The Vikings’ quarterback battle has already produced a new layer of intrigue, and Kyler Murray is right in the middle of it.
Since the spring, the assumption has been that the free-agency signing is the front-runner to eventually claim Minnesota’s starting job over 2024 first-round pick J.J. McCarthy. But ESPN’s Ben Solak raised a fresh warning flag on Tuesday, arguing that Murray may not be the cleanest match for Kevin O’Connell’s offense.
Long before O’Connell was sorting through this competition, he had success with quarterbacks such as Kirk Cousins and Sam Darnold. Solak pointed to those passers as players with “big frames, talented arms and a willingness to throw over the middle of the field.”
That’s where Murray comes in, and where the concern starts.
“It’s easy to see how Murray doesn’t fit in the O’Connell offense -- he doesn’t throw to the middle of the field well and doesn’t hang tall in the pocket,” Solak wrote. “Harder to see but perhaps more impactful is what he might do to the O’Connell offense, or in other words, what he might precipitate out of this system that has spread rapidly across the league.”
There has already been reporting that Murray entered the NFL’s summer break as “the favorite to win the starting job in training camp.” Still, O’Connell hinted in June that the race for the No. 1 role could stretch through multiple preseason games.
That matters because the exhibition slate won’t look anything like the regular season. The pressure and speed will be different once the games count, but the preseason should at least offer the first real clues about how Murray and McCarthy are being evaluated.
Solak’s bigger point was that O’Connell’s system is not frozen in place. He argued that the coach has adapted well enough to put quarterbacks in positions where they can survive and succeed, even when they are not perfect fits.
“Over his seasons as the Vikings' head coach,” Solak explained, “[O’Connell] has done well to put imperfect quarterbacks in strong positions to succeed. Last season, both J.J.
McCarthy and Carson Wentz attempted fewer passes to the intermediate middle than any other quarterback O’Connell coached in Minnesota or [while serving as the offensive coordinator for the Los Angeles Rams during the 2020 and 2021 seasons]. Wentz was under center on only 37.4% of his dropbacks, again O’Connell's lowest mark.
McCarthy threw more deep outbreaking routes than any O’Connell quarterback -- the sort of routes that O’Connell will need for Murray, as they're easier for him to see.”
Solak also made the case that Minnesota could unlock more with Murray than many people are expecting.
“The ceiling in Minnesota with Murray is far, far higher than we're inclined to estimate.”
For now, the real answer won’t come from speculation. Fans and everyone else will get a better read on the situation when the Vikings open the preseason against the New York Giants on Aug. 15.
In Other News...
Three Vikings Already Look Like Cutdown Week Casualties
With roster cutdown day looming on Aug. 30, the Vikings are starting to sort out the bottom of the 90-man roster, and a few names are already looking vulnerable. Max Brosmer, Taki Taimani and Dwight McGlothern all face uphill climbs as Minnesota trims to 53, with each player running into a different kind of squeeze as camp winds down.
Taimanis path has gotten tougher with the teams recent additions up front, while his own injury history only adds to the challenge. McGlothern has had a harder time carving out defensive snaps and now sits behind a crowded cornerback group, leaving little margin for error as the final decisions come into focus. [Read more 🡒]
Two Vikings Moves Just Changed Everything About This Offense
The Vikings spent the offseason making two moves that could reshape the way this offense looks in 2025. Adding another quarterback into the mix changes the conversation around how Minnesota wants to build around its passing game, while bringing in Jauan Jennings gives the team a sturdier layer of depth behind Justin Jefferson and Jordan Addison at receiver.
For a team already built around explosive playmakers, those additions raise the ceiling and the uncertainty at the same time. One analyst has already gone as far as calling Minnesotas offense one of the five most improved in the league, with top-10 scoring potential in play, but the real intrigue is how the quarterback picture and the new receiving options fit together once camp gets rolling. [Read more 🡒]