J.J. McCarthy’s Giants run is starting to look a lot like the kind of quarterback comeback story the NFL keeps handing us.
It’s become a familiar route: a highly drafted quarterback flops in his first stop, spends time bouncing around as a backup, lands in the right setup, and suddenly looks like a real starter. Geno Smith, Baker Mayfield, Sam Darnold and Daniel Jones have all taken that road in recent years. McCarthy may be next.
The Vikings made him the 10th overall pick in the 2024 draft after trading up for him, but the fit never clicked. Injuries played a part, and so did McCarthy’s own slow development as an NFL prospect. By the time it was obvious Kevin O’Connell wasn’t going to be the coach to turn McCarthy from a Michigan-style game manager - backed by defense and a strong run game - into a franchise quarterback, the Vikings had already moved on.
That move came on September 28, when Minnesota sent McCarthy to the Giants for a 2027 fifth-round pick. His stock had dropped that far.
He was buried as the Vikings’ third-string quarterback behind Kyler Murray and Carson Wentz, while the Giants were scrambling after Jaxson Dart went down with meniscus and MCL injuries in his left knee in Week 2 against the Los Angeles Rams. New York needed help behind Jameis Winston.
McCarthy needed a reset.
He got one in the most unexpected way possible during the Giants’ 34-27 Week 6 loss to the New Orleans Saints. Winston threw an interception with 12:28 left, and after New York had already built a 10-0 lead before falling behind 34-10, head coach John Harbaugh turned to McCarthy looking for a spark. What he got was much more than that.
In less than a full fourth quarter, McCarthy went 11 of 21 for 243 yards with one touchdown, one interception and a 90.0 passer rating. The big number wasn’t just the yardage - it was how he got it. McCarthy was pushing the ball downfield and hitting explosive throws right on the money, not just living off short completions and yards after the catch.
That outing earned him a spot in Secret Superstars for Week 6, and it also earned him the starting job for Week 7 against the Houston Texans.
The Texans were still a real test, even if DeMeco Ryans’ defense wasn’t the same unit it was in 2025, when it was maybe the NFL’s best. McCarthy answered with another clean, efficient performance in a 27-21 overtime win, completing 20 of 28 passes for 252 yards with no touchdowns, no interceptions and a 99.1 passer rating.
The Giants leaned on the run, but McCarthy kept showing the same thing: he can make the throws that matter. The route concepts around him also started to show up more clearly, and they’ve helped him play to his strengths at this stage of his career.
That’s where the new environment matters. O’Connell built concepts too, of course, but sometimes a quarterback just needs a different setting.
“Preparation,” McCarthy said after the Texans game, when asked how the tight-window throws have been such a big part of his recent performances. “I feel like preparation, over the years of playing football, you just refine the routine each and every week.
I feel like I’m in a really good spot right now, just Monday through Saturday and just being able to have that trust in these guys as early as now, since I’ve been here. I haven’t been here long, but I trust those guys every time the ball comes out of my hand.
I trust the offensive line up front. I trust the backs are going to get us in great situations when I do hit the checkdowns, but at the end of the day, it’s the players around me.”
Now the 4-2-1 Giants turn to a 2-6 Philadelphia Eagles team that has been a major disappointment, with Vic Fangio’s defense taking a surprising step back. Fangio addressed the Giants on Tuesday and singled out McCarthy, too.
“They’ve got a really good offense. They’ve got skill at the receiving position.
They did a nice job raiding the Ravens, not only for John [Harbaugh], but for [TE Isaiah] Likely and [FB Patrick] Ricard. They’ve got a lot of the Ravens-type offense that they had when Greg [Roman] was there, and they’ve intermixed Kansas City-type passing in there with Matt [Nagy].
They’ve got it going right now. They’ve got good wideouts, good tight ends, two good backs.
The quarterback has come in, in a short period of time, and really done a nice job, for them to get him for a [fifth-round] pick is a steal.”
If McCarthy keeps this up and helps push the NFC East-leading Giants to the playoffs for the first time since the 2022 season, the story around him changes fast. A career that looked stalled could suddenly have a new chapter.
In Other News...
Blake Brandel Is Forcing A Vikings Decision Up Front
Blake Brandel has quietly become one of the more important moving parts on the Vikings offensive line since Ryan Kellys retirement opened the door at center. Over the last four games, Brandel has settled in and given Minnesota exactly the kind of stability teams hope to find in a midseason transition, limiting pressure and sacks while drawing solid marks from Pro Football Focus.
Now the question is whether the Vikings treat that as a short-term answer or something more durable. Brandel is in the final year of his contract, and his play has at least made a case for keeping him around for the 2027 season, even as the front office may still prefer to chase a longer-term fix through the draft. [Read more 🡒]
Vikings Suddenly Have A Quarterback Problem They Cant Ignore
Kevin OConnells latest quarterback update only sharpened the uncertainty hanging over Minnesotas most important position. With Kyler Murray sidelined by a hamstring injury and listed week to week, Carson Wentz is set to get the start against the Bills, giving the Vikings a short-term answer while the bigger picture remains murky.
The larger issue for Minnesota is what comes next. Murray and Wentz are both on one-year contracts, and general manager Nolan Teasley is staring at a quarterback room without an obvious long-term solution, limited cap space and an uncertain 2024 draft class. For a team trying to stay competitive, the position could become the defining decision of the offseason. [Read more 🡒]
Vikings Suddenly Face A Quarterback Deadline Debate They Can't Ignore
Carson Wentz is set to start Monday night with Kyler Murray sidelined by a hamstring injury that is expected to keep him out week to week, and that alone has pushed quarterback depth back into the spotlight for Minnesota. With second-year player Max Brosmer currently the backup option, the Vikings are suddenly dealing with the kind of uncertainty that can make a front office rethink its plans before the trade deadline.
That has led to speculation about whether Minnesota will explore outside help at the position, especially with the market thinning and the need for a more experienced insurance policy becoming harder to ignore. The challenge is finding a deal that makes sense, and even then, the Vikings may have to navigate a reluctant seller if they decide to keep pressing for an answer before the deadline passes. [Read more 🡒]