The Vikings may be headed for a 3-0 start, but JJ McCarthy’s spot on the depth chart is still the kind that gets attention for all the wrong reasons.
Minnesota can move to 3-0 for the first time since 2024 and just the sixth time since 2000 if it beats the 0-2 Tampa Bay Buccaneers on Sunday. Kevin O’Connell will have starting quarterback Kyler Murray back in Week 3 after Murray missed Week 2’s win in Chicago, following a concussion on the 11th play of the opener against the Green Bay Packers. Carson Wentz, the 33-year-old NDSU alum, has been holding down QB2 duty in Murray’s absence, while McCarthy sits as QB3 and would only be available in an emergency in Tampa.
That’s not exactly the kind of role anyone imagines for a 2024 first-round pick. McCarthy’s name has mostly faded from the conversation since he started camp competing for the job and then dropped all the way to third on the Vikings’ quarterback chart by Week 1.
But on Tuesday, the silence around McCarthy broke in a hurry.
Veteran NFL reporter Gary Myers suggested the Giants should call Minnesota and try to swing a deal for McCarthy after news surfaced that New York starter Jaxson Dart may be out for the season because of a knee injury suffered in Week 2.
“If Jaxson Dart is done for the year, I think the @Giants should trade for Vikings third-string QB J.J. McCarthy.
GM Joe Schoen considered him w/6th overall pick in 2024 (they took Malik Nabers). McCarthy helped Jim Harbaugh win national championship in 2023 and he loves McCarthy.
John and Jim often sign players with a history with each other. Probably would cost only mid-round pick and Giants could run same RPO offense they were using with Dart that is not suited to Jameis Winston.
If McCarthy plays well for Giants, can build up his value to trade him after season or supplant Winston as Dart’s backup. Low-risk move.
McCarthy has been huge disappointment in Minnesota but he’s only 23 years old, a few months older than Dart.”
Myers’ point centered on something that has been true for a while: the Giants have long had an eye on McCarthy. New York seriously considered him with the No. 6 overall pick in the 2024 draft before taking Malik Nabers instead. And this wasn’t the first time McCarthy had come up as a possible trade fit for the Giants, either.
Back in late August, when McCarthy was sliding down Minnesota’s depth chart, NFL insider Jason La Canfora also mentioned New York as a team that could show interest if the Vikings were willing to move him for a low price.
The comparison between McCarthy and Dart is part of what makes the idea easy to float. McCarthy has played in just 10 games, with 57% completions, 1,632 yards, 11 touchdowns and 12 interceptions. A knee injury in his rookie year wiped out that season and clearly slowed his development.
Dart, meanwhile, has already built a much larger NFL sample despite being drafted a year later. The former USC quarterback has appeared in 16 games and started 14 of them. He’s completed 64.9% of his passes, thrown for 2,522 yards, and posted 18 touchdowns against 5 interceptions.
For now, McCarthy remains in Minnesota as QB3. But with the Giants staring at a potentially season-changing injury, his name is back in the trade conversation.
In Other News...
Vikings Young Talent Is Already Separating After Ugly Week 2
The Vikings may be sitting at the top of the division after a 9-3 win over the Bears, but the bigger story for Minnesota has been how quickly the young roster is starting to sort itself out. A few early standouts helped steady a sloppy game, with Banks turning in six tackles and Donovan Jackson continuing his strong start at guard, giving the team reasons to feel better about the future even in a grind-it-out divisional fight.
Elsewhere, the picture is less settled. Tai Felton and Claiborne are still trying to carve out meaningful roles, while Brett Thorson has looked useful as a punter but is now dealing with a hamstring injury. For a team trying to build depth around its core, the early season is already separating the players who are moving forward from the ones still waiting for their chance. [Read more 🡒]
Rob Brzezinski's Tough Call Helped Spark The Vikings Pass Rush
When Minnesota moved Jonathan Greenard to the Eagles in exchange for two picks late in the third round of the NFL Draft, it was the kind of deal that looked more like a long view than a quick fix. Interim general manager Rob Brzezinski made clear it was not an easy call, and he also understood the obvious downside: the move did not make the Vikings better right away.
Dallas Turner has helped explain why the front office was willing to endure that short-term discomfort. After the trade, Turner emerged as one of the teams most important pass rushers and has given the defense a much-needed edge off the edge. For a Vikings team always chasing pressure and disruption, the return on that gamble is beginning to show up in a hurry. [Read more 🡒]
Bears QB Trouble Just Got Worse After That Vikings Game
The Bears left their matchup with the Vikings already dealing with quarterback uncertainty, and the situation has only become messier heading into Week 3. Tyson Bagent is now in the NFL's concussion protocol, putting his status in doubt for Chicago's game against the Philadelphia Eagles, while Caleb Williams is also sidelined with a hamstring issue and is considered week to week.
If both young quarterbacks are unavailable, the next option could be Case Keenum, a veteran who has not been asked to carry a full-time starting role in quite some time. For a Bears team trying to steady itself early in the season, that kind of depth chart shuffle is hardly ideal, and it leaves one of the league's most watched quarterback situations hanging over the week. [Read more 🡒]