J.J. McCarthy’s first run as Minnesota’s starter didn’t go the way anyone in Vikings land wanted, but the fan base isn’t ready to close the book on him just yet.
That’s the clearest takeaway from a recent survey by The Athletic’s Alec Lewis. Of the 3,088 people who answered the question about Minnesota’s quarterback of the future, 54.4 percent still picked McCarthy. Kyler Murray drew 18.3 percent, while 27.3 percent said they’d rather the Vikings’ long-term answer be someone else entirely.
For a player whose stock took a hit after last season, that’s a notable show of patience. McCarthy missed his entire rookie year because of a knee injury, then got his first real shot as an NFL starter and struggled with the kind of inexperience that showed up almost every time he was on the field.
The quarterback picture got even more crowded when Minnesota brought in Murray in free agency. Kevin O’Connell says there will be a competition for the QB1 job this summer, but the assumption around the league is that Murray has the inside track.
The survey suggests Vikings fans are leaning that way for the short term, too. In the same poll, 69.2 percent of 3,087 respondents wanted Murray to start in Week 1, while only 29.3 percent wanted McCarthy under center to open the season.
That split points to a fan base that may be thinking in two timelines: Murray now, McCarthy later. In other words, plenty of Minnesota supporters seem open to the idea of McCarthy spending 2026 learning from the sideline before getting another chance in 2027.
Whether that matches the Vikings’ own plan is the real question. Are they hoping Murray wins the job, plays well and sticks around beyond 2026? Or is McCarthy still the long game, with the organization simply waiting for the right moment to hand him the keys again?
In Other News...
Vikings QB Battle Could Force A Stunning Roster Decision
The Vikings are prepared to let their quarterback competition stretch well into training camp, with the battle between Kyler Murray and J.J. McCarthy shaping up as one of the more closely watched decisions on the roster. Minnesota already has Carson Wentz lined up as the likely backup, which means the eventual call at the top of the depth chart could ripple beyond just who takes the first snap in September.
Tyler Forness pointed out that the team may not rush to settle the job, with the starter potentially not being named until the joint practices against the Ravens ahead of the Aug. 22 preseason game. That leaves a lot of room for the situation to get uncomfortable, because the loser of the competition may not just be moving down a spot, but could be staring at a far less secure role than either quarterback expected when camp opened. [Read more 🡒]
ESPN Just Singled Out The Vikings Biggest Edge In 2026
The Vikings have spent plenty of time building around their passing game, and ESPNs latest roster breakdown suggests that remains the clearest place where they can separate from the pack. The focus landed on Minnesotas wide receiver and pass-catching group as the teams biggest edge heading into 2026, a nod to just how much talent the Vikings can throw at defenses when the offense is clicking.
Justin Jefferson still sits at the center of it all, with Jordan Addison, Jauan Jennings and T.J. Hockenson giving Minnesota a mix of speed, versatility and matchup problems that few teams can match. The bigger question is how that group will be deployed with Kyler Murray in the mix, since a new quarterback can change the rhythm and shape of the passing game even when the personnel is already in place. [Read more 🡒]
Vikings Fans Already Have One Big Reason To Worry About Caleb Banks
Caleb Banks arrived in Minnesota with the kind of draft pedigree that usually comes with immediate expectations, and the Vikings were willing to spend a first-round pick on a defensive tackle they believe can become a real difference-maker. His college tape offered enough promise to justify that bet, especially after a strong 2024 season, but the bigger question has always been whether his talent can translate if he stays on the field.
For now, the concern is less about upside than availability. Banks has yet to take a snap for the Vikings because of a foot issue that has already interrupted his path before, and his limited 2025 season only sharpened the worry around his durability. For a team that passed on other needs to get him, the early months of his NFL career are already carrying more pressure than anyone in Minnesota probably wanted. [Read more 🡒]