans Real Reason For Optimism
Charles Demmings has been one of the more encouraging developments at Vikings training camp, where the rookie cornerback has made a strong early impression with his athleticism and nonstop energy. Coaches and teammates have taken notice of the way he carries himself, pointing to the confidence, work ethic and easy presence he has brought to the field and the locker room.
On the practice field, Demmings has backed that up with timely pass breakups and the kind of competitive flash that can quickly get a young defensive back on the radar. For a Minnesota secondary always looking for usable depth and upside, his emergence offers a real reason for optimism, even if the bigger question is how far that momentum can carry once the sessions get more demanding. [Read more 🡒]
Bears Left Tackle Situation Could Matter To The Vikings Early
With the Bears still sorting through their offensive line picture, the left tackle spot is one of the early NFC North situations worth watching from Minnesotas side. Chicago general manager Ryan Poles said the club is open to adding help on the defensive line but generally feels comfortable with its roster, while the team also dealt with Kyler Gordon missing practice because of a calf injury. In the middle of all that, the Bears are evaluating their options at left tackle, a spot that can shape how steady the offense looks before the season settles in.
Braxton Jones has been getting first-team reps as Chicago works through the position, which gives the Vikings another wrinkle to track in a division matchup that could turn on protection and pressure. For Minnesota, any uncertainty up front in Chicago matters early because it can affect how the Bears handle pass rushers and how quickly that offense can find rhythm. The bigger question is whether the Bears can stabilize the edge before it becomes a problem, and the answer may not come immediately. [Read more 🡒]
Brian Flores Ranking Sparks A Vikings Debate Fans Wont Ignore
Brian Flores has spent three seasons turning the Vikings defense into one of the more respected units in the league, with Minnesota finishing in top-10 territory in multiple categories under his watch. So when CBS Sports asked 12 NFL analysts to rank the games best defensive play callers, Flores landing fifth immediately stirred the kind of debate that usually follows a coach who has built a clear identity and delivered steady results.
The list put him behind Mike MacDonald, Steve Spagnuolo, Jesse Minter and Vic Fangio, and the most eyebrow-raising part for Vikings fans was Minter jumping ahead of Flores. It is the sort of ranking that invites a real conversation about how much weight should go to recent buzz versus sustained production, especially when Flores has already shown he can reshape a defense and keep it near the top of the league. [Read more 🡒]